Monstrous podcast

The Great Amherst Mystery

2026-11-16
0:00
42:14
Spola tillbaka 15 sekunder
Spola framåt 15 sekunder

A note from Monstrous: Carrie and MawMaw are taking a leave from weekly hosting to focus on personal family matters. Carrie will continue researching and writing our episodes, with Riley bringing you the weekly stories. Carrie may also appear for interviews as they are arranged; those appearances do not necessarily mark a return to weekly hosting. There is no return date to announce. Thank you for respecting their privacy and supporting the show.

In 1878, 18-year-old Esther Cox lived with her sister’s family in a small yellow cottage at 6 Princess Street in Amherst, Nova Scotia.

Then the knocking began.

According to the accounts, objects moved without anyone touching them. Esther’s body swelled.

Knocks answered questions. Fires started inside the home. Matches fell from the ceiling. And one terrifying message reportedly appeared above Esther’s bed:

“Esther Cox, you are mine to kill.”

But was Esther Cox haunted by a poltergeist?

Or was this a story shaped by trauma, fear, a crowded household, public obsession, Victorian Spiritualism, and a writer who turned her private suffering into a bestselling supernatural tale?

In this episode of Monstrous, researched and written by Carrie and narrated by Riley, we explore the Great Amherst Mystery from beginning to end: Esther’s reported encounter with Bob MacNeil, the strange events inside the Teed family home, the fires, witnesses, Walter Hubbell’s role, Esther’s failed public tour, the contested details of her late-1879 conviction, and the legacy that still keeps her story alive in Amherst today.

We also separate what the historical record supports from the claims, folklore, and later supernatural retellings that turned Esther Cox into one of Canada’s most famous paranormal figures.

Was it a poltergeist?

A hoax?

A trauma story no one knew how to hear?

🎄 The Monstrous Giving Tree — donations close November 30 every year.

Give here:

Families in need:

Email [email protected] with "Giving Tree" in the subject line. There's no shame in needing a little help — that's exactly what this tree is for. Everything stays private.

📧 Send us case suggestions and listener stories:

[email protected]

📱 Follow us on all social media links here:

https://linktr.ee/monstrouspod

Fler avsnitt från "Monstrous"