The Blue Ridge Breakdown podcast

“Budgets Are Moral Documents” — And Patrick Morrisey's Budget is Damning

0:00
40:43
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

West Virginia’s latest round of policy decisions raises a simple question: what are we actually prioritizing? In this conversation with Seth DiStefano of the West Virginia Center on Budget and Policy, we walk through proposed cuts to childcare assistance, the expansion of the HOPE Scholarship, and the push for data centers across the state. Each issue on its own might seem technical. Taken together, they tell a much clearer story about who benefits, who pays, and what kind of future is being built.

Troy Miller: Welcome back to the Blue Ridge Breakdown. It has been a moment, but, you know, the world goes on. And we are here to try to break down some of. Some of what’s gone on in the last month, especially here in Jefferson county in West Virginia. And to that effect, I’m thrilled to be joined today by Seth DiStefano, who is the senior Policy outreach director for West Virginia Budget and Policy.

Troy Miller: West Virginia Budget and Policy. You can find them at wvpolicy.org it’s w v p o l I c y dot org and first of all, Seth, thanks for taking the time to join me this morning.

Seth DiStefano: Of course. Thank you for having me on, Troy.

Troy Miller: I appreciate it and appreciate all the great work you guys. You all do over there at the center for Budget and Policy. It’s a tremendous resource for people are trying to actually get some information about things start. There’s so much to cover. There’s so many things from cuts to children’s assistance, which is where we’ll start.

Troy Miller: The HOPE Scholarship, which I would argue is also cuts to children’s assistance, the data centers, health care, everything under the sun. But let’s start with Governor Morrissey wants to take $40 million away from children’s assistance and clothing assistance. And that’s $40 million out of what, so far as I can tell, is $140 million budget.

Troy Miller: So that’s, you know, fully a third of what is budgeted there. What’s going on here? Why do you think he would take this sort of. Why is this the program? And I guess why might not be the first question to start with, because that might be not quite what you want to answer. We don’t know his motivations, but what the hell’s going on here?

Seth DiStefano: That’s a great question, Troy. Thank you for kind of kicking things off with this one.

Seth DiStefano: I’m sure folks who regularly tune into your podcast or anyone around the state who’s been watching any form of news this week, saw that Governor Morrissey had a press conference on Monday afternoon, Monday at 1pm where he announced, you know, several areas where he feels state government can save money and should be saving money.

Seth DiStefano: And to put that money towards other things, namely filling potholes, I believe was the cause du jour, which I’m all about filling potholes. I think we could be doing a lot more of it. And you ask anyone in West Virginia or any lawmaker, they’ll tell you the number one thing people contact them about is fixing up roads.

Seth DiStefano: Unfortunately, one of the things that Governor Morrissey for some reason, zeroed in on was clothing vouchers, clothing assistance for poor children, and childcare assistance for families via the West Virginia Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program, which is referred to as tanf. You know, TANF is a federally matching program. West Virginia puts up money.

Seth DiStefano: It gets an equal matching amount back. And there are several initiatives that are funded through the TANF program, two of those being clothing vouchers for poor kids, essentially, and childcare assistance for working families who are struggling to make ends meet. And so I think that just one of the reasons I’m glad we kicked it off with this is it politically. It’s a real head scratcher.

Seth DiStefano: This has landed like a lead balloon all across the state. I mean, there has been multiple people kind of within the state legislature who have very clearly said, no, we’re not. I’m not going to support the health chair in the House of Delegates. Evan Worrell has been quoted as saying he is not supporting any cuts to clothing vouchers or childcare assistance.

Seth DiStefano: You are seeing family resource networks who rely often TANF funds and do great work. You know, you talk about a loaves and fishes, and we’re organizations that really provide far more in services to families than whatever they take in. It’s our FRNs and family resource centers really out there telling folks and raising the alarm. And I just, I have to wonder two things essentially.

Seth DiStefano: The first of which I would point out if you followed the state legislature this year, I think it’s fair to say that there was only one truly consensus, you know, one kumbaya issue to arise from the fold in the legislature, and that was support for childcare.

Seth DiStefano: There was really only one bill that, that people stood up and said on a bipartisan basis, across the board, floor speeches, the whole nine yards, you know what? We have to do this. It was a bill to support childcare and specifically, I believe, child care centers. And at this time, I would give a big shout out to the West Virginia association for Young Children Team for WV Kids Moms Rising.

Seth DiStefano: My executive director, Kelly, has put a lot of work into this over the past several years and that that coalition really built child care into an issue that could not be ignored politically anymore.

Seth DiStefano: And to their credit, they have really lifted the profile of, you know, supporting child care and supporting child care centers to the point where it was just across the board, you know, lawmakers standing up saying, yes, we must do this and we have to do more, right? It wasn’t just we have to do this, it was, this is just the we have to continue to do more.

Seth DiStefano: And so for Governor Morrissey in the face of that to come out and say, you know what, I’m going to come after childcare doesn’t exactly make a ton of sense to me. Like, if anything, you would think he would see the writing on the wall and embrace the fact that so many people across West Virginia are really supporting child care.

Seth DiStefano: And in the eastern panhandle, I think one could make the argument that because the cost of living out your way is significantly higher for families than it is in other parts of the state, support for childcare, I think, is an even more pertinent issue for your folks out there.

Seth DiStefano: I mean, like a two both parents having to work in the eastern panhandle, I think is probably more of a necessity than it is in other parts of the state, just because it does cost so much more to live out there. And so I wanted to kick things off and glad we did kick things off with this.

Seth DiStefano: This is something that is going to have to be monitored closely Wherein, you know, the legislature, as it is comprised of right now, not only came out and supported more investments for childcare, they very clearly, Republicans and Democrats, mind you, had said that this is simply the beginning. This is where we have to start.

Seth DiStefano: More has to be done if West Virginia is going to be competitive on a workforce participation basis and an economic development basis. And then the government comes in and says, Governor comes in and says, well, actually, no, we’re going to cut childcare subsidies. You know, something to pay close attention to in the weeks and months that follow.

Troy Miller: Yeah. And. Well, there’s a couple of things that I feel like, really I would, I would add to that, first of all, and I think this is really important, like table setting. And I think the audience will generally agree with me on this, is budgets are moral documents in many ways. And sorry, my video froze. We’ll keep trying to work on that as the interview goes on.

Troy Miller: But the budgets are moral documents. They are the list of priorities for many since Jim justice was bragging about the big surplus that …



Get full access to The Blue Ridge Breakdown at blueridgebreakdown.substack.com/subscribe

More episodes from "The Blue Ridge Breakdown"