A thirteen-year-old girl begins falling into trances.
She says she can see the dead.
Then one day, she opens her eyes and says she is no longer herself.
In 1877, Mary Lurancy Vennum—known as Lurancy—became the center of one of America’s most unsettling alleged possession cases. Her family feared she was losing her mind and might be sent to an asylum. But after she began claiming to see spirits, a local Spiritualist physician and a grieving family offered another explanation.
They believed the spirit of Mary Roff—a young woman who had died twelve years earlier—had taken control of Lurancy’s body.
According to the accounts, Lurancy recognized Mary Roff’s family, used private nicknames, remembered details from Mary’s life, and spent about one hundred days living in the Roff family home while claiming to be their dead daughter.
Was it spirit possession?
Was it grief, suggestion, trauma, dissociation, or an illness people in 1878 could not understand?
In this bonus episode of Monstrous, Riley explores the Watseka Wonder: the trances, the reported memories, the Roff family’s loss, the Spiritualist movement, and the question that still refuses to fade.
Did Mary Roff really come home?
🎄 The Monstrous Giving Tree — donations close November 30 every year.
Give here:
- GoFundMe: https://gofund.me/584d87a77
- Venmo: https://www.venmo.com/u/Monstrous_Pod
- PayPal: https://www.paypal.biz/monstroustcpod
- Amazon e-gift card: email one to [email protected]
Families in need:
[email protected] with "Giving Tree" in the subject line. There's no shame in needing a little help — that's exactly what this tree is for. Everything stays private.
📧 Send us case suggestions and listener stories:
📱 Follow us on all social media links here:
Fler avsnitt från "Monstrous"



Missa inte ett avsnitt av “Monstrous” och prenumerera på det i GetPodcast-appen.








