Hot Take Books podcast

Montclair: Romantasy, Hold the Spice

0:00
50:05
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Montclair by Anderson W. Frost | Thorns, Feathers, and Bones Saga

Anderson W. Frost doesn't hold your hand, he puts you in the cart and sends you flying down the mountain. Montclair, his 300-page side-quest novella, is the whole ride: new town, new cast, and a mystery you piece together click by click. The boys keep the first 15 minutes spoiler-free with scores and verdict up front, so you can sample before committing. Then the wall drops and the theories fly: who Sabine's business partner really is, what Winifred is becoming, and a gods hierarchy the boys spend a solid ten minutes trying to map. Ryan wasn't sold on the trust at the story's core; Rich bought it completely β€” and admits the guy who dunks on 1,200-page books might not be a novella guy either. Rich's standing note for Frost: maybe the best new action writer in the game, and he won't write enough action. The one-star review segment died this week β€” they couldn't find a single one. Get on the bandwagon now. πŸ“–

Overall: 7.5 out of 10 (Rich 7.3 / Ryan 7.7)Verdict: Buy

Book: Montclair by Anderson W. Frost
Series: Thorns, Feathers, and Bones Saga (novella)

  • [00:00] β€” Cold open: back from the late-summer break, crushing the books
  • [01:11] β€” Intro + episode framing (spoiler-free): book mail from Anderson W. Frost, what Montclair is
  • [02:43] β€” Who should read this book: the romantasy on-ramp, Frost's gothic-romance experiment, and the no-spice reassurance
  • [07:35] β€” Overall impressions: Frost doesn't hold your hand, and Rich's confession β€” he might not be a novella guy
  • [10:34] β€” Scores + Verdict (spoiler-free, up front): Rich 7.3 / Ryan 7.7 β€” overall 7.5, Buy
  • [11:19] β€” Socials plug + 🚨 spoiler warning β€” spoilers start
  • [12:05] β€” Rich's hot take: you don't need book one first β€” and romance readers could even start here
  • [15:52] β€” Worldbuilding & Lore: essence gods vs mythology gods, what Winifred is turning into, and the daylight debate ("maybe he's a sparker")
  • [30:22] β€” Characters: the Damien–Sabine trust debate (Ryan not sold, Rich bought it), the read-it-after-book-two theory, and Rich's date-with-a-new-book problem
  • [37:50] β€” Story: the Rift Massacre drop, the ceremony logic, Mortis, and the squad heading north to Hildeheim
  • [44:48] β€” Rich's #1 feedback for Frost: the best new action writer who won't write enough action
  • [46:06] β€” One-star reviews: none to be found
  • [49:11] β€” Wrap-up


TikTok: @hottakebks

Instagram: @hottakebooks

More episodes from "Hot Take Books"