Rainmaker Fundraising podcast

From Stuck to Story

0:00
26:41
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Every Friday, a man walked into a nonprofit that serves teenagers struggling with addiction and left a $10 bill at the front desk. Nobody thought much of it. Then someone got curious and asked why. The answer took about ten seconds to tell, and it will stay with you a lot longer than that.

That story is the whole thesis of this episode. The stories that move donors are rarely big, loud, or made for television. They’re small, specific, and true.

Katie Whitehorn is senior copy director at Historic, part of the Masterworks family of brands, and author of From Stuck to Story, a bestseller in multiple categories. She didn’t learn storytelling in a conference room or a classroom. She started in southern Iraq in 2003, went on to work in seven countries across four continents, then spent seven years on an in-house marketing team reading and writing thousands of donor stories. Her book distills all of that into a four-ingredient framework for maxed-out nonprofit communicators who know they need better stories and don’t know where to start.

Andrew and Katie get into the brain science of why stories beat statistics, how to tell hard stories without exploiting anyone, why your story doesn’t need a happy ending, and where the line sits between moving donors and manipulating them. And yes, you’ll find out what the $10 bill was for.

The Conversation

Act One: One Face Beats a Million

Katie’s first big lesson came in southern Iraq in 2003, when the news was all chaos and suffering (03:10). On the ground she met mothers, fathers, and aunts who wanted what parents everywhere want: to get their kids to school safely and give them a future. Her takeaway has shaped everything since. We have more in common than we have differences, and story is how a donor steps into someone else’s shoes. Then Andrew asks the question every CMO eventually asks: where’s our brand in all this? (05:01) Katie’s answer is that the brand shows up in how you tell the story. If you value human dignity, show dignity. The organization enters as the helper, and the donor enters as the partner. But the story always stays with one person, because “you can’t picture groups.” Andrew remembers World Vision colleagues making the same point years ago (07:29): talk about millions of hungry children and people tune out. Talk about one child and the magic happens.

Act Two: Telling the Hard Stories

What about stories you can’t tell in full, like trafficking or domestic violence (09:30)? Katie’s first move is practical. Change the details to protect the person, then tell your readers you did. Donors understand the risks, and the disclosure makes them feel trusted with something sensitive. Her second move is more powerful: focus on small moments. Enter The Secret Life of Walter Mitty (11:11), a movie Andrew admits he hasn’t seen (consider this his homework). Walter fights sharks and longboards down a mountain ahead of an erupting volcano. But the heart of the film is a phone call in a Papa John’s about straws. Small, mundane moments are where the truth lives. For a child at risk of trafficking, that might be the hours alone while both parents work, or the three-mile walk to clean water.

Act Three: Your Brain on Story

Does every story need a happy ending (13:41)? No, Katie says, but it always needs hope. She points to the Zeigarnik effect: our brains fixate on unfinished business, which is why cliffhangers work. Stop the story at its climax and the donor gets to help write the ending. That isn’t dishonest, because there’s always one more kid who needs a tutor and one more family who needs a food box. Why stories over statistics (17:35)? Start telling a story in any room and it goes quiet. Our brains treat story as survival information. And borrowing from Jeff Brooks, Katie explains that we decide emotionally first, in nanoseconds, then let logic build the case (18:33). Your “very logical” donors included. So where’s the line between moving people and manipulating them (19:25)? Katie pulls out her heavily tabbed copy of Bobette Buster’s Do Story. Pander to someone’s emotions and they’ll resent it. Unlatch their heart and they’ll be grateful. The best stories confirm who donors already believe they are: generous, caring, compassionate people.

Act Four: The Recipe and the $10 Bill

Katie lays out her four ingredients (21:59): a single character, a clear conflict with real stakes, a concrete sensory detail that gives the reader something to hold, and an emotional connection built on universal experiences like parenthood. Andrew, who “technically lied” about being down to his last question, asks how frontline staff should gather all that (23:47). Her answer is refreshingly low-tech. Voice memos, sticky notes, interview scribbles, program reports. Get all the raw material, sort it into the four ingredients, and the book’s workbook scaffolds the draft. Then Andrew puts her on the spot: tell us a story (24:58). She tells one she heard from Julia Campbell on the first episode of We Are For Good. The man with the $10 bill had a son who got caught up in drugs in high school and overdosed. The ten dollars was his son’s weekly allowance. He couldn’t put it in his own child’s hand anymore, so he gave it to help someone else’s. “Those stories are everywhere,” Katie says, “and it just takes a little bit of curiosity to draw them out.”

The Big Ideas

1. Tell the story of one, not millions. The brain can’t hold a crowd. It can hold a face, a smile, a kid you want to hug. Your organization still belongs in the story, as the helper, with the donor as the partner.

2. The small moment is the story. Skip the shark fight and find the Papa John’s. A mundane, concrete moment often reveals more truth than a dramatic one, and it’s the safest way to tell sensitive stories with dignity.

3. Leave the loop open, but never leave out hope. An unresolved story gives donors a role in the ending. The work is never finished, so ending at the climax isn’t a trick. It’s an honest invitation.

4. Emotion decides. Logic signs the paperwork. Even your most analytical donors feel first and justify second. Statistics support a decision. Stories make it.

5. Curiosity is a story-collection strategy. The best story in your building might be a quiet $10 gift nobody has asked about. Capture raw material any way you can, then sort it into character, conflict, concrete detail, and emotional connection.

Quotable

“You can’t picture groups, you can’t relate to groups. You want to always focus on the individual.”

“Story moments don’t have to be big and dramatic.”

“We don’t want to manipulate people, but we do want to move them.”

“Those stories are everywhere, and it just takes a little bit of curiosity to draw them out.”

Connect with Katie

Grab From Stuck to Story on Amazon or at fromstucktostory.com. Find Katie at katiewhitehorn.com, and connect with her on LinkedIn, where she’s very active and always up for a good conversation about story.

This episode of the Rainmaker Fundraising podcast is brought to you by Andrew’s newest book, Rainmaking: The Fundraiser’s Guide to High-Impact Offers.

The difference between great fundraising messages and average fundraising messages is the offer. Generic offers like “give hope” and “help us reach our goal” do nothing to inspire donors to give. That’s why you need to include a high impact offer in every fundraising message you send out. Andrew’s new book walks you through the exact framework you need to create your very own high impact offers. Andrew has used this very approach to raise more than $1 Billion for nonprofits throughout his career. You can get it for just $9.99 (paperback), or just $4.99 (Kindle).



Get full access to The Rainmaker Fundraising Newsletter at rainmakerfundraising.substack.com/subscribe

More episodes from "Rainmaker Fundraising"