Imperfect Mens Club podcast

Self-Validation: Everybody Claps Until They Don't

0:00
32:33
Recuar 15 segundos
Avançar 15 segundos

Season 5, Episode 43: Self-Validation: Everybody Claps Until They Don't

Overview

Mark and Jim sit down the morning after the midterm elections, with half the country feeling validated and the other half not. That sets up this episode of The Imperfect Men's Club, a conversation about validation, self-validation and what a man does with either one once he has it. Mark reads the definition of self-validation, the internal act of recognizing, accepting and making sense of your own emotions, thoughts and experiences without needing external approval. Then the two of them test it against real life.

Two pieces of good news get it started. Mark's LinkedIn post hits 5,000 impressions when he's used to about 500. Jim gets a letter from the CEO of the National Kitchen and Bath Association saying he's been accepted for a national committee role by unanimous decision, and the dopamine carries him right through the weekend. That's a big moment for a former cabinet maker who says he built the boardroom but never sat at the table.

From there, Mark and Jim work through a grid comparing validation and empowerment, then get into external validation, confidence, faith and why men are so bad at telling other people they're doing a great job. It's a conversation for any man trying to figure out how much other people's opinions should count, and what to do when the good news finally shows up.

Key Themes

1. Validation Looks Back, Empowerment Looks Forward

Jim brings a grid that splits the two. Validation deals with emotional reality. It acknowledges what is or has been felt, and it asks, "Am I allowed to feel or think this way?" Empowerment deals with practical agency. It prepares for what can be done next, and it asks, "What am I capable of doing about this?"

Mark's point is that the second part is optional. Good news can be available to you and still go unused. He wonders out loud what his own ratio is, how often he's turned validation into action versus saying thank you and moving on, and he admits he doesn't know the answer.

2. When External Validation Counts: One Opinion vs. 5,000 People

Mark starts out wary of external validation because you're just as likely to get unvalidated by somebody else as you are validated. Jim pushes back. One person's opinion can mislead you, but a collective group of people is a feedback mechanism, and 5,000 LinkedIn impressions say something worth building on. Mark's own reaction backs him up. As soon as he saw the number, he wanted to pour gas on the fire and find out who those people were and whether any of them took action.

Mark adds a limit, too. It depends on who the group is. His side didn't win the day in the election, and he says he doesn't feel any less validated about where he stands. What he feels is curiosity about what happens next.

3. Jim's Two Things Every Human Wants: To Matter and What We Don't Have

Jim shares a line he's been testing on people. We all want the same two things. Most people guess the first one, which is to matter. The second is what we don't have, or what we tell ourselves we don't have. Once we get it, the mind moves on to the next thing, and the loop starts over unless we slow down long enough to be grateful.

Jim says the list of people you really want to matter to starts big and ends up a very small room. He also connects it to belonging. A lot of men work solo now, and isolation makes all of this harder. An association, a church or a team gives you a place to matter.

4. Where Self-Validation Comes From: Confidence, Faith and the Only Opinion That Matters

Jim calls life a confidence game, where having none keeps you in your own way and having too much is a problem of its own. Mark thinks we start collecting that confidence young, from parents, coaches and teachers, and he's always been fascinated by the athlete who has no apparent reason to be confident and is anyway. His question is where that comes from.

Mark's answer for himself is faith. He came back to the practice of his Catholic faith, and now he regularly asks whether God, who's watching, would approve of what he's doing. If he gets a yes or a likely, he calls that a really powerful form of self-validation. Jim connects it to the champions who thank their higher power first after a Super Bowl or a World Series, whatever that belief may be for them. He then shares a quote that the only permission, the only validation and the only opinion that matters in our quest for greatness is our own. Mark's reason for building that inner strength is simple. Hardships are coming.

5. The Validation You Give Away: Why Men Forget to Celebrate Other People

Mark asks a question that flips the episode. We've talked about getting validated, so how about giving it? He wasn't raised to celebrate, and his kids still give him a hard time for it. When one of them brought home straight A's and mentioned a girlfriend got a Mercedes for doing the same, Mark's offer was ice cream. He says celebration is validation, and it's something he's still reminding himself to get better at.

Jim says we underestimate how much it matters, especially coming from someone in a position of power or respect. Mark's rule is that it has to be genuine. He doesn't mean kissing up to everyone all the time. When a waiter or waitress does a great job, he asks for the manager and tells them to do whatever they can to keep her. He says that changes their day, and none of us do it nearly enough.

Why This Episode Matters

A lot of men in the middle of their lives are running on other people's opinions and don't realize it until those opinions change. The promotion, the compliment and the big number on a post all feel great for about a weekend, and then the mind goes looking for the next one. Chase that long enough and, as Mark puts it, you're probably going to be disappointed most of the time. Plenty of men also get the good news and do nothing with it.

The Imperfect Men's Club exists for honest conversations like this one, with two guys who still get a dopamine hit from good news, and one of them still gets reminded by his kids to celebrate. If you're trying to depend less on other people's approval without pretending you don't like it, start here. Then send this episode to a man who needs to hear it. Better yet, tell him he's doing a great job first.

Listen, Subscribe and Review

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

Website

Mais episódios de "Imperfect Mens Club"