The Catholic Thing podcast

Pathways to Eucharistic Devotion

0:00
8:04
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds
By Michael Pakaluk
But first a note from Robert Royal: Professor Pakaluk takes a careful - and much-needed - look today at a piece of bad news about low levels of belief about the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist among Catholics. Things may not be as bad as a recent survey suggested. But Vatican II said the Eucharist is the "source and summit" of Christian life. So if Catholics are wavering about that teaching, it may mean things are very precarious indeed. We now have to pursue all available means - teaching, preaching, devotions - to restore that understanding. That's one of our central commitments here at TCT. If that's important to you, too, please help.
Now for today's column...
A recent study reports, once again, that only about three in ten American Catholics believe in the Real Presence. Suppose someone asks you the question the study posed: "Do you believe that when the priest consecrates the host during Mass: (1) the bread and wine are transformed, actually becoming the body and blood of Christ, or do you believe (2) the bread and wine are symbols of his body and blood, or (3) are you not sure what happens?"
You should reply that it's a deeply confused question. Any educated Catholic ought to say that he doesn't quite know how to answer it.
Answer (1), as ordinary English would understand it, is false. It's not true that the bread and wine are "transformed." The substance of the bread and the substance of the wine are changed, indeed, but the accidents (appearances) remain the same. Since the bread and the wine just are the substances together with their accidents, they are not transformed.
Even if (1) were revised accordingly, it would still be misleading, because it is incomplete. The substance of the bread is changed into the body of Christ, yes; but the whole Christ is present in the consecrated bread, His "body, blood, soul, and divinity," and so too in the consecrated wine.
Christ is living, not dead. Therefore, He must have a soul. He is both God and man. Therefore, He must possess divinity. As the question is written, it invites us to picture the bread becoming the body, and the wine the blood, and nothing more, which is to picture Christ as a corpse, because only when He was lying in the tomb was His body separated from His blood and from His soul.
The question leaves out exactly what makes Eucharistic devotion the love of a divine person.
Given these difficulties, a thoughtful person might prefer (2), because it is true that "when" the priest consecrates the host, just as "before" he does so, the bread and wine are symbols of Christ's body and blood (that is, they stand for them). Answer (2), then, looks more truthful than (1). Note that answer (2) does not concern what happens after or by the consecration. In particular, it does not affirm that the bread and wine remain unchanged, or that they are "merely" symbols. A sacrament does what it symbolizes: of course they are symbols.
Anyone, then, who thought carefully about (1) and (2) might feel constrained to endorse (3) as a failsafe, with "I'm not sure what happens" coming to mean "I'm not sure I can endorse either of the two alternatives you've given me." After all, a faithful Catholic is free to endorse (3) if he means by it, "I'm not sure of the mechanism or means by which it happens," which is to say, "It's a mystery."
Are you really "sure what happens" at the moment of consecration?

Should we judge it a worthwhile goal that everyone who checks off a box identifying himself as "Catholic" should also respond (1) to the question above? I don't see that it is. Is it a great failure if someone does not? The greater failure is that most such Catholics are seldom at Mass. And yet it is the checkbox that is decried when it is reported that only one-third of Catholics believe in the Real Presence.
The goal seems stranger still when the question appears in a survey series that also asks, "Do you agree or disagree that it is sometimes okay for a marr...

More episodes from "The Catholic Thing"