Talking About Marketing podcast

Balancing Your Bot In Business

0:00
25:06
Recuar 15 segundos
Avançar 15 segundos

From a gentle book about communicating one small step at a time to a Godzilla prompt that wore out two teams, we explore why AI works best when a human starts it, polishes it and stays awake for the judgement call (and what happens to a bot army when nobody does).

Communication starts small. David gushes about Vinh Giang’s new book on becoming a better communicator without leaving your comfort zone for long.

David confesses his Godzilla prompt is awesome, a bit scary and a lot of work for the people downstream.

Steve spots the same lesson in a viral political post, where the bot comments turned into talking vegetables.

A Microsoft outage shows David why one basket is never enough. A 1980s chicken ad shows both hosts how far we’ve come.

Get ready to take notes.

Talking About Marketing podcast episode notes with timecodes

01:30 Person This segment focusses on you, the person, because we believe business is personal.
Small Steps, Safe Landings: Vinh Giang on Communicating Better

Small steps win. David recommends Vinh Giang’s book Before We Forget How to Connect. He suggests you listen to it, because Vinh voices every character himself. David first found Vinh on YouTube as a polished keynote speaker. Then he warmed to him when Vinh talked about how he learned to communicate. Vinh started school at five with no English and a lunchbox of rice and fish sauce that his classmates did not appreciate.

The method suits anyone who finds communication hard. Take one small scary step. Return to safety. Enjoy the gain, then take the next step. David saw the same need in his years of teaching and his master’s in strategic communications. Vinh used the same approach with his son Xander, who was diagnosed with autism at two. The book ends at a school assembly where Xander collects a prize for communication.

Steve asks what symptom should send you to this book. David has an answer for every small business owner. You know your product so well that you jump to a conclusion halfway through the customer’s sentence. Then you launch into your favourite story about the business. The customer has their own problem and their own reason for talking to you today, and a story that makes no sense to them costs you the deal. David finds this book gentler than others on the shelf, and far kinder than “follow my instructions and you’ll be fabulous”.

10:00 Principles This segment focusses principles you can apply in your business today.
The Godzilla Prompt and the Price of Judgement

Judgement costs energy. In his American role with Speakeasy Marketing, David built a scraper that searches the internet twice a week. It finds the five most relevant news items for small law firms. Then he built a content prompt he calls Godzilla, because it’s awesome and kind of scary. In eight minutes it turns each news item into three blogs, three emails, three LinkedIn posts and three Facebook posts, in the styles of Robert Collier, Ray Edwards and Drew Eric Whitman.

The copy is good, and a person still needs to polish it. That’s where the unexpected consequence arrives. David has been handing the marketing and writing team so much to polish that they have no time left for evergreen content, website work or anything that needs deep thinking. His takeaway: AI works best as human, AI, human. A tool that is a bit useful can quickly turn destructive when it tips a team’s week out of balance.

Steve recognises it from a complex website job this week. A Claude trained in the client’s voice produced draft content that sounded right. Someone still has to say yay or nay, and that proofreading was mentally draining. Then comes the cautionary tale. A viral Nigel Farage post about Andy Burnham drew comments that looked like bot output gone wrong, including “The onion is learning how to play the trumpet.” Judgement takes time and costs a lot of energy. As David puts it, no judgement means a big mess.

17:00 Problems This segment answers questions we've received from clients or listeners.
When Outlook Goes Down: The Accessibility Angle on the Microsoft Outage

Outlook went down. You’ll find plenty of commentary on the big Microsoft outage that hit Outlook, Teams and OneDrive, so Steve and David skip the technical post-mortem. They look at something many people missed.

David says nobody loves Outlook. For a blind person using accessibility software, though, it has the best accessibility of any powerful email package. During the outage he forwarded email from his iPhone to Gmail, opened it in webmail on his laptop and acted on it there. Every job took an extra five minutes. Gmail is slow and awkward for a blind user, but it got him through.

Steve’s lesson is about monopoly. Imagine a Microsoft phone and no Gmail account, and you’d have been stranded. Talking between different services can be frustrating, because each one wants to lock you into its world. The pain is worth it. David agrees, which is why he stays competent in three different environments. He can’t be without at least two of them.

20:00 Perspicacity This segment is designed to sharpen our thinking by reflecting on a case study from the past.
Red Rooster’s Wing Snack and the Uplift Test

Times have changed. To finish, Steve plays a 1980s Red Rooster ad for a wing snack at $1.99, built on a pun about a surname and a stereotype. David grew up in South Australia, where Red Rooster wasn’t around. In 1984 he was making friends with Vietnamese people who had been in Australia a year or two and were finding their feet in English. Even then, he says, he would have watched the ad and wondered whether we really had to do this.

Would it run today? David thinks an agency would say no, though some audiences would still laugh. Steve points out that humans learn through mimicry and enjoy the novelty of the other. The ad crosses the line because we’re more aware of the collateral damage when you milk a stereotype for a cheap laugh. David’s test is simple. The ad is culturally crass, and it uplifts nobody.

The segment ends where hungry podcasters always end up: a debate about the pecking order of chicken go-tos, a long drive for a whole bird, and the hope of wings that would make the trip a stone’s throw.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Mais episódios de "Talking About Marketing"