The Knysna Murders: Did They Get the Right Man?

In 2005, Jessica Wheeler and Victoria Stadler were murdered less than a month apart in Knysna.The crime scenes appeared very different. But investigators began to suspect that the two young women had been murdered by the same offender.Dr Gérard Labuschagne — then Commander of the SAPS Investigative Psychology Unit — was brought into the investigation to conduct a behavioural linkage analysis.DJ Heinrich van Rooyen was eventually convicted of both murders and sentenced to two life terms. But he has always maintained his innocence.In this episode of PROFILER, Gérard takes us inside the original investigation: how the murders were linked, how behavioural linkage works, the differences between MO and signature, why Van Rooyen became a suspect, the DNA and other forensic evidence, his changing versions of events, and what ultimately happened in court.We also hear from investigator Mike Bolhuis, who was involved in the case at the time.More than twenty years later, Van Rooyen remains in prison and arguments about his guilt continue.The linkage analysis concluded that one offender murdered both women. But was Heinrich van Rooyen that offender?Did they get the right man?Contact: [email protected]

What was it actually like to train as a criminal profiler at the FBI Academy at Quantico when profiling was still an emerging discipline?In 1990, Amsterdam homicide detective Carlo Schippers was selected to spend an entire year at Quantico, training and working alongside some of the pioneers of modern criminal profiling.John Douglas was running the unit. Carlo was taught by figures including Robert Ressler, Roy Hazelwood and Ken Lanning. His training included forensic pathology, abnormal psychology, studying solved murders and eventually working on real cases submitted to the FBI by police departments across the United States. It was also a remarkable moment in profiling history. The Silence of the Lambs had been partly filmed at the FBI Academy and was released while Carlo was there. He remembers taking the same elevator seen in the film down to the underground Behavioral Science Unit, watching the media descend on John Douglas and attending a special preview of the movie with FBI Academy staff. Carlo joins former head of the SAPS Investigative Psychology Section Dr Gérard Labuschagne and Paul Llewellyn to give a rare first-hand account of that year: how FBI profilers were trained, what the work actually involved, what Hollywood got wrong and how Carlo eventually took what he had learned back to the Netherlands and became the country's first profiler.Carlo also discusses his new book, Denken als de dader — Thinking Like the Offender, looking back across his 45-year police career and the reality of working with homicide, serial murder, sexual offending, missing persons, stalking and coercive control. [email protected]

Brian Mudyiwayana did not rely on force to find his victims.He relied on trust.Lt Col Elmarie Myburgh joins Paul Llewellyn and Dr Gérard Labuschagne to take listeners inside one of South Africa's most disturbing serial murder investigations.The discussion explores how promises of employment and relationships became methods of victim selection, how investigators linked murders across multiple towns through behavioural analysis, victimology and forensic evidence, and what Myburgh observed during her interview with Mudyiwayana after his conviction.The conversation also examines offender psychology, post-offence deception, rehabilitation, parole and why power, control and excitement became central to the court's understanding of the offender.Brian Mudyiwayana was convicted of six murders and sentenced to six life terms plus 17 years' imprisonment.

Most people assume someone caught with child sexual abuse material is simply looking at images. Investigators, psychologists and behavioural specialists see somethingvery different.In this episode of Profiler Africa, Paul Llewellyn speaks to Dr Gérard Labuschagne and Kirsten Clark about the psychology of child sexual offenders, the growth of online exploitation networks, and the landmark Gerhard Alberts case that helpedchange how South African courts approached these crimes.A discussion about offender behaviour, cognitive distortions, digital investigations, risk assessment, and the uncomfortable reality that some of the most dangerous offenders can appear completely ordinary.📩 [email protected]

The murders began appearing across southern Gauteng. Women were being raped, robbed and killed. As investigators started connecting the dots, a disturbing picture emerged — they were hunting a serial offender.In this episode, Paul Llewellyn is joined by former SAPS profiler and investigator Lt Col Elmarie Myburgh to revisit the case of Lazarus Tshidiso Mazingane, the man who became known as the Nasrec Serial Killer. Together they walk through the investigation as it unfolded, from the first signs of linkage to the arrest and conviction of one of South Africa's most notorious serial offenders.They also examine the behavioural themes at the heart of the case: escalation, victim selection, control, behavioural linkage and the investigative lessons that remain relevant today.📩 [email protected]🌍 plotshift.co.za

From the recent Pretoria Boys High controversy to the Primrose Primary shooting and the infamous Krugersdorp sword attack, South Africa has repeatedly been forced to confront the reality of violence in schools.In this episode of Profiler Africa, Paul Llewellyn is joined by Dr Gérard Labuschagne and former SAPS Investigative Psychology specialist Kirsten Clark to examine the warning signs that often emerge before violence occurs, the psychology behind threats and targeted attacks, and why schools frequently miss opportunities to intervene before tragedy strikes.The discussion explores threat assessment, leakage, grievance, behavioural warning signs, and the critical difference between punishment and prevention.📩 [email protected]🌍 plotshift.co.za

Chairperson of Parliament’s Portfolio Committee on Police, Ian Cameron joins Paul Llewellyn and Gérard Labuschagne to unpack South Africa’s collapsing murder detection system.The discussion explores shocking SAPS detection-rate statistics, overloaded detectives, gang violence, forensic failures, crime intelligence breakdowns, and the growing crisis of public trust in the justice system.The episode also examines the difference between detection, arrest, prosecution and conviction — and what happens to a society when murder stops carrying consequence.📩 [email protected]🌍 Plotshift Media

Former Hawks Provincial Commander SCI Brig. Danie Hall joins Profiler Africa to discuss 40 years inside SAPS and the evolution of detective work in South Africa.From serial killer investigations and undercover hitman stings to organised crime and investigative psychology, Hall reflects on the realities of policing, teamwork and violent crime investigations.📩 [email protected]🌍 plotshift.co.za

In January 2003, nine men were murdered inside a house in Sea Point, Cape Town, in what became known as the Sizzlers massacre. Only one person survived.In this episode of Profiler Africa, Paul Llewellyn speaks to Quinton Taylor — the sole survivor of the massacre — about his life before the attack, the events of that night, and the psychological aftermath of surviving extreme violence. The conversation explores:trauma and survivalCape Town’s underground sex industry in the early 2000sfear, resilience, and spiritualitythe long-term psychological impact of violenceQuinton’s memoir, I Don’t Want to DieA deeply personal and disturbing firsthand account of one of South Africa’s most infamous murder cases.📩 [email protected]🌍 plotshift.co.za

Tonight on Profiler Africa, Paul Llewellyn and co-host Gerard Labuschagne are joined by retired Cape Town detective Jonathan Morris — the man many criminals feared not because he used force, but because he understood them.Known as the Confessor Cop, Morris built a reputation for getting murderers, gangsters and serial killers to reveal the truth through preparation, patience and psychological pressure rather than brutality. In this episode, he reflects on the cases that defined his career — and the toll they took on him personally.We discuss:• how evidence, timing and respect often worked better than intimidation• the Jimmy Maketta serial killer case and securing confessions• the Sizzlers massacre and one of Cape Town’s most horrific crime scenes• inside the Taliep Petersen murder investigation• policing gang violence in some of Cape Town’s toughest areas• the Swanepoel case and solving the murder of a close friend and fellow officer• how detectives were trained to understand violent offenders• the hidden trauma many investigators carry after years on the job• why treating suspects like human beings often helped crack casesThis is more than a crime interview.It is a rare look inside the mind of a detective who solved some of South Africa’s darkest cases by understanding the people who committed them.Support Profiler Africa:Become a Member: https://www.youtube.com/@PROFILERAFRICA/joinBuy Me a Coffee: https://buymeacoffee.com/profiler#ProfilerAfrica #JonathanMorris #ConfessorCop #TrueCrimeSouthAfrica #CrimePodcast