
In October Paul Miller published an article called “UMC 2025: The Death Tsunami Was a Picnic”. I had never met Paul, and I was a little mad that I didn’t know who he was, because the piece is very high quality. So I asked him on. He also built a set of infographics for our conversation, which you can see in the video. What follows is my write-up of that conversation.
In 2011 Lovett Weems of the Lewis Center for Church Leadership gave the United Methodist Church a name for what was coming: the “death tsunami.” The boomers who lead and fill these churches are roughly the same age. They are going to die in roughly the same period, and the mainline is not at replacement rate. Weems said that while he was still inside the UMC, before disaffiliation season ever started.
Then disaffiliation came, and it made things worse. Surprise, surprise. Now that the 2025 data sets are out on umdata.org, Paul went through all of them. His conclusion, and mine, is that the UMC is not in a death spiral. It is in a free fall. That will surprise no one who left.
I had two reasons for wanting to talk with him. The Global Methodist Church is not reporting numbers like this right now, and I wanted to ask what kind of numbers are actually worth reporting. I also think there is a natural interest in data for anyone who believes faith bears fruit that can be observed. Jesus said it could.
“Make a tree good and its fruit will be good, or make a tree bad and its fruit will be bad, for a tree is known by its fruit.” — Matthew 12:33 (BSB)
You can’t be a slave to the numbers. But the numbers should interest you.
Puppies and Sunshine
When I asked Paul how he was, he said “puppies and sunshine,” which is the answer he gives everybody. We figured out before we hit record that we’re almost exactly the same age. He has listened to my channel for years, and he went through the same move into the GMC that I did.
Paul is full-time clergy, and he also teaches humanities at Veritas Academy, a classical Christian school in Leola, Pennsylvania. He has been there six years, mostly teaching literature and history, with some theology. His children attend too. His explanation for all that work: if he doesn’t stay busy, he gets into trouble. During COVID he taught himself to install a doorknob.
He did not grow up in church. In his own words, he followed a pretty girl into a Bible study at Calvary Chapel of Philadelphia, and later found out she was the pastor’s daughter. The next Sunday he was in her father’s church, Bethesda United Methodist in Philadelphia, parking under I-95 when it rained. They have been married since 2007 and have four children.
Before that, he couldn’t tell you the difference between the Charlie Brown Christmas special and Roman Catholicism. His parents were not even Christmas-and-Easter people. About five or six weeks in, after church, he felt it: a warming in the chest, and the sense that he couldn’t turn away from this now.
He came to ministry by way of banking and finance, which explains his affinity for numbers. The crash of 2007 to 2009 knocked him around, and his wife told him he was studying Scripture all the time anyway, so why not get a degree in it. He went to Lancaster Bible College and was first appointed in 2014. He was United Methodist clergy for twelve years.
Hopeland and the Eastern Pennsylvania Lawsuit
Paul’s church, Hopeland, was one of the churches in the Eastern Pennsylvania lawsuit (I published my conversation with Joe DiPaolo about that fight the morning Paul and I spoke). The suit started with 41 churches in 2022 and grew to 50. The docket says 51 because one church goes by two names. Paul was in court every single day of the trial.
What broke the camel’s back for Hopeland was the conference’s silence. In 2022, after General Conference was delayed a third time, the Eastern Pennsylvania Conference said it would publish its disaffiliation process before the end of May. May passed. June passed. July passed. Paul had been telling his people the information was coming. When the church finally voted, the vote was 103 to 6 to leave. Some of the more progressive members voted to go too. They weren’t crazy about the direction, but they liked the conference even less.
For Hopeland, Paul said, it was never really about the presenting issue. It was about trust. The church had been through a run of pastors, and every new appointment was a battle. That distrust predated him by years.
At the end of July, Hopeland sent the conference a letter terminating the relationship. The conference said they weren’t allowed to do that, and Hopeland said, “Thank you for your opinion.” Just before we spoke, Bishop Cynthia Moore-Koikoi sent a letter naming Hopeland and two other churches and moving toward exigent circumstances to reclaim the property. Paul couldn’t say much more than that, and I asked people to pray for him and his church.
I said what I have seen around the country: these conferences don’t seem much concerned with arguing the merits. They hire a big firm and spend whatever it takes to exhaust the other side, and it has worked nearly everywhere except Texas and perhaps Alabama. The bishops have declared the season of church exits over. Paul called that wish-casting. It reminded me of George W. Bush on the aircraft carrier.
Cotton Candy and Swiss Cheese
My first question was whether everything UMData collects is worth collecting. Paul’s answer was that all information tells you something, even inaccurate information, because it tells you about the methods and sometimes the motive behind them.
He gave the UMC real credit here. They didn’t have to release these numbers, because the numbers don’t look good, and they released them anyway. That deserves credit for transparency. The United States data is decent, with some flaws. The international data, he said, has the consistency of cotton candy or Swiss cheese.
2025 is the first year the overseas numbers have really been posted, and Paul can see why the church was hesitant: in many places the numbers simply don’t exist. Some conferences on other continents didn’t report anything for a decade, not even a journal. Only 3 of the 32 African conferences he could find reported every single year. That’s not even 10%.
That’s a troubling thing, because the GMC is setting its reporting norms right now. I put forward petitions to General Conference requiring a certain level of reporting from every annual conference, and they were shut down quickly as America-centric. My knee-jerk reaction was to call that racist, as if being Anglo is what makes reporting possible. The best argument I heard against my petitions was that many of these churches are in persecuted areas, and reporting could make them easier targets.
Paul’s suggestion was to let people give an estimate along with a confidence level when exact numbers aren’t possible. He also thinks the UMC gathered far too much data, leaned on its statistics to lead, and didn’t know what to do with them. The GMC could ask a fraction of the questions, get more out of them, and get more buy-in, because it would take a pastor maybe ten minutes.
891 a Day
Then we went through Paul’s infographics. The first covers members and congregations. From the end of 2015 to the end of 2025, professing members fell 46% and congregations fell from 31,631 to 20,148. Something a lot of people don’t know: the United Methodist Church has been in decline since its very first year. There was never a point at which it grew. For a long time the decline was meager. Now it is accelerating.
Paul pointed to 2016, the General Conference that produced the Commission on a Way Forward. Before that, the yearly losses ran around 0.8% to 1.6%. In 2017 the loss hit 2% for the first time in his records, and it has stayed at 2% or worse every year since. Ultimately, the church went from about 7 million members in 2015 to 3.8 million.
The next slide breaks it down by day: an average of 891 professing members lost every day for ten years. Paul’s point in p…
Get full access to PlainSpoken at plainspokenpod.substack.com/subscribe
D'autres épisodes de "PlainSpoken"



Ne ratez aucun épisode de “PlainSpoken” et abonnez-vous gratuitement à ce podcast dans l'application GetPodcast.








