S3 Ep1: Deadbolt

Marking the 17th anniversary of Matt Stewart’s unsolved murder, Freddie chats with two of Matt’s friends and examines a handful of relevant public statements—including a 2025 sermon given by Matt’s widow, a 2021 interview with a former detective who claimed to have consulted on the case, and a cryptic social media comment a former Mooresville Police Captain made earlier this year.Who Killed Matt Stewart: http://whokilledmattstewart.comPodcast Website: https://www.unforgottenpodcast.comUNFORGOTTEN Forum: https://unforgotten.freeforums.netAngel’s Sermon (RiverLife Fellowship Chapel Hill)David Newman Interview (Dropping Wisdom With Santos)UNFORGOTTEN: The Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart is an independently produced podcast series which takes a detailed look at the still unsolved homicide of Matthew Ryan Stewart; a 31 year old father of three who was murdered inside his Mooresville, NC home during the early hours of June 9th, 2009. The series dives into the strange facts of the crime and features exclusive interviews with the victim's friends, family, and neighbors, as well as commentary from experts.

New Episode - 6/9/2026

Freddie and Steve discuss posts made on the forum (www.unforgotten.freeforums.net) during the past year. Freddie announces that a popular true crime podcast will do an episode about Matt's murder later this year. 

Freddie struggles to get a formal interview with X, a close family friend of the Stewart's who was interrogated and accused by investigators 2013. Nationally renowned forensic psychiatrist Dr. Carole Lieberman weighs in on Angel's 2017 Youtube testimony. Freddie unearths and examines a June 2009 interview with the neighbor across the street who opened the door for Angel on the morning of the murder. UNFORGOTTEN: The Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart is an independently produced podcast series which takes a detailed look at the still unsolved homicide of Matthew Ryan Stewart; a 31 year old father of three who was murdered inside his Mooresville, NC home during the early hours of June 9th, 2009. The series dives into the strange facts of the crime and features exclusive interviews with the victim's friends, family, and neighbors, as well as commentary from experts.

Freddie and Steve speak with "Lucy", the former family friend of the Stewarts featured in episodes 5 & 6 of Season #2.UNFORGOTTEN: The Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart is an independently produced podcast series which takes a detailed look at the still unsolved homicide of Matthew Ryan Stewart; a 31 year old father of three who was murdered inside his Mooresville, NC home during the early hours of June 9th, 2009. The series dives into the strange facts of the crime and features exclusive interviews with the victim's friends, family, and neighbors, as well as commentary from experts.

Freddie discusses 2 guns which were turned over to police in April of this year, as well as the gun's prior owner, who was questioned by investigators in the wake of Matt's murder. We continue with “Lucy’s” testimony, and also hear from another of Matt’s co-workers at Lake Norman Regional Medical Center, as well as one of his first cousins.UNFORGOTTEN: The Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart is an independently produced podcast series which takes a detailed look at the still unsolved homicide of Matthew Ryan Stewart; a 31 year old father of three who was murdered inside his Mooresville, NC home during the early hours of June 9th, 2009. The series dives into the strange facts of the crime and features exclusive interviews with the victim's friends, family, and neighbors, as well as commentary from experts.

Steve (moderator of Unforgotten.FreeForums.net) joins Freddie to answer listener submitted questions following episode #5 of Season 2.UNFORGOTTEN: the Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart is an independently produced podcast series which takes a detailed look at the still unsolved homicide of Matthew Ryan Stewart; a 31 year old father of three who was murdered inside his Mooresville, NC home during the early hours of June 9th, 2009. The series dives into the strange facts of the crime and features exclusive interviews with the victim's friends, family, and neighbors, as well as commentary from experts.

Freddie speaks with a neighbor on Northland Ave, a few houses down from Matt and Angel, who claims to have had his window open on the evening of the incident. A family friend discusses her experience at Jean's house, in the wake of Matt's murder.UNFORGOTTEN: The Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart is an independently produced podcast series which takes a detailed look at the still unsolved homicide of Matthew Ryan Stewart; a 31 year old father of three who was murdered inside his Mooresville, NC home during the early hours of June 9th, 2009. The series dives into the strange facts of the crime and features exclusive interviews with the victim's friends, family, and neighbors, as well as commentary from experts.

Steve (moderator of Unforgotten.FreeForums.net) joins Freddie to answer listener submitted questions following episodes #3 & #4 of Season 2.UNFORGOTTEN: the Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart is an independently produced podcast series which takes a detailed look at the still unsolved homicide of Matthew Ryan Stewart; a 31 year old father of three who was murdered inside his Mooresville, NC home during the early hours of June 9th, 2009. The series dives into the strange facts of the crime and features exclusive interviews with the victim's friends, family, and neighbors, as well as commentary from experts.

Freddie explores an old family feud, and interviews Michelle, the neighbor whose house Matt's oldest daughter was staying on the night of the murder.  UNFORGOTTEN: The Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart is an independently produced podcast series which takes a detailed look at the still unsolved homicide of Matthew Ryan Stewart; a 31 year old father of three who was murdered inside his Mooresville, NC home during the early hours of June 9th, 2009. The series dives into the strange facts of the crime and features exclusive interviews with the victim's friends, family, and neighbors, as well as commentary from experts.