Practical(ly) Pastoring podcast

Second Chances & Second Chairs

0:00
1:03:03
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

What do you do when you realize you may have turned down the right church because you did the math wrong? And what if everyone around you thinks you should become a lead pastor, but you are perfectly happy being the number two?

This week Andrew, Tim, Del, and Jeff tackle two questions about calling, self-awareness, and being willing to admit, “Maybe I was wrong.”

First, a pastor reconnects with a church he seriously considered about a year and a half ago. The ministry fit was strong, the leadership structure made sense, and both sides wanted the relationship to work. The deal-breaker was compensation.

Except now he has realized he misunderstood how clergy housing allowance affected the numbers, and the salary he turned down would actually have worked just fine for his family.

Should he swallow his embarrassment and call them back?

The guys talk about why compensation is a legitimate part of ministry discernment, why a financial mistake is not a character flaw, how to reopen the conversation without making things awkward, and why humility may actually strengthen the relationship rather than hurt it.

Then the conversation turns to a youth pastor with more than 20 years of experience who keeps being told he should become a lead pastor.

The problem?

He does not want to.

He calls himself Scottie Pippen, not Michael Jordan. He loves supporting a lead pastor, developing people, leading from the second chair, and helping the whole team succeed. He has even served as the primary leader during a pastoral transition and came away more convinced than ever that he did not want the first chair.

So is he resisting God, or simply understanding how God has gifted him?

The guys discuss the difference between leadership ability and lead-pastor calling, why ministry is not a corporate ladder, the enormous value of secure second-chair leaders, how much weight to give the perspective of your spouse and mentors, and whether lack of desire is always evidence of fear.

Sometimes humility means being willing to step up.

Sometimes humility means being content not to.

Join the Practically Pastoring Facebook Community for conversations about calling, staffing, church searches, preaching, leadership, conflict, and all the other things that rarely fit neatly into a seminary syllabus.

Don’t do ministry alone.

SPONSORS

The Practical(ly) Pastoring Conference is coming February 15–17, 2027.

Thanks also to our friends at Church Merch for supporting Practically Pastoring. For shirts, mugs, banners, tumblers, event gear, promotional products, and more, visit promotionsguy.com/churchmerch.

Church Merch, merch for your church.

More episodes from "Practical(ly) Pastoring"