Rainmaker Fundraising podcast

Fired for Doubling Revenue

0:00
32:00
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

John Lepp’s agency recently doubled a client’s direct mail revenue. Then the client fired them, because the marketing team didn’t like how the appeal looked.

That story captures the gap between what looks good and what actually raises money, and John has spent nearly 30 years on the right side of it. In this episode, the co-founder of Agents of Good explains why there’s no room for being clever in fundraising, why your appeal shouldn’t read like a doctoral thesis, why he deliberately stamped over half a client’s logo, and why AI is basically a frying pan. You’ll also hear about a mother-in-law who sends $100 without reading the letter, and a blunt bit of career advice for anyone who finds empathy hard: go work at a bank.

Meet John Lepp

John is co-founder and partner at Agents of Good, the Canadian fundraising and communications agency he launched with Jen Love in 2009. He cut his teeth in advertising, including a stint at a pharmaceutical agency where he learned to turn complex ideas into simple pictures. He then worked as a freelance designer and with agencies across Canada and internationally.

Today he works with organizations around the world on annual and individual giving. He’s the author of Creative Deviations and a regular on conference stages, where he is famous for one thing above all: giving fundraisers permission to be human.

The conversation

Your donors are not grading your vocabulary

John’s old boss had a rule: there’s no room for being clever in fundraising. John has honored it ever since. Clever forces donors to do cognitive work, and as he puts it, our brains are inherently lazy. Nobody wants to decode your appeal.

When clients send him letters to review, he runs a readability score first. Some come back at a grade-16 reading level. His verdict is gentle but devastating: that’s not cleverness, that’s not knowing how to talk plainly. And if your organization preaches inclusion, writing at a graduate-school level (or letting your designer reverse out tiny type) quietly undercuts everything you claim to stand for.

The agency that never launched

Andrew noticed that Agents of Good opened its doors in 2009, smack in the middle of a global financial meltdown. John’s answer: there was no launch. A few anonymous promo videos on Twitter were enough to send an Australian agency scrambling to find out who these new competitors were. Meanwhile, John and Jen simply talked to the people they already worked with, and clients followed.

The lesson he took from it applies to every charity too. Nobody cares about your anniversary, your logo colors, or your brand positioning statement. They want to know what you need from them, and whether they want to do it.

Stop living in checkbox world

Too many charities run on autopilot: the calendar says spring appeal, so out goes a spring appeal, with silence in between. John’s alternative is a Donor Experience System. It means consistent emotion across every touch, values that echo the donor’s values, decision-science nudges that make giving easy, and above all, identity reinforcement.

Drawing on Dr. Jen Shang’s work on self-identity, John argues that giving is an expression of who we are. So hold up a mirror: tell the donor you see them as the compassionate person they are. Most charities never do. His model is Disney, where every touchpoint from the parking lot to the washrooms is built around the story.

“If it’s hard for you, go work at a bank”

What if you’re a tiny shop with no Disney budget? John’s answer is refreshingly simple. Make the ask abundantly clear. Sound like a group of humans who care. Make the action easy. Then actually, genuinely care about the person you’re writing to. That’s it.

And if being a thoughtful, empathetic human feels hard, this might not be your sector. Andrew agreed and pushed on a harder problem: fundraisers who want to experiment but fear that one failed test takes food out of someone’s mouth. John’s wish is that more bosses and board members would sit in on these conversations at industry conferences and inside nonprofit offices everywhere, instead of saying no to ideas they have no experience judging.

Why messy wins

Paper clips. Crooked stamps. A stamp that deliberately covers half the logo. John knows these sound trivial, and that’s exactly the point. When a client objected to the covered logo, he told them their reaction was the reason he did it: a donor will pause and wonder why, and that pause is the hook that gets them to pay attention.

“A printing press doesn’t have thumbs” (John’s pithy line). Small imperfections signal that a human, misguided as they might be, put this together for another human. But nothing is accidental. John tells his designers that every box on the page needs a reason to be there.

Fired for doubling the revenue

Here’s the story that made Andrew’s jaw drop. John’s agency was recently let go by a client after doubling revenue on a mail appeal, because the marketing team and development director didn’t like how the organization looked.

John wrote Creative Deviations largely for marketing and comms people, and he’s careful not to blame them. But his ask of clients is simple: flag factual errors, and bring test results to anything else. His job isn’t to please you or your boss. His brief is the donor.

AI is a frying pan

On AI, John reaches for the kitchen. A $25 nonstick pan or a fancy All-Clad, it doesn’t matter: if you don’t know how to make an omelet, the pan won’t do it for you. He apologized for the analogy. Andrew thought it was perfect.

The tougher part: John knows of agencies training bots on top writers’ copy so they no longer need to hire them, and consultants telling his own clients to do the same. He connects it to his mother-in-law, who admits she can’t read appeal letters without crying, so she just sends $100. The last thing John will do is take advantage of that kindness. Use AI as a tool, he says. But not as a replacement for real human interaction. This is a loving, emotional craft, and it needs humans in it.

Take it back to your desk tomorrow

* Score your next appeal before it mails. Run a readability check. If it reads at a college level or above, rewrite it the way you’d say it across a kitchen table.

* Hold up a mirror. Add one line that tells the donor who they are: compassionate, generous, the kind of person who shows up for kids. Then thread it through every piece.

* Fill the silence between appeals. Map what a donor hears from you between asks. If the answer is nothing, you’re living in checkbox world.

* Make one intentional imperfection. A paper clip, a stamp on an angle, a handwritten note. Know exactly why it’s there.

* Change the approval conversation. Ask reviewers to flag factual errors, and to bring test results for everything else. “I don’t like it” is not a brief.

* Think of AI like a pan, not a chef. It’s only as good as what you put in it. A great meal is not created by the pan it’s cooked in. It’s created by the chef. It’s assembled in the pan. AI functions the same way.

Lines you don’t want to miss

“There’s no room for being clever in fundraising.”

“If you’re writing to a grade sixteen level, you are not being inclusive.”

“Our donors don’t like direct mail? Well, you’re doing it as badly as you possibly can.”

“A printing press doesn’t have thumbs.”

“If it’s hard for you to be a thoughtful, caring, empathetic human, go work at a bank.”

“My job isn’t to figure out what you or your boss likes. My job is to do something the donor can understand, feel connected to, and give to very easily.”

“It doesn’t matter what kind of pan you have. If you don’t know how to make the omelet, the pan’s not gonna do it for you.”

Rainmaking: The Fundraiser’s Guide to High-Impact Offers

Get the book today that is helping nonprofit organizations around the world create better, more compelling fundraising offers and raise more money for their causes.

The print version is just $9.99, and the Kindle version is only $4.99. Send me an email with proof of purchase and I’ll send you an expanded Tool…



Get full access to The Rainmaker Fundraising Newsletter at rainmakerfundraising.substack.com/subscribe

More episodes from "Rainmaker Fundraising"