It's Ben a Week podcast

We’ve Ben Unfollowed (ft. Eleven)

0:00
58:30
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Eleven is back on It’s Ben A Week—and somehow a casual catch-up turns into an hour-long therapy session about friendship, fame, social media and knowing when it’s time to let people go.

With Ben suddenly experiencing a new level of attention from The Traitors: New Blood, he’s noticing something strange: people are treating him differently. Old acquaintances are popping back into his DMs, people he’s known for years are suddenly acting differently around him, strangers are asking for photos, and everyone apparently “always knew” this was going to happen—even though Ben certainly didn’t. 

That leads Ben and Eleven into a much bigger conversation about friendship. They’ve known each other since 2015 and can go months—or even a year—without talking and immediately pick up where they left off. But not every friendship works that way. Some people are meant to stay, some belong to a particular season of your life, and others simply reach their expiration date without a dramatic fight or falling out.  

Then Ben makes a confession: he knows when you unfollow him.

And yes, sometimes he wants an explanation.

Ben and Eleven unpack the surprisingly complicated psychology of the Instagram unfollow, why Ben immediately unfollows people back, Eleven’s completely different approach to cutting people out of her digital life, jealousy, comparison and why social media can make friendships considerably more complicated than they need to be.

Eleven also reflects on once having around 600,000 YouTube subscribers, watching roughly half of that audience disappear as she moved away from beauty content, and learning that evolving publicly sometimes means losing people who only connected with an earlier version of you. 

Finally, Ben and Eleven answer listener questions about friendships, queer identity, making yourself smaller for other people, being misunderstood and figuring out who in your life actually gets you without needing an explanation.

In this episode:

  • Why people are suddenly treating Ben differently
  • Getting recognized after appearing on TV
  • Ben’s unexpected “gay cowboy” persona
  • Playing a straight cowboy as a gay actor
  • Why some friendships last decades and others expire
  • Drunk Ben’s entirely separate collection of friends
  • Finding your people after moving somewhere new
  • Friendship between queer men and women
  • Knowing when someone isn’t “your person”
  • Missing a wedding because of a Burning Man threesome
  • Why Ben needs closure when friendships end
  • The psychology of unfollowing someone
  • Why Ben knows exactly who unfollowed him
  • Jealousy and comparison on social media
  • Eleven losing hundreds of thousands of YouTube subscribers
  • Fame, attention and being put on a pedestal
  • Ben and AJ navigating Ben’s current career whirlwind
  • Listener friendship questions
  • Making yourself smaller to keep other people comfortable
  • Why communication might solve more than we realize

🎧 Subscribe to It’s Ben a Week
New episodes every week filled with unfiltered stories, wild guests, and brutally honest laughs. Hosted by photographer and professional barrel racer Ben McDonnell.

📍 Listen & Subscribe:
Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube | Amazon | Wherever you get your podcasts

🔗 Connect with Ben:
Instagram: @itsbenaweek
TikTok: @itsbenaweek
Website: itsbenaweek.com

💬 Want to be on the show?
Submit your story or pitch at itsbenaweek.com

More episodes from "It's Ben a Week"