Hi-Phi Nation podcast

Police Discretion (Encore)

17/11/2026
0:00
43:15
Recuar 15 segundos
Avançar 15 segundos

Is a mobile home a home or a car? Is a car parked inside a home part of the home? The answer to these stoner philosophical questions determine the scope of police power. Over the last 100 years, the Supreme Court has presided over the expansion of police discretionary powers to stop, search, and arrest people through litigation over automobiles. In this episode from 2020, we look at the stories of those decisions, including Carroll, Ross, and Whren.


Then, we turn to the political morality of police discretion, and why John Rawls’ test of public reason places far more constraints on law enforcement than the Supreme Court ever would. We investigate the consequence of public reasons tests for targeted policing, racial profiling, and consider whether police should have the power to overrule democratically elected criminal laws. Guest voices include Sarah Seo, Brandon del Pozo, and archival audio from SCOTUS.


Brandon del Pozo’s book is called The Police and the State: Security, Social Cooperation, and the Public Good. Host Barry Lam’s new book is called Fewer Rules, Better People: The Case for Discretion, published by Norton.


Join Slate Plus to unlock full, ad-free access to Hi-Phi Nation and the rest of your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe directly from the Hi-Phi Nation show page on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Or, visit slate.com/hiphiplus to get access wherever you listen.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Mais episódios de "Hi-Phi Nation"