
0:00
58:12
Demon in White by Christopher Ruocchio | Sun Eater, Book 3 | Sci-Fi
Everyone says get through book three and you're in. The boys got through book three. Ryan is still annoyed he had to commit to three long-ass books to find out, and Rich isn't, he fell in love with the whole series right here. The first 15 minutes are spoiler-free with the read-or-skip call, so you can sample before the spoilers hit. The boys agree on the one thing that isn't working: the fake-biography narration, where Hadrian narrates Hadrian winking at Hadrian. π
Overall: 7.2 out of 10 (Rich 7.3 / Ryan 7.0)
Verdict: Buy
Shownotes!
- [00:00] β Cold open: football's back, and Rich had to beg for a Sunday recording
- [01:07] β Intro + episode framing (spoiler-free): book three of Sun Eater, and is it Ruocchio or Rocchio?
- [01:29] β The show's history with the series: Empire of Silence was an early episode, Howling Dark came this year, and the boys' relationship with book one is "controversial"
- [02:23] β Ryan's gripe: three long-ass books before a series gets good, and the salty TikTok comments about calling it slow
- [02:53] β Who this episode is for: the should-I-keep-going listener
- [03:33] β Objective versus subjective β Rich showed up sunburnt and fell in love with the series in this book
- [03:52] β Ryan spoiler-free: loves the worldbuilding, can't bring himself to care about the characters
- [05:09] β Two kinds of sci-fi, and the cosmic horror turn this book takes
- [07:06] β Hadrian has grown up, and what that does to the book-one and book-two complaints
- [10:40] β Socials plug + π¨ spoiler warning β spoilers start
- [11:27] β Worldbuilding & Lore (8 each): what the Quiet actually are
- [12:07] β Ryan's knock: a mile wide and an inch deep
- [12:39] β Time as a flat plane, and why Hadrian dodges bullets by moving sideways through probability
- [14:28] β The Watchers, and what the Cielcin are really looking for
- [15:34] β Big Dick Bill, Earth's savior, and why the Quiet helped him
- [16:03] β Full Lovecraft: beings too vast to notice us
- [17:08] β The Emperor and the politics β Rich talks himself into a 12 and asks if they can cut it
- [17:25] β Ryan's complaint: the ExaltedβCielcin alliance happened off page
- [19:12] β Characters (Rich 7 / Ryan 6): the time jumps and development that lands between books
- [24:37] β Prince Alexander, and a tangent on why a seven is a good score
- [27:42] β Hadrian correcting Alexander's bigotry, and whether the boys were ever sold on that turn
- [30:41] β The kneel, the strike, and Alexander hurting his own hand
- [31:33] β Valka: the marriage argument, her society's view of it, and Rich going Team Celine
- [33:14] β Tor Gibson is back, and Ryan is 99% sure he wasn't supposed to be
- [34:21] β Lorian Aristides fills the Switch-shaped hole, and Rich flags him as a future turncoat
- [35:46] β Bassander Lin flips: the soldier becomes an acolyte of the Half-Mortal
- [37:04] β Story (7): the fake-biography format still isn't working
- [38:32] β Ryan: this is five mini books in one, and yes, we know he blew up the sun
- [39:54] β Hadrian narrating Hadrian winking at Hadrian β "I'm lost"
- [41:38] β What did work: better pacing, the assassination attempt, the Coliseum, and catching a highmatter blade on the arm from old Thousand Eyes
- [44:27] β Getting lost in the action, and why Pierce Brown and Sanderson do it better
- [46:24] β Gritty military moments and Polino telling his commander absolutely not
- [47:26] β A strong finish, Valka's chimera, and something close to a Sanderlanche
- [48:07] β Predictions: Ryan wants Hadrian embedded with the Cielcin, Rich wants more Jaddian warriors
- [49:29] β Rich's note for book four: stop being five genres at once. Less is more. He came up with that himself
- [50:34] β One-star reviews: cardboard characters, a failed Pierce Brown impression, and the reader whose two-and-a-half-year reading streak this series broke
- [57:08] β Who should read this book, and who absolutely should not
- [58:16] β Wrap-up
TikTok: @hottakebks
Instagram: @hottakebooks
More episodes from "Hot Take Books"



Don't miss an episode of βHot Take Booksβ and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








