Does Scouting Have a Future?
Participation dwindles among boys and girls
For over 100 years, Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts have had the same motto: "Be prepared."
Whether the organizations are prepared to thrive in the 21st century is unclear. Scouting membership locally and nationwide has dropped significantly over the past decade.
The ranks of Beacon Scout Troop 3041, which meets near the Elks Lodge on Route 9D, have dwindled to 12 boys, down from 35 before the pandemic, said Scoutmaster John Darcy. Philipstown Troop 437 has 20 Scouts, down from 40, said Matt Koch, the committee chair of the troop that meets at the Garrison Fish and Game Club in Philipstown.
Those numbers track with declines across the Hudson Valley, which has 9,000 Scouts and Cub Scouts, down from 18,000 in 2019. Nationwide, Scout membership has dropped from 2 million in 2019 to 1 million. Scouting peaked in the 1970s at nearly 5 million.
In 2010, the Boy Scouts were hit with thousands of claims of sexual abuse, dating to the 1940s. None of the accusations involved troops in the Highlands, though some allegedly occurred in the Hudson Valley, according to databases compiling the incidents and news reports. The claims led the Boy Scouts of America to declare bankruptcy in 2020.
In 2024, the Boy Scouts began to accept girls and rebranded as Scouting America. Its president at the time, Roger Krone, said the organization hoped to "chart a course toward continued growth, relevance and impact."
Richard Stockton, CEO of the Greater Hudson Valley Council of Scouting America, based in Fishkill, said the national group "hit a perfect storm between COVID, the bankruptcy and the sexual abuse scandals. We lost quite a bit of credibility."
He said that adult volunteers now undergo training and are prohibited from being alone with Scouts. "We have to prove ourselves," said Stockton.
The organization's focus is to recruit Cub Scouts. "The most effective way of recruiting is peer-to-peer: parents inviting other parents," said Jon Whitaker, the Hudson Valley Council's field director.
The results in the Highlands have been mixed. Philipstown's Cub Scout Pack 137 has grown from 30 Cubs a few years ago to 45, said Cubmaster Paul Wynn. "Parents often tell me they're looking for activities that get their kids off screens," he said. Last month 50 scouts and parents gathered at Philipstown Park to launch model rockets.
Recruitment in Beacon has been a challenge, said Ed McMillan, cubmaster for Pack 3001, which meets at the Memorial Building on Main Street. The pack has about 25 members, but nearly half are fifth graders who will leave when they enter middle school next year.
Despite participating in events like Spirit of Beacon Day, they've had difficulty recruiting younger children, McMillan said: "There's just not as much engagement or interest as you'd expect."
Jaiden Gunther, 17, who became an Eagle Scout in an Oct. 25 ceremony at Hubbard Lodge as part of the Philipstown troop, said children often prefer activities like sports and drama. A few years ago, he said, "we had a group of 15 Cub Scouts who graduated and crossed over into the Boy Scout troop. Over the past two years, it's down to three."
Darcy, the Beacon scoutmaster, worries "the younger generation does not appreciate the ideas of helping in the community, living by the Scout oath and law, being trustworthy, helpful — all those things," he said. "There's no drive to be that better person."
For the Girl Scouts, it's hard competing with school activities, said Kari Rockwell, the CEO of Girl Scouts Heart of the Hudson. Once a child gets home at 5:30 p.m., Rockwell said, the last thing a parent wants to do is "turn around and drive back out to a troop meeting." The numbers of Girl Scouts and adult volunteers in the Hudson Valley has dropped by about 40 percent, to 25,000, over the past decade, she said.
In Beacon, Girl Scouts have dropped in half from a decade ago to about 50, said Rhonda Altonen, who leads the local troop. Older girls, she said, "...