
0:00
9:29
By John M. Grondelski
But first a note from Robert Royal:
Christianity is a complete key to life precisely because it affirms not only the truths of Revelation, but the consequences that follow from those truths. And as Dr. Grondelski says today, that means not only accepting the words in Scripture that Jesus tells us about Heaven and Hell - words many today would prefer not to hear. We also have to see deeply into the teaching because if our acts are not free or do not turn us towards real Good and Evil, our very dignity as human beings would be diminished.
God took a big chance in making us free, and the jury is still out on how many of us will accept that challenge as He intended, which is why we need saints, doctors, scholars, and even TCT writers to remind us constantly of the great drama of human life. If you want to know more of this - and I know most of you do - we need your help. It's that time of year. Please, help us to make sure TCT is here for the rest of this year and for many years to come. Do your part towards keeping the spirit alive in our Church and our world.
Now for today's column...
November in the Catholic Church has a decidedly eschatological cast. The month is dedicated to praying for the souls in Purgatory, while the end-of-Ordinary-Time readings – Sundays and weekdays – focus on the "Last Things," i.e., death, judgment, heaven, and hell.
In some sense, November's traditional eschatological focus rubs against common approaches encountered in the rest of the year in post-Vatican II Catholicism. Critics decry the almost instant canonization tone of many funeral homilies, while the lack of attention to the sacrificial nature of the Eucharist means many contemporary Catholics would be hard pressed to explain the necessity of prayers for the faithful departed.
The ancient heresy of apocatastasis – the idea that everybody will eventually be saved – persists in a kind of "Catholic version" that skates at the edge of heresy: "dare we hope" that all will be saved?
Yes, we hope. But the usual expressions of that hope seem to be a wink and nod that the "hope" is in fact our belief, constrained only by the continued bonds of ecclesiastical teach
ing holding us back from full-throated affirmation. Pope Francis repeatedly veered in this direction. Yes, we concede that theoretically Hell might exist, but we really expect it to be empty.
The practical expression comes from our pastoral refusal to talk about Hell as real, to mention Purgatory only in November, and to canonize the deceased while "celebrating their life" in our funerary rituals. It all collides with St. Paul's sober injunction to "work out your own salvation with fear and trembling." (Philippians 2:12)
This November, let me suggest that hell is an expression of God's mercy.
That idea is hardly novel, though likely not understandable to many today. Its usual expression involves some combination of anthropology and morality. As Heaven is not so much a "place" as a "state" of loving God, justice – towards God and towards the sinner – cannot force love out of one who chooses not to love.
Heaven or Hell ultimately depend on taking seriously the reality of human freedom, which finds its ultimate challenge in love, and which then includes the possibility of not loving. It remains a matter of justice and love: justice in respect of one's free choice, love in the sense of God not forcing Himself unrequitedly on the one who does not love Him.
While this explanation is traditional, it does not necessarily ring true to today's ears. Most people seem to imagine a "happily ever after" scenario where, somehow, God's persistence will ultimately triumph over human obstinacy, bringing all to true love of God.
If human life is any indication – and many of these same people are big on "experience" – we know that a lover's diligence notwithstanding, there are cases where that love is refused and refused definitively. Partisans of this view do not explain how God somehow ...
But first a note from Robert Royal:
Christianity is a complete key to life precisely because it affirms not only the truths of Revelation, but the consequences that follow from those truths. And as Dr. Grondelski says today, that means not only accepting the words in Scripture that Jesus tells us about Heaven and Hell - words many today would prefer not to hear. We also have to see deeply into the teaching because if our acts are not free or do not turn us towards real Good and Evil, our very dignity as human beings would be diminished.
God took a big chance in making us free, and the jury is still out on how many of us will accept that challenge as He intended, which is why we need saints, doctors, scholars, and even TCT writers to remind us constantly of the great drama of human life. If you want to know more of this - and I know most of you do - we need your help. It's that time of year. Please, help us to make sure TCT is here for the rest of this year and for many years to come. Do your part towards keeping the spirit alive in our Church and our world.
Now for today's column...
November in the Catholic Church has a decidedly eschatological cast. The month is dedicated to praying for the souls in Purgatory, while the end-of-Ordinary-Time readings – Sundays and weekdays – focus on the "Last Things," i.e., death, judgment, heaven, and hell.
In some sense, November's traditional eschatological focus rubs against common approaches encountered in the rest of the year in post-Vatican II Catholicism. Critics decry the almost instant canonization tone of many funeral homilies, while the lack of attention to the sacrificial nature of the Eucharist means many contemporary Catholics would be hard pressed to explain the necessity of prayers for the faithful departed.
The ancient heresy of apocatastasis – the idea that everybody will eventually be saved – persists in a kind of "Catholic version" that skates at the edge of heresy: "dare we hope" that all will be saved?
Yes, we hope. But the usual expressions of that hope seem to be a wink and nod that the "hope" is in fact our belief, constrained only by the continued bonds of ecclesiastical teach
ing holding us back from full-throated affirmation. Pope Francis repeatedly veered in this direction. Yes, we concede that theoretically Hell might exist, but we really expect it to be empty.
The practical expression comes from our pastoral refusal to talk about Hell as real, to mention Purgatory only in November, and to canonize the deceased while "celebrating their life" in our funerary rituals. It all collides with St. Paul's sober injunction to "work out your own salvation with fear and trembling." (Philippians 2:12)
This November, let me suggest that hell is an expression of God's mercy.
That idea is hardly novel, though likely not understandable to many today. Its usual expression involves some combination of anthropology and morality. As Heaven is not so much a "place" as a "state" of loving God, justice – towards God and towards the sinner – cannot force love out of one who chooses not to love.
Heaven or Hell ultimately depend on taking seriously the reality of human freedom, which finds its ultimate challenge in love, and which then includes the possibility of not loving. It remains a matter of justice and love: justice in respect of one's free choice, love in the sense of God not forcing Himself unrequitedly on the one who does not love Him.
While this explanation is traditional, it does not necessarily ring true to today's ears. Most people seem to imagine a "happily ever after" scenario where, somehow, God's persistence will ultimately triumph over human obstinacy, bringing all to true love of God.
If human life is any indication – and many of these same people are big on "experience" – we know that a lover's diligence notwithstanding, there are cases where that love is refused and refused definitively. Partisans of this view do not explain how God somehow ...
Mais episódios de "The Catholic Thing"



Não percas um episódio de “The Catholic Thing” e subscrevê-lo na aplicação GetPodcast.








