Hamish McKenzie On Substack And Journalism

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit andrewsullivan.substack.comHamish is one of the co-founders of Substack and its chief writing officer. He’s a former reporter for the tech blog PandoDaily and a former lead writer for Tesla. He’s the author of Insane Mode: How Elon Musk’s Tesla Sparked an Electric Revolution to End the Age of Oil, and his new book is called How to Save the Media. A native New Zealander, and former journalist himself, Hamish has kept writers at the heart of the Substack model, first pioneered by the Dish.The episode was recorded on November 10, 2026, and aired on November 13. Timestamps for the main sections:* 06:18: Hamish’s upbringing in New Zealand and his journalism* 28:00: The early internet and the advent of blogs and the Dish* 50:00: The rise of social media and Substack’s challenge to it* 133:27: Substack standing strong against censorshipFor two audio clips — when the enshittification of social media began, and the challenges of affordability on Substack — go here and here on YouTube.More topics covered: Hamish’s mom a teacher of Maori culture; his dad a physicist on the ozone layer; nightlife journalism in Hong Kong; clashing with Elon and his lawyers; meeting his Substack co-founders working at Kik; the pamphleteering era ended by newspapers; the pioneering of Matt Drudge; Kinsley and Slate; Evan Williams and Blogger; the origins of the Daily Dish; mass intimacy; war bloggers after 9/11; the Dish getting donations in 2002; blogging at Time, The Atlantic, and The Daily Beast; the ad model failing; the unraveling of mags; the Dish going independent in 2013; TinyPass; Patreon; the Daily Dish retiring; NY Mag firing me and jumping to Substack; Yglesias leaving Vox; Bari selling The Free Press to David Ellison; Tina Brown reborn as a writer; media bias on Israel; cancel-culture threats to Substack; Twitter and enshittification; the internet becoming TV; Grindr and Sniffies; and the challenges of a scaled-up Substack.Browse the Dishcast archive for episodes you might enjoy.

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit andrewsullivan.substack.comMichael is a journalist and historian. He’s currently the senior political analyst for the Washington Examiner, a resident fellow emeritus at the American Enterprise Institute, and the longtime co-author of The Almanac of American Politics.The episode was recorded on November 4, 2026, and aired on November 6. Timestamps for the main sections:* 04:29: Michael’s upbringing and his early career* 24:46: The tsunami that swept away Republicans this week* 43:23: The electoral impact of the Iran War* 51:21: The Dem victories in Texas and the immigration issue* 102:56: El-Sayed and shifting attitudes toward Israel* 115:11: The future of the GOP with Trump as a lame duckFor two audio clips — on how the GOP dummymandered itself, and if Texas is really turning blue — go here and here on YouTube.More topics covered: Michael raised in the Detroit area; the Great Migration; his Dem youth turning conservative; the Dem coalition of blacks and college whites that started in the ‘60s; the decades of Dem dominance in the House until ‘94; Clinton and Carville; the narrowing of POTUS victories since the ‘90s; gerrymandering; the GOP’s “thumping” in the 2006 midterms; Trump’s “they/them” ad and McDonald’s stunt; his gilded obsessions; his family cashing in; his lonely support of tariffs; the trade war with Canada; the ICE and DHS debacles; Mamdani and the rise of DSA; the Iran War and Graham’s death; his sister’s loss; AIPAC spending big against El-Sayed; the chilling anti-Israel ad in Michigan; the shocking defeat of Abbott; Talarico’s triumph; Hispanics turning on Trump; the border; the youth vote and men swinging against Trump; Narcissus at the Reflecting Pool; DeSantis speaking out; and Vance’s tweet dissenting over Trump’s war.Browse the Dishcast archive for episodes you might enjoy.

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit andrewsullivan.substack.comCatherine is a philologist with a particular focus on Augustine of Hippo. She’s both the Leslie Clark Professor in the Humanities and a Professor of Greek, Latin, and Classical Studies at Bryn Mawr College. The author of many books, her most recent is Augustine the African. We had an exhilarating afternoon talking about this African who helped frame the West.The episode was recorded on October 27, 2026, and aired on October 30. Timestamps for the main sections:* 07:43: How Catherine came to specialize in Augustine* 24:19: The profound influence of his mother* 42:56: His conversion to Christianity* 52:42: The deaths of his mom, son, and best friend in quick succession* 101:23: His decades preaching and writing in HippoFor two audio clips — on Augustine’s struggles with sex, and the moment he converted to Christianity — head to our YouTube page.More topics covered: Catherine growing up mostly in Oxford; her family’s dedication to the classics; the Romans’ Gaza-like destruction of Carthage; the ferocious debating style of Augustine; his struggle to be humble; his emotional openness; his disgust over Roman games and executions; his early interest in Manichaeism; the problem of evil; sex in the Garden of Eden; Augustine’s persistent horniness; his 14-year relationship with a woman he ditched for an arranged marriage; his close bond with his Christian mother who long tried to convert him; the unprecedented nature of his Confessions; Oakeshott’s awe; Augustine on friendship; memory and time; The City of God filled with relentless counter arguments; Wittgenstein and the limits of language; the miracles of everyday life; the homelessness of Jesus and St Francis; and how Rome was falling at the end of Augustine’s life.Browse the Dishcast archive for episodes you might enjoy.

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit andrewsullivan.substack.comMy old friend Chris — the most intelligent, sane, and well-read conservative thinker writing in America today — returns to the Dishcast for his fourth appearance. He’s a senior fellow at the Claremont Institute, a contributing editor to the Claremont Review of Books, a contributing writer for the NYT and The Spectator, and a member of the editorial committee of the French quarterly Commentaire.The episode was recorded on October 14, 2026, and aired on October 23. Timestamps for the main sections:* 03:57: The Iran debacle and Trump’s broken promise on wars* 33:11: Gaza and surging antisemitism on the left and right* 46:01: Germany and the rise of the AfD* 103:12: The political situation in France and Spain* 112:03: The state of the right in the UK* 129:30: What the GOP might look like after Trump is goneFor two audio clips — on the lawfare against right-wing pols in Europe, and whether the Iran War will split Trump’s party — head to our YouTube page.More topics covered: the CIA cautioning against the Iran War; gas prices and inflation; China “laughing at us”; the Houthis harming global trade; Trump’s fickle moods; protectionism and tariffs; staggering corruption in crypto and other cons; Vought and Miller; Musk’s DOGE demolition; USAID and bias; Rubio’s expansive role; his Athens speech and thymos; Vance and “heritage Americans”; MAGA vs international alliances; Obama opposing the Iraq War; Howard Dean; the war in Gaza; Israel as Goliath; college protests and woke antisemitism; the Groypers and rising antisemitism on the right; the dark talents of Fuentes; the left’s rejection of nationalism; AfD and its origins; lesbian AfD leader Alice Weidel; Merkel and Syrian refugees; the surging popularity of Marine Le Pen; the Vox party in Spain; the fall of Starmer; the Restore and Reform parties; the waning influence of Farage; Count Binface; Kemi’s leadership; and Orwell’s views on Englishness.

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit andrewsullivan.substack.comEvan is a former campaign fundraiser and political strategist for Democrats. She just published her first book, Nothing Left: Confessions of a Democratic Operative, which really blew me away. She’s also a writer and podcaster on Substack.The episode was recorded on October 13, 2026, and aired on October 16. Timestamps for the main sections:* 02:18: Evan’s upbringing in a poor, tumultuous family and trailer park* 21:44: Her illness that led her to fight for Obama and his ACA* 33:43: When she started to turn against Democrats* 57:51: Getting canceled for being a “fragile white woman”* 111:55: The death of her veteran brother and a woke disdain for patriotism* 123:21: Her vote for Trump as a reactionary protestFor two audio clips — on her lifelong illness that drove her to campaign for Obama, and the woke dominance of Dem donors — head to our YouTube page.More topics covered: how unions helped Evan’s family; the many marriages of her parents; going to 10 different schools; instability with money and healthcare; becoming a first-gen college grad; progressive activism; Bernie and AOC; the colorblind message of Obama; Hillary’s shift to identity politics; the smug elitism of Dem operatives; nepotism; weaponizing “oppression”; the Dem suspicion of straight men; Evan’s “masculine” approach to fundraising; the woke pipeline of the Ivy League; Kaepernick’s knee; oikophobia; immigration and the border; the ICE overreach; the silence of scared liberals; and how Dems haven’t gotten the message after 2024.Browse the Dishcast archive for episodes you might enjoy. Coming up: Chris Caldwell on the right in the US and Europe, Michael Barone on the midterms, Francis Fukuyama on his memoir, Hamish McKenzie on Substack and journalism, Cynthia Burack on gender studies, Cyrus Habib on leaving politics to become a priest, Catherine Conybeare on Augustine, and Nancy Sherman on Aristotle.

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit andrewsullivan.substack.comMichael is the best nonfiction writer in America — and another friend from the early TNR days. He’s the author of so many bestsellers, including Liar’s Poker, Moneyball, The Blind Side, and Flash Boys. He was on the Dishcast four years ago to discuss The Premonition: A Pandemic Story, and last year to discuss a collection of essays called Who Is Government?This week we’re covering his new book, Blockers: Rebels in the Deep State, which profiles some unknown heroes in the bureaucracy who defended the rule of law against Trump in his second term — and faced the consequences. Think of it as the flip-side of Jake Weisberg’s treatment of the powerful cowards who caved.The episode was recorded on September 29, 2026, and aired on October 9. Timestamps for the main sections:* 03:36: How Michael decided to frame and shape the book* 11:32: DOGE as the tip of the spear for Trump 2.0* 27:36: The physical takeover of buildings by DOGE* 42:45: The amazing story of Alex Marangides inventing a new fire science* 101:20: Covid policy and the turmoil at the National Institutes of Health* 119:32: Michael’s moving tribute to his daughter DixieFor three audio clips — why DOGE was never really about downsizing, the only member of DOGE who was fired, and Michael writing a play for his deceased daughter — head to our YouTube page.More topics covered: how Trump 2.0 is different than 1.0; firing his transition team in 2016; the purging of enemies after 2024; Musk wanting to take control of NASA; reversing woke terminology; bypassing Congress; weaponizing private data; Musk promising pardons to DOGE; dismantling USAID; Vought and knee-capping the NIH; Michael’s scoop that Francis Collins was actually fired; debating the culpability of Bhattacharya; the Clinton-Gore downsizing; fixing the ozone layer; Trump’s sycophants; the horrifying Howard Lutnick; and inspiring stories of civil servants standing up for their role and the rule of law.

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit andrewsullivan.substack.comEmily is a senior editor at the New York Times Book Review. She’s also worked as a senior editor at The New Yorker, an ideas reporter for the NYT, a fashion features writer at Vogue, and a deputy editor of Lingua Franca magazine. Her new book is The Frenchmen: Or, My Life in Theory.A polished transcript is here, including money quotes. Below are timestamps for the main sections of the pod:* 03:56: Emily’s upbringing in a Francophile family* 14:27: The postmodern idea that language is everything* 31:05: The postmodern New Right* 41:14: The dark dysfunctional lives of many of the French thinkers* 103:27: The fatalism in pomo discourse* 117:14: How Emily became skeptical of postmodernismFor two clips of the episode — on the word games of postmodernists, and the screwed-up lives of Foucault and others — head to our YouTube page.More topics: Emily growing up in Indiana with regular trips to France; the country’s post-war boom but drop in world status; colonial revolt in Algeria; Heidegger and Nazism; Barthes and Maoism; Derrida and language; Levi-Strauss and structuralism; Camus and existentialism; nihilism; bourgeois as an epithet; Lacan and the unconscious; Althusser strangling his wife to death; the Straussian cult; Allan Bloom; the Sokal hoax; Stanley Fish and deconstruction; John Boswell and homosexuality; Foucault deconstructing gayness; the AIDS crisis; the prison system; Orwell and Oakeshott; Sarah Bakewell on Montaigne; HR and pronouns; the fatalism of Coates; and Trump’s exec orders on language in government.Browse the Dishcast archive for an episode you might enjoy. Coming up: Michael Lewis on the bureaucrats who fought back against Trump, Evan Barker on how the Democratic Party got hijacked by elite activists, Sean Illing on the relevance of Camus and Nietzsche, Catherine Conybeare on Augustine, and Cyrus Habib on leaving politics to become a Jesuit priest. Please send any guest recs, dissents, and other comments to [email protected].

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit andrewsullivan.substack.comJake is a journalist and a dear old friend, starting in our early days as interns together at TNR. He’s the former longtime editor of Slate and the co-founder of the podcast company Pushkin Industries. He’s also the chairman of The Committee to Protect Journalists and a regular contributor to the New York Review of Books. His new book is called Profiles in Cowardice: A Study of Collaboration in the Trump Era.A polished transcript is here, including money quotes. Below are timestamps for the main sections of the pod:* 04:09: Jake’s background that made him especially attuned to corruption and totalitarianism* 18:45: Contrasting the craven Lindsey Graham with the principled Liz Cheney* 25:45: How Megyn Kelly — and others demonized by the left — came to support Trump* 35:15: Liberal lawyers like Brad Karp who needlessly bent the knee* 45:52: Debating the culpability of colleges targeted by Trump* 53:36: Jeff Bezos’ 180 and his lifelong obsession with space travel* 58:43: The abomination of January 6th and McConnell caving over the impeachment* 102:28: Debating the culpability of John Roberts for Trump’s success* 117:26: Reminiscing on our early days at TNR and the genius of Mike KinsleyFor two clips of the episode — on why McConnell balked at banning Trump, and how Megyn Kelly became a bully — head to our YouTube page.Other topics: growing up in Chicago with public servants for parents; his dad taking on the Daley machine; Jake’s talent for takedowns back at TNR; South Park mocking Trump; Stop the Steal and Jan 6; Biden’s clusterfuck campaign; the Cheneys backing Harris; Trump’s retribution; the weakness of Schumer; McCain’s nonconformity; Massie’s cojones; the university deals with Trump; his talent as a bully; higher ed’s dearth of viewpoint diversity; anti-semitism in the Ivy League; Musk and the big subsidies for SpaceX; decimating USAID and PEPFAR; Bezos funding the Melania doc; SCOTUS checking tariffs; the presidential immunity ruling; the post-presidencies of Bush and Obama; and the one magazine piece I would never write.Browse the Dishcast archive for an episode you might enjoy. Coming up: Emily Eakin on the French postmodernists, Sean Illing on the relevance of Camus and Nietzsche, Michael Lewis on the bureaucrats who fought back against Trump, and Evan Barker on how the Democratic Party got hijacked by elite activists. Please send any guest recs, dissents, and other comments to [email protected].

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit andrewsullivan.substack.comArianna is a writer and businesswoman. She co-founded The Huffington Post in 2005, and after it was acquired by AOL, she became the president and editor-in-chief of The Huffington Post Media Group. She’s currently the CEO of Thrive Global and the author of 15 books, including Thrive and The Sleep Revolution.A polished transcript is here, including money quotes. Below are timestamps for the main sections of the pod:5:05: Arianna’s meteoric rise at a young age and challenging left-feminism28:05: IQ, meritocracy, and what sets humans apart from AI50:10: A crisis of meaning and the “false god of productivity”114:07: The importance of sleep and how to improve itFor two clips of the episode — on the desperate need for grace in our discourse, and how to sleep better — head to our YouTube page.More topics: Arianna’s upbringing in Greece; her dad’s anti-Nazi magazine in WWII; the power of maternal love; her time at the Cambridge Union as its first foreign prez; her first book The Female Woman; her love affair with Bernard Levin; the feminism of the Gospels; meritocracy; AI surpassing us in intelligence; our culture’s distrust of nature; Arianna’s burnout in 2007 and my own in 2015; silent meditation retreats; Matthew Crawford and craftsmanship; Loren Eiseley the anthropologist; mental illness; psychedelics; God as love; Maslow’s pyramid; and Arianna giving me tips for my insomnia.Browse the Dishcast archive for an episode you might enjoy. Coming up: Emily Eakin on the French postmodernists, Sean Illing on the relevance of Camus and Nietzsche, Jake Weisberg on the cowards who caved to Trump, and Michael Lewis on the bureaucrats who fought back. Please send any guest recs, dissents, and other comments to [email protected].

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit andrewsullivan.substack.comAzam is an international investigative reporter for the New York Times. He used to be the Times bureau chief in Afghanistan, as well as Mexico, Central America, and the Caribbean. He won a Pulitzer last year for his work on the US intervention in Afghanistan, among other awards. He’s also the author of Fear Is Just A Word: A Missing Daughter, a Violent Cartel, and a Mother’s Quest for Vengeance. I discovered him simply by reading the paper and noticing an extraordinary ability to ferret out the truth. In conversation, Azam did not disappoint. A polished transcript is here, including money quotes from the chat. Below are timestamps for the main sections of the pod:05:23: Growing up in a Pakistani family in a small-town Virginia10:36: The value of fiction over nonfiction22:26: Azam’s time reporting on Wall Street, and then the horrors in Afghanistan46:24: A deep dive into a terrifying new wave of synthetic drugs1:03:56: The violent settlers in the West Bank and the Israeli officials speaking outFor two clips of the episode — on the new wave of dangerous drugs, and the Israeli government arming the West Bank settlers — head to our YouTube page.Other topics: the lack of bigotry in Azam’s upbringing in the South; how UVA was more tribal than his high school; the war on terror; nation-building; how little the US understood Afghanistan; funding warlords against the Taliban; not talking to Taliban officials; US propaganda and lies; a story of suicide; Estonia beating fentanyl; the mega-potency of new drugs like nitazenes; drug-soaked paper causing overdoses in US prisons; why targeting suppliers doesn’t work anymore; harm reduction and Narcan; methadone; decriminalization in Portugal; the popularity of weed; the cynicism and evil of Hamas; dead kids in Gaza and US bombs; the depravity of Ben-Gvir; high-ranking Israelis against the settlements; and Bibi’s polling for the coming election.Browse the Dishcast archive for an episode you might enjoy. Coming up: Emily Eakin on postmodernism, Jake Weisberg on the cowards who caved to Trump, Michael Lewis on the federal workers who fought back, and Arianna Huffington on living well. Please send any guest recs, dissents, and other comments to [email protected].