It's Ben a Week podcast

I’ve Ben Murdered! (The Traitors Tell-All)

11/17/2026
0:00
46:11
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Spoiler Warning: This episode discusses major events and eliminations from The Traitors: New Blood.

I’ve been murdered. And now, I can FINALLY talk about it. 🩸

After months of keeping secrets, Ben McDonnell is officially out of The Traitors: New Blood—and he’s ready to unpack his experience inside the Scottish castle.

In this special solo episode of It’s Ben A Week, Ben reflects on the whirlwind of becoming a reality television contestant, the unexpected friendships, the strategy behind his game, and the moment he discovered that Katie and Shane had sent him packing.

But first, Ben is opening his secret diary.

Throughout his time on The Traitors, Ben kept a journal documenting his experiences, including his very first impressions of every cast member. Now, he’s reading those original notes aloud—and some of them are surprisingly accurate.

From immediately identifying his fellow “Dolls” to predicting that Michael might turn on him, Ben shares what he really thought about the cast before the game unfolded.

Then it’s time to talk strategy.

Ben reveals that he went into the experience absolutely determined to become a Traitor. In fact, he’d spent so much time planning how he’d play as a Traitor that he barely considered what he’d do if he was chosen as a Faithful.

He also explains why he suspected Tamika early on, why he deliberately avoided pushing for her banishment, and how he hoped keeping her in the game might eventually lead to his own recruitment.

Ben also opens up about the realities of playing an intense social strategy game, the friendships that formed, the challenges of watching the edited episodes, and why he believes viewers didn’t get to see some of the cast’s best moments.

And, of course, he’s answering YOUR questions.

Who did he trust the most? Who played the smartest game? Who surprised him when he watched the show back? Who was the biggest flirt? Who would he kiss, marry, and banish? Was he actually mad at Katie? And would he ever return for an All-Stars season?

Plus, Ben responds to the criticism surrounding New Blood, addresses comments made by a fellow cast member, and reveals why he has absolutely no regrets about how his time on the show ended.

From his first arrival at the castle to his final appearance in a fabulous fur coat, Ben is looking back on an experience that changed his life—and looking forward to whatever comes next.

In this episode:

  • Ben’s reaction to being murdered on The Traitors
  • How he became obsessed with the show
  • His first impressions of the entire cast
  • The secret diary he kept during the experience
  • Why he desperately wanted to be a Traitor
  • His strategy as a Faithful
  • Why he suspected Tamika but wanted to protect her
  • The surprising friendships he made
  • What viewers didn’t see in the shorter episodes
  • Why the game was more emotionally intense than expected
  • The fan reaction to New Blood
  • Why Ben wore his fur coat to his murder
  • The truth about his relationship with Katie
  • His biggest regrets and favorite moments
  • Which players impressed him most
  • Who he’d want on an All-Stars season
  • Why he introduced himself as a barrel racer
  • Which cast members he’s still closest with
  • His response to Michael’s interviews
  • Whether he’d ever return to The Traitors
  • What’s next for Ben and Season 3 of It’s Ben A Week

🎧 Subscribe to It’s Ben a Week
New episodes every week filled with unfiltered stories, wild guests, and brutally honest laughs. Hosted by photographer and professional barrel racer Ben McDonnell.

📍 Listen & Subscribe:
Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube | Amazon | Wherever you get your podcasts

🔗 Connect with Ben:
Instagram: @itsbenaweek
TikTok: @itsbenaweek
Website: itsbenaweek.com

💬 Want to be on the show?
Submit your story or pitch at itsbenaweek.com

More episodes from "It's Ben a Week"