Road Cycling Academy Podcast podcast

3D-Printed vs Traditional Cycling Saddles: Which Is Better?

0:00
12:44
Recuar 15 segundos
Avançar 15 segundos

Summary:

Are 3D-printed cycling saddles actually better than traditional saddles, and do you need to spend hundreds of dollars to get a good one?

3D-printed saddles have become increasingly common, using lattice-style padding that allows manufacturers to fine-tune the amount and feel of the padding. But according to expert bike fitter Neill Stanbury, a higher price doesn't necessarily mean you're getting a better saddle.

In this episode of the Road Cycling Academy Podcast, Cam Nicholls is joined by expert bike fitter Neill Stanbury to compare 3D-printed cycling saddles with more traditional foam-padded designs.

Neill explains how a typical 3D-printed saddle is constructed, from the rails and shell through to the TPU upper. He discusses how manufacturers can change the structure of the lattice to fine-tune the padding and why the process differs from producing a traditionally covered saddle.

They also discuss price, including the significant difference between relatively inexpensive direct-from-China 3D-printed saddles and premium options from major cycling brands.

Durability is another consideration. Neill discusses issues he observed with some earlier 3D-printed saddles and how more recent examples appear to be holding up, while also comparing them with the way padding can deteriorate over time on some traditional saddles.

But the discussion ultimately comes back to fit. The construction method and price don't determine whether a saddle will work for a particular cyclist. Shape and compatibility with the individual rider remain critical when choosing a saddle.

In this episode:

  • What makes a cycling saddle 3D-printed
  • How the rails and shell compare with a traditional saddle
  • What TPU is and how it's used in 3D-printed saddle padding
  • How the lattice structure of a 3D-printed saddle is produced
  • Why different lattice structures can change the feel of the padding
  • How 3D-printed and traditionally covered saddles differ in manufacturing
  • Why traditional saddle construction can require more manual labour
  • How much 3D-printed saddles can vary in price
  • Why Neill questions the high price of some premium 3D-printed saddles
  • How manufacturers can fine-tune padding through the printed structure
  • Durability issues Neill saw with some early 3D-printed saddles
  • How more recent 3D-printed saddles appear to be holding up
  • Why the padding in some traditional saddles can deteriorate over time
  • Whether Neill would like to see a 3D-printed SMP saddle
  • Why saddle shape remains important regardless of padding technology
  • Why some racers are using lower-cost 3D-printed saddles
  • Why an expensive 3D-printed saddle isn't automatically the right saddle
  • Why the best saddle is ultimately the one that fits the rider

The construction and price of a saddle don't tell you whether it will work for your body. 3D printing offers some interesting advantages, but saddle shape and individual fit remain central to finding the right option.

Road Cycling Academy helps recreational and amateur cyclists train smarter, improve their performance and get more from the limited training time they have available.

If you're unsure which saddle is right for you or want to better understand your overall position on the bike, RCA's Bike Fit Fundamentals provides a step-by-step approach to understanding and improving your bike setup.

#RoadCycling #CyclingSaddles #3DPrintedSaddle #BikeFit #CyclingComfort #CyclingTips #BikeFitting #CyclingPerformance #RoadCyclingAcademy #NeillStanbury

Transcript:

Cam Nicholls (0:01)
Welcome to the RCA podcast designed for recreational and amateur road cyclists with a focus on performance. We dive into cycling training, nutrition, strength training for cyclists and even bike fitting tips, all designed to help you train smarter, ride faster and hopefully tear your mate's legs off. So without further ado, let's dive into today's episode.

Welcome back to the RCA podcast which is also on YouTube. Today I'm joined by expert bike fitter, Neil Stanbury. And today, Neil, we're going to be talking about 3D printed versus standard saddles.

My good friend here, the S&P Nimba next to me.

Neill Stanbury (0:41)
Look at it.

Cam Nicholls (0:42)
Isn't it beautiful? It is beautiful. What's best? 3D printed or standard?

And perhaps before you tell us what's best, for those, I think some people may not know what a 3D printed saddle is. So can you just give us a bit of a rundown?

Neill Stanbury (0:54)
Yeah, it's quite complicated. I wish I knew more about this, but I'm going to hopefully explain it as best as I can.

What they do when they're making a 3D printed saddle, generally speaking, the rest of the shape is the same except for the upper.

So you're going to have the same rails, in this case, some carbon molded rails. You're going to have the same shell, generally speaking, underneath it, which gives you the general shape of the seat. The difference is obviously in the upper.

So this is all the same on the bottom. The upper is an open-cell type of TPU. It's a thermoplastic poly something, one of those.

I think there's a couple of different versions of this, but it's basically a rubberized plastic. It has some flex. It has some give. It's not rock hard, obviously.

And they weave it typically into a hexagonal open-cell shape. Some of them you'll see like this Riot one here. It's got a different profile, different contour, different type of print that the machine has made.

And this has got a different upper surface compared to the one that I just had in my hands from the same company, which is a much more open-cell. And here again on my left is another one which has got an even different style of print.

Now how they make these essentially is that they'll make the shell. They'll make the rails. They bond them to each other.

They stick them in a jig and they stick them in a 3D printer, which is essentially a nozzle head which extrudes the plastic, the rubberized plastic.

It extrudes it in three dimensions, hence 3D printer. It is literally like a print head that's extruding the material constantly.

Each one of these, I'm not sure how fast they are now, but last time I looked into this, this would take quite a long time to make in the printer. This might be in the printer for like six hours.

Six hours?

Possibly more.

But aren't they like a $800?

Ah, so we'll get onto that in a second.

Cam Nicholls (2:46)
Versus the specialized ones are like $800 or something ridiculous.

Neill Stanbury (2:49)
There is some subtle variances in the pricing, which we'll try and shed some light on in a minute. So stick around for that.

But I believe they, look, the printers might be getting a lot faster. It wouldn't surprise me if they're spitting these things out in 30 minutes now.

But you do need time for the plastic or the thermo-molded plastic, plasticized rubber to essentially harden. As the nozzle head passes, it has to harden into that shape.

So you can't go super fast or it'll all be sloppy and floppy and it won't harden. So the head has to move fairly slowly. So you're looking at plenty of time to make them.

What you're not looking at is plenty of skill.

So when you make one of these, which is a standard Satellis, an SLR Boost Endurance, I think, you have to have a skilled worker who can cover this.

Like literally, I think they cover them by hand and they will tuck the covering in underneath it. They'll glue it. They'll probably brush it as well.

I think these are, yeah, I think these are still made in Italy.

These ones are, aren't they?

They are. Yeah, the Eagles.

Yeah. That's what makes them so amazing, mate.

Yeah.

I just can't keep my hands off it.

It really is a thing of beauty, isn't it?

So this requires skill and it requires labor to produce.

The foam that's underneath is nothing special. A few cents worth of extruded or expanded foam. And the covering, probably moderately expensive to make, but the materials are not very expensive.

But the labor, you have to have skilled technicians to make them perfectly.

This, you need a printer and a button. Go.

And you come back in whatever number of hours and it's ready to go. You can have 50 printers going at once because they're not that expensive generally in the big scheme of things. And you can pump these things out on an assembly line really quick.

In addition, the TPU is very cheap, very cheap.

Right. This Riot air code in front of me here, where do I go? I've got another Riot. This is the Ultimate. These come out of China. These are very high quality seats.

Cam Nicholls (4:47)
We've spoken about these in the past. I'm just thinking as we're going through this, my two favorite saddles, the one in your left hand there and that one. The polar opposite actually.

Neill Stanbury (4:56)
Yeah, exactly.

Cam Nicholls (4:57)
One's handmade and the other one comes out of a- How does that work? And they're completely different shapes.

Yeah.

Neill Stanbury (5:03)
Very interesting. Yeah, very interesting. We'll delve into that in another video.

Cam Nicholls (5:06)
Okay, exactly.

Neill Stanbury (5:07)
Because they are about as different as you can get realistically, but both of them work for you.

So where was I going with this? Yes.

So you can produce one of these Riots and sell it through the international marketplace and ship it to Australia for around $80 Australian dollars, which is crazy. Absolutely crazy. Amazingly cheap.

What that tells me is that the TPU is cheap. It's very, very cheap. You might be looking at a dollar or $2 worth of material actually printed onto the top of the shelf.

Right. And really, really cheap.

Now Specialized, for example, will sell their Roman Evo Pro 3D, whatever it's called. It's got a million names, 600 odd bucks with the carbon rails.

They are selling a lifestyle. This is not an expensive way to produce a saddle.

That is insane, which is why I hate that style. There's certain amounts of profiteering I don't mind too much in our industry, but a $600 saddle that's TPU printed.

The reason these are so cheap is because this is actually cheaper to make than a regular style saddle.

So 3D printing is fantastic as a cheap way of producing a seat. It also can produce beautiful, graduated and what's the word, curated levels of padding.

The latest versions of this AirCode, the padding is just perfect. It's not too hard. It's not too soft. It's beautifully done.

Same with the Ultimate here and this other one, which I can't tell you much about because the secret's real business.

This one has beautifully produced padding, which is fantastically done. It's just not too hard. It's not too soft.

You can iterate the padding level.

Because there's no human error in those, is that why?

Yep.

You can just print a more open cell weave or a more closed cell weave and change it in tiny increments. You can iterate it really quickly and easily until you get exactly the right amount of padding.

Some of these are done absolutely beautifully. They're just fantastic.

You can buy a lot of these for sub-$100 Australian dollars, which is like $65 US because it's a cheap material to produce saddles with and it works really well.

Some of the early ones had trouble with the chamois cream wicking through your nicks and destroying the material, making it fold and crack.

I haven't seen that in a long time. It was particularly endemic amongst the early specialized ones.

I haven't seen it for a long time. I think they've fixed all of those reactivity issues with the material.

These last really well all of these, I'm not seeing them coming apart, ripping, falling apart, cracking any more than I'm seeing something like that come apart or rip or crack or have the material fold back or collapse in the padding, any of that sort of stuff.

Cam Nicholls (7:52)
This podcast is brought to you by the Road Cycling Academy.

If you're struggling with a sore back, numb hands, neck pain, or simply feel uncomfortable on the bike or worse yet you feel like your power transfer is not optimal, our BikeFit Fundamentals program could be exactly what you need.

Created by the world-renowned bike fitter Neil Stanbury, BikeFit Fundamentals is a simplified online step-by-step program that helps you understand and improve your position on the bike.

One of our RCA members recently via a Google review shared that for years he suffered from lower back pain and numb arms while riding.

He tried professional bike fits, different saddles, stems, and countless adjustments, sound familiar, but nothing seemed to work.

He couldn't ride for more than two hours without back pain.

After working through BikeFit Fundamentals, he made a series of changes to his Q-factor, that's stance, width, saddle position, cleat setup, and his cockpit, and the result, he was able to increase his training volume from circa six hours per week to over 12 hours a week with no back pain.

What he loved most wasn't just the outcome, it was finally understanding what to change, why to change it, and what he should feel like when it's done right.

If you'd like to become more comfortable, more efficient, and get more out of every ride, check out BikeFit Fundamentals on the Road Cycling Academy website with Neil Stanbury.

Now let's get back to the podcast.

What about the general wear? Because I know these wear down to a point, there's only a small amount of padding in there, so you always say you've got to replace these, what, once every two or three years or something like that?

SMPs are a bit unique.

Neill Stanbury (9:34)
As much as I love this shape, I do not love the padding that they use, because it does collapse within two to five years for most people.

Are you finding that with the 3D, or it's too early to tell?

It's too early to tell, but generally, no.

I'm seeing people that have had these Riot ones, for example, for a couple of years, they look brand new still.

Cam Nicholls (9:52)
Yeah, okay.

Neill Stanbury (9:52)
These ones have a habit of collapsing over time, and I don't love that, but man, the shape is fantastic for a lot of people.

Cam Nicholls (10:00)
Yeah, okay.

Neill Stanbury (10:01)
So there you go. That's 3D printed saddles, mate. Any other good questions while we're on the topic?

No.

Are you going to go to your standard saddles now?

If someone made a 3D printed SMP, yes, but they haven't gone down this path yet.

I'm wondering if they might have one in the works. It'd be nice to see.

They have got a couple of new models, which have got less of the logos. They're more of a blacked out one, but they're still a standard memory foam style thing.

I would be really interested to see a 3D printed SMP.

So if the guys in Italy are thinking of doing something new, please, I would love to see a Nimba or a Blaster, in my case, with some nicely molded TPU and maybe a slightly lower entry price.

Cam Nicholls (10:42)
Yeah. There is a pattern on the Eagle, isn't there?

Oh, yeah.

Yeah. So it would have to be SMP.

Yes. Yes.

Neill Stanbury (10:48)
They have a number of very tightly held patterns around the shape. As you would if you had a saddle shaped like that.

And it's fair enough because it is unique and it is fantastic.

In my experience, probably still the best style of seat, generally speaking, in the world.

Cam Nicholls (11:04)
So, I mean, really the best saddle is the one that fits the rider.

And from your experiences, the 3D are a great option in terms of quality, in terms of build design, ergonomics, wear. It's ticking a lot of boxes.

And I think probably the biggest takeaway from me listening to you talk today is don't lean into these really expensive prices you're seeing from these brands.

Don't want to throw Specialized under the bus because they're not the only ones. Everyone does.

With the 3D printed because ultimately, and I know a couple of the guys that race in RCA bikes online use the rides and they love it.

So they're being used at an elite level as well, at least here in Australia.

I see them all the time.

Neill Stanbury (11:45)
A lot of those guys prefer the style of seats.

And when you're putting them on the ground every now and again at $500 or $600 a pop and you tear the edge off the thing, it can get very expensive.

And they are literally a cheaper way to make a saddle.

And I think it's great. The big brands have got to come down closer to the price margins of the direct from China guys.

Yeah. Okay.

Cam Nicholls (12:08)
Well, look, if you're in the market for a new saddle and you're wondering which is the right one for you, Neil and the RCA, we've put together a program called BikeFit Fundamentals, tutorials, downloadable guides, and an online community, which you're actually in there responding to questions.

Each and every question I see you respond to. So good on you for that.

I'm pretty motivated in there, mate. Keeping it going.

But there's a module, module five is on crank length and saddle selection.

It is indeed.

Yeah. So if people are interested in doing a deep dive there, we'll provide a link below and we'll catch everyone in the next podcast.

Mais episódios de "Road Cycling Academy Podcast"