Rainmaker Fundraising podcast

Sprinting to Success

0:00
21:08
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Most organizations treat a capital campaign like a marathon. Holly Kessler’s team treated theirs like a sprint, and they’re about to cross the finish line on a $1.1 million goal with a staff you could fit in a minivan.

Holly is the Director of Community Engagement at Forsyth Jail and Prison Ministries in Winston-Salem, North Carolina. The ministry has served the county jail and a state work-release prison camp since 1977, through chaplaincy, a pre-release Transition to Work program, and post-release support. Holly is an ordained pastor who spent more than a decade in child welfare fundraising before joining the ministry in early 2024. She didn’t go looking for prison ministry. It found her.

In this episode, Andrew and Holly unpack how a five-person full-time team bought a building, renovated it, and opened a reentry center in under a year. They also kept the annual fund on track the whole time. Holly shares the low-budget marketing that worked, the open house they threw for a building they didn’t own yet, and the one-word lesson that changed how they ask for major gifts: specific.

The Conversation

Act One: “I Can Raise Money for That”

When Holly interviewed for the job, she asked her future executive director a dangerous question (04:39): after nearly 47 years of steady work, what’s next? His answer was a dream to build a reentry center with transitional housing, meeting space, and a stronger post-release program. Holly’s reaction was immediate. “I can raise money for that.” Her logic was hard to argue with. These men are coming home one way or the other. The only question is whether they come home with support.

The board said yes in 2025, and things moved fast (06:37). The silent phase started that summer. The campaign went public at the ministry’s October breakfast, and the building was purchased the same month. They raised more than $600,000 by year-end. Renovations ran from December to April, and the First Lady of North Carolina, Anna Stein, spoke at the May ribbon cutting. A week later, the first two residents moved in. As of recording, they’re $28,000 from the goal.

Act Two: Two Asks, One Breakfast

Holly’s biggest surprise was the speed (07:57). The campaign budget was about one and a half times the ministry’s annual budget, and the team still hit its annual fund goal in both years. The less pleasant surprise: a few donors who were expected to step up didn’t. Andrew can relate (08:57). In one of his own campaigns, a board member proudly pulled out a credit card and gave $50. Sometimes that’s just how it goes.

So how do you ask for capital and annual dollars without one eating the other (09:43)? Their consultant was blunt. Everyone already knew about the project, so not mentioning it at the breakfast would be weird. Some people would shift their annual gift, and the team would have to live with that. The fix was clarity. They used separate pledge cards, presented the campaign first and the annual fund second, and the executive director closed by saying, in effect, “We need your annual gifts too.” Lots of people gave to both.

Act Three: The Good-Enough Playbook

Holly’s first keeper is a little heretical (11:35). They wrote a strong case statement and professionally printed one page. Everything else, including the videos, was made in-house. A slick video gets watched once, she says, so “good enough” really is good enough.

The second keeper came from their realtor (12:40). He convinced the seller to let the ministry host an open house before closing. Big artist renderings showed visitors what the empty rooms would become, and the footage later helped breakfast guests who missed it see the same vision. The third: they applied for every capital grant they could find (13:25). They won more than half, several from brand-new funders. That matters in a city like Winston-Salem, where everyone knows who has deep pockets and everyone is already knocking on their doors (14:07).

And what would they never do again (15:02)? Holly thought hard and came up with exactly one thing: the open house caterer. Way too much food, way too much money. They switched caterers for the ribbon cutting. Lesson learned.

Act Four: Name the Number

The board went first and gave more than 10% of the goal together, with every member participating (17:39). That gave the team a strong number to announce on launch day. From there, they used donor history and CRM screening to find prospects for five- and six-figure gifts, then met each one for a tour and a conversation (18:35).

Here’s the lesson Holly wants every fundraiser to hear (18:59). When they made a specific ask, donors almost always met it. When they asked vaguely, they heard “We’ll think about it, we’ll pray about it.” Then they never heard anything again. People with that kind of capacity are used to being asked for specific amounts. Don’t be shy.

She closes with the story that sums it all up (20:14). A board member brought her neighbors to the open house. Their son had been incarcerated on drug-related charges and later died from his addiction. “If our son had had this type of resource when he got out of prison, he might still be here today,” they told Holly. A space in the center now carries his name. At the ribbon cutting, his mother stood in front of the sign with tears streaming down her face.

The Big Ideas

Don’t let fear of cannibalization stop you. Ask for both capital and annual gifts, and make the difference crystal clear with separate pledge cards and an explicit “we need both.” A few donors will shift their gift. Most won’t.

Good enough is good enough. One strong case statement and one polished piece go a long way. Your donors care about the vision more than the production value.

Let people walk through the dream. An open house with renderings, even before you own the building, turns an abstract plan into something donors can see and feel.

Look past the usual deep pockets. Apply for every capital grant you can find. Institutional funders you’ve never approached may be the ones who say yes.

Name the number. Specific asks get met. Vague asks get prayed about and forgotten.

Quotable

“These men are coming back into our community one way or the other. So they can come back with our support or not.”

“A real slick professional video is really pretty to look at. They’re gonna look at it once and they’re gonna move on.”

“People who have that kind of means are used to very specific asks.”

“If our son had had this type of resource when he got out of prison, he might still be here today.”

Connect with Holly

Website: fjpm.org

Holly’s contact information is on the ministry’s leadership page, along with details on its chaplaincy, Transition to Work, and post-release programs.

Rainmaking: The Fundraiser’s Guide to High-Impact Offers

Your fundraising offer, or the reason you give donors to support you, must answer seven key questions to effectively motivate a gift. Most nonprofits get this wrong. In fact, many simply fall back on the most generic offer possible, “you can help provide hope.”

But generic hope doesn’t get the job done.

And if your mission is critical, you need offers that motivate donors to act and to make the most generous contributions possible.

That’s why I wrote Rainmaking: The Fundraiser’s Guide to High-Impact Offers.

This book distills the offer development training that I’ve guided hundreds of nonprofits through over the last 25 years and helps you successfully answer the Seven Questions for your organization.

The book is priced specifically for you, the nonprofit fundraiser or leader who needs to get things done effectively, without breaking the bank. Print copies are available for $9.99, and the Kindle version is only $4.99.

If you buy the book, shoot me an email and I’ll send you a FREE Toolkit to help you act on everything in the book. It’s a $24.99 value that you get completely free!



Get full access to The Rainmaker Fundraising Newsletter at rainmakerfundraising.substack.com/subscribe

More episodes from "Rainmaker Fundraising"