Highlands Current Audio Stories podcast

Beacon to End Flock Contract

0:00
5:32
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds
Council acknowledges privacy concerns
After hearing from dozens of residents opposed to the technology over the last four months, the Beacon City Council voted on Monday (Nov. 16) to discontinue the city's use of Flock automatic license-plate readers.
The change will be immediate; Police Chief Tom Figlia said Tuesday that he was manually removing his officers' and other agencies' access to the cameras.
Figlia told the council during a September meeting that license-plate readers helped Beacon police locate endangered people and solve crimes or arrest suspects at least a dozen times, including in assaults, hit-and-runs and a shooting.
However, he said on Tuesday that "it is up to our elected officials to constantly assess the balance between security and privacy. I am glad to have been given the opportunity to demonstrate how we have used the LPRs so that they were fully informed in their decision."
Beacon has seven cameras in six locations: at entrances to the city on Route 9D, Route 52 and Washington Avenue, and on Main Street. The Flock Group, the Atlanta-based company that has sold 120,000 LPRs to 6,000 communities nationwide, will remove them. The city will pay $30,000 during the remainder of its contract, which runs to December 2028.
The council had not planned a vote but added a resolution to the agenda authorizing City Administrator Ben Swanson to terminate the contract. Mayor Lee Kyriacou voted "no" and Sergei Krasikov abstained, although both said they understood and, in some ways, agreed with the public criticism of the cameras.
The Flock system analyzes photos of passing vehicles, records their plate numbers and categorizes them by make and model, color and any damage. Law-enforcement agencies can search the system's database to locate stolen vehicles, criminal suspects and missing persons.

Although Flock says the devices do not capture drivers' faces or other distinguishing features, LPRs have come under nationwide scrutiny as allegations have emerged of misuse and privacy breaches, including cooperation with federal immigration authorities. The data can also be shared with a nationwide network of thousands of law-enforcement agencies.
While the Beacon department withdrew from the national network earlier this year, downsizing the agencies that have access to about 400, residents have said they believe breaches are still possible. Council Member Paloma Wake on Monday called the system "profoundly leaky."
The council's decision follows similar moves elsewhere in the region. In September, Dutchess County officials agreed to remove the county's 65 Flock LPRs and the Newburgh City Council voted to end its contract with the company.
That same month, state Sen. Michelle Hinchey, a Democrat who represents northern Dutchess County, introduced a bill that, among other provisions, would ban the sale of LPR data to private entities; block out-of-state law enforcement from accessing New York LPR data without judicial authorization; require LPR data to be deleted within 48 hours unless needed for an investigation or retained pursuant to a warrant; and require auditable logs documenting queries for LPR data.
The Beacon council in October asked its attorney to investigate ending the contract with Flock, although the request seemed to be about putting options on the table without a clear mandate in either direction. By Monday, however, a majority of its members said they'd been convinced by their own research and the public outcry.
Council members said they appreciated Figlia's efforts to safeguard camera data. But Amber Grant and Paloma Wake, who were both on the council when the city entered into its agreement with Flock in 2023, said they have since learned more about privacy concerns associated with the system.
Council Member Zack Smith said his concern is about "extra-legal use of the cameras, rather than the prescribed legal use that's been set forth by the chief, and I don't think the chief's explanation addresses that....

More episodes from "Highlands Current Audio Stories"