Mentoring IRL podcast

Ep #38: How to Disagree with your Boss

9/14/2026
0:00
16:48
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Contact us: [email protected]

Disagreeing with Your Boss: How to Push Back Without Damaging Trust

What do you do when you disagree with your boss or customer? Speaking up can feel intimidating, particularly when the other person has significantly more authority or when the disagreement occurs in front of others.

In this episode, Angela Falcini and Bill Bonwit explore how mentors can help people navigate these difficult conversations. The goal isn't to “win” an argument. It's to understand the situation, contribute your perspective, find the best solution, and strengthen the relationship along the way.

Reframe Disagreement as Problem Solving

Disagreement doesn't have to be combat. Instead, approach it as collaborative fact-finding. Rather than trying to prove the other person wrong, seek to understand their reasoning and constraints.

That mindset can reduce anxiety and make it easier to have a productive conversation. Remember: discomfort is normal. As Bill emphasizes, getting comfortable being uncomfortable is part of growing as a leader.

Practical Tactics for Productive Pushback

Get curious first.

Ask questions such as, “What's driving the timeline?” or “How did we land on this approach?” Genuine curiosity may uncover information you don't have—budget constraints, executive commitments, deadlines, or other factors influencing the decision.

Separate the person from the position.

You can strongly disagree with an idea while remaining respectful toward the person presenting it.

Acknowledge their concerns.

Try identifying what you believe is driving the decision. This demonstrates that you've considered their perspective and gives them an opportunity to clarify.

Present concerns as questions, not verdicts.

Instead of saying, “I think this is the wrong direction,” try, “Help me understand how this holds up if X happens.” Questions invite collaboration rather than defensiveness.

Bring an alternative.

Don't simply identify a problem. Offer a potential path forward. Even an imperfect alternative demonstrates that you're invested in solving the problem rather than simply criticizing the decision.

Use the power of silence.

After making your case, give your boss time to process what you've said. Resist the temptation to immediately fill the silence or soften your position. Listening carefully—and allowing the other person to finish—can take much of the tension out of the conversation.

Be prepared to accept “no.”

Your boss may have information you don't have or may simply weigh the factors differently. If you've presented your concerns thoughtfully and the decision remains unchanged, that isn't a failure. Successfully voicing your perspective can actually build trust for future conversations.

Learn From Every Disagreement

The real development comes after the conversation. Mentors should encourage mentees to ask:

  • What worked?
  • What surprised me?
  • What would I do differently next time?

Mentees can also build confidence by observing experienced leaders handle disagreement in real time. Watching how a leader manages tone, pacing, questions, and awkward moments can teach lessons that no framework can fully capture.

The Bottom Line: Build Trust

Productive disagreement is ultimately about trust. When your boss knows that you're pushing back because you genuinely want the organization and team to succeed—not because you simply want to be right—your credibility grows.

The objective isn't to win the disagreement. It's to understand, contribute, and help the organization succeed.

More episodes from "Mentoring IRL"