The Blue Ridge Breakdown podcast

Thom Hartmann Breaks It Down: Oligarchy vs. Democracy, From Mesopotamia 11000 BC to Minneapolis 2026

0:00
30:34
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

At a moment when democracy itself feels increasingly fragile at home and abroad, I sat down with Thom Hartmann to talk about power, oligarchy, and what he calls “humanity’s ancient way of living.” We discuss the historical roots of democracy, the rise of modern technocratic elites, the long arc from the New Deal to Project 2025, and why the struggle between democracy and authoritarianism is not new, but newly urgent. This conversation is wide-ranging, candid, and grounded in history, with an eye toward what comes next.

Below is a transcript generated in part using Alice.ai and ChatGPT.

You can watch and listen to The Blue Ridge Breakdown across the internet

This conversation is available on YouTube, Apple Podcasts, and Spotify, with clips and highlights on Troy’s Instagram.

Troy MillerThom Hartmann is America’s number one progressive talk radio host. You can find him daily from noon to 3 Eastern, 9 to noon Pacific, pretty much anywhere you can find radio, or progressive radio at that. And he’s the New York Times bestselling author of dozens of books, one of which is The Hidden History of American Democracy: Rediscovering Humanity’s Ancient Way of Living, another of which is The Last Hours of Ancient Sunlight, which I’m very proud to have worked on the updated edition of.

Before we get too much further: Thom, welcome back to The Blue Ridge Breakdown. Thanks for joining us.

Thom HartmannThanks, Troy. It’s always nice to hang out with you. My cat says hi, too.

Troy MillerThom, as we’re recording this on January 14, 2026, I see basically everywhere I look, from the sort of intraparty Democratic level out to the streets of Minneapolis, out to the streets of Venezuela, this sort of existential question of: are we, the people, going to be in charge of our future here?

Are we going to be able to do something about the existential crises of machine learning, artificial intelligence, automation, all of this? The existential crisis of climate change? Elon Musk has said that don’t bother squirreling away money anymore for retirement because in 10 or 20 years it’ll be irrelevant. Says a guy who’s about to be a trillionaire.

And in the streets of Minneapolis, I think we’re seeing the same sort of thing play out, whether we’re going to have a bunch of masked bandits who are accountable only to Kristi Noem and Donald Trump basically roaming the streets and deciding who is ripe for violence, or whether we’re going to take control of our country.

And the parallels—I see the end of the Roman Republic into the Empire stages. I see the British, the Boston Massacre has been coming to mind as I look at Minneapolis. FDR talked about in one of his inaugural addresses: we fought the enemy without in the American Revolution; we fought the enemy within in the Civil War; and at the time, FDR was saying that we were again confronting the enemy without with Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany and imperialist Japan. I think we’re facing the enemy within again today.

So with all of that, one of the reasons I really wanted to talk to you today, and in the midst of all of this, is that you have literally written a book on American democracy and rediscovering humanity’s ancient way of living.

So with all of that as primer, what do you mean when you’re talking about reclaiming humanity’s ancient way of living, for one? And for two, what do we have with American democracy? How is this so special? Why is this so special?

Thom HartmannYeah, well, I mean, what we have right now is increasingly oligarchy in the United States, unfortunately. But yeah, democracy is the oldest operating system for humanity. Virtually every aboriginal or Indigenous tribe around the world is organized democratically or something close to it.

That’s the system that the founders of this country—Madison and Jefferson and Franklin in particular—they were the three who had a lot of interactions with Native Americans as they were growing up and throughout their lives, particularly Jefferson and Franklin.

And what they observed was democracy actually happening in these communities, the largest of which, of course, was the Haudenosaunee Confederacy.

And so this message—that there is a way that humans can live where power flows from the bottom up, not the top down, where government derives its authority from the consent of the governed, to quote the Declaration of Independence—it’s a principle that really, really resonates with people.

And it has, all around the world, over and over and over again, at least in the modern era, the last 200 years, changed governments and changed the way people live.

There’s always been a dynamic tension. You could argue that the rise of—well, in fact, Daniel Quinn makes this argument very cogently in his book Ishmael, which is a novel, but it’s just brilliant. I used to know Dan before he passed away—that we were always largely democratic prior to the agricultural revolution.

And what happened with the agricultural revolution was suddenly we went from basically everybody being involved in food production—mostly the men hunting, mostly the women gathering, but nonetheless everybody involved in food production—to a very small number of people being in charge of food production, those being the farmers.

And the farmers quickly discovered that they could lock up the food. And because without food, after a couple of weeks you die, or a couple of months depending on what your stores are like in your body, this became the power of life or death.

And thus came the original kings and kingdoms. It was all based on locking up the food, on controlling the critical resources—food, water, transportation, stuff like that.

So I think in that context you could make the argument that the post-agricultural revolution era from 7,000 years ago up until about 200 years ago was an argument for oligarchy and kingdom and authoritarian governance.

Because everybody said all these advances that we made from the Stone Age literally to the modern technological age happened during times of kings and kingdoms and emperors and princes and all that kind of stuff.

I’ve heard that argument made over and over again throughout the years. And the corollary argument, which was being made in a big way during FDR’s time, was that if you try to insert too much democracy, you’re going to end up with chaos. This was Russell Kirk’s The Conservative Mind.

And I think what we’ve found, what we’ve learned, is that even—or particularly maybe with the experiment of democracy in the United States and in northern Europe—high levels of democracy, high levels of diffusion of power, high levels of participatory democracy, where power flows from the bottom up, actually enhance the growth of economies and enhance the development of innovation and things like that.

But there’s always been this dynamic tension between democracy and autocracy.

And the autocrats—you’ve got right-wing billionaires. One famously said he’s increasingly convinced that democracy and freedom are incompatible. That was, I believe, Peter Thiel.

You’ve got others saying women shouldn’t have—well, again, it was Peter Thiel—saying the biggest mistake we made was letting women vote.

These are very powerful and influential people. J.D. Vance wouldn’t be vice president without Peter Thiel.

And so there’s this broad skepticism about democracy among the tech bros and the dark-enlightenment figures. And I see that as probably the biggest challenge that we have going forward, outside of the Trump administration’s naked attempts to turn us into a dictatorship.

Troy MillerRight. I mean, I honestly see these guys in the wings basically just allowing Trump to have a nice big playpen of whatever, knowing that he’ll be gone soon enough and then they’ll be able to implement whatever they want.

And Peter Thiel has also said basically that he doesn’t know why he should have to go and appeal to people who are never going to agree with him. Let’s use technology to basically go around the institutions of politics and the democrat…



Get full access to The Blue Ridge Breakdown at blueridgebreakdown.substack.com/subscribe

More episodes from "The Blue Ridge Breakdown"