Collecting Issues-Comic Podcast podcast

X-Men: Elsewhen Vol. 1 (2026) – John Byrne’s Dark Phoenix What-If?

0:00
1:07:08
Recuar 15 segundos
Avançar 15 segundos

What if Jean Grey survived the Dark Phoenix Saga? John Byrne finally answers that question his way in X-Men: Elsewhen Vol. 1 (Marvel, 2026). It started as Byrne’s own fan project on his blog and picks up the Claremont/Byrne X-Men at the moment Jim Shooter changed everything.


On this episode of Collecting Issues, the monthly comic book club podcast, Ben and Mick look at what Byrne brings back:


  • Low-powered, street-level X-Men
  • Wolverine back to being an unpleasant little guy with knife hands
  • A grotesque MODOK in the Savage Land
  • A Magneto with no redemption arc
  • A new breed of Sentinel that siphons mutant powers


We also get into:


  • The art, including the jumps in style when Paul Willis takes over
  • The Fantastic Four nearly taking over the book
  • Sebastian Shaw wearing far too many clothes
  • The parts that didn’t age well: some rough lines on autism and a very dark turn in Jean’s storyline
  • Why it reads less like a meta takedown of Chris Claremont and more like a straightforward, nostalgic 80s X-Men comic


There will be spoilers. It’s a book club, not a review show.


Next month we close out the year with Get Jiro! by Anthony Bourdain (Dark Horse).

Follow us on social and subscribe to our Substack for the Collecting Issues Christmas gift guide for comic book lovers.

X-Men Elsewhen, John Byrne X-Men, Dark Phoenix Saga, Chris Claremont, Jean Grey, Phoenix, Wolverine, Kitty Pryde, Magneto, Sentinels, MODOK, Fantastic Four, X-Men 97, Marvel comics 2026, comic book podcast, comic book club, X-Men review


Find us

Join the Discord and read along

Read Our Substack

Follow us on Instagram

Follow us on Tiktok

Watch us on Youtube


Time Stamps:


00:00 Preview Seven Sentinels

00:30 Welcome to Collecting Issues

04:07 The premise: Byrne's alternate X-Men timeline

10:13 The Phoenix turning point and Jim Shooter

14:49 Savage Land, Sauron and MODOK

24:29 Artwork, colouring and changing styles

32:43 Father and Son- new mutants and Xavier

40:42 Wide Awake-Sentinels and representation

45:34 Byrne versus Claremont-Wolverine and the Fantastic Four

54:23 Magneto-villain or antihero?

56:09 Jean, the Phoenix and the ending

01:00:28 Final verdict and what comes next

01:05:54 Recommendations, next month and where to follow


#XMenElsewhen #JohnByrneXMen #DarkPhoenixSaga #ChrisClaremont #JeanGrey #Phoenix #Wolverine #KittyPryde #Magneto #Sentinels #MODOK #FantasticFour #XMen97 #MarvelComics2026 #ComicBookPodcast #ComicBookClub #XMenReview

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Mais episódios de "Collecting Issues-Comic Podcast"