ZINE podkast

Unplugging Is Not The Solution You Want

30.09.2024
0:00
19:00
Do tyłu o 15 sekund
Do przodu o 15 sekund

The crisis of endless troughs of content, outrage-bait, attention incentives, intermittent reward slot machine dynamics, comparative quantified self-worth, static profiles demanding fixed personal brands, Zoom-fatigue, and our weakening muscle of discerning fact from fiction it’s all just. too. much. for our brains to manage.

Statistics about our declining state of mental health amid our increases in screen time are not even needed to support any of tech’s effects. Pause and take a breath. You can feel it. That’s enough.

For remedies, we’ve been prescribed to delete our apps, curb notifications, turn our phones greyscale, invest in flip phones, and look away from screens two hours before bed. Oh, and especially don’t doom-scroll or check work email (same thing) as soon as you wake up. 

Whoops.

Meanwhile, the recommendations from the other extreme advise us to become more productive by upgrading our tool stacks — as if we can transform into machines, ourselves, dominating our problems with “hacks.”

Using more tech to defeat the pitfalls of tech? Nice try.

How many times have you plowed through your timed app limits in the last week?

Over the years, countless books and campaigns such as the Social Dilemma raised awareness and proposed the aforementioned solutions.

But I ask:

Has anything meaningfully changed over the last decade? No. Really.

What’s changed?

We now have TikTok. Screen time climbs higher. Our meditation apps interrupt us with push notifications urging us to return to their feed of more video content. A three year old is now impressively proficient with an iPad — good luck snatching that thing out of their clutch. Sludge content, unafraid, pleases our needs for stimulation. Hell, “brain-rot” is a phrase we don’t even question.

Meanwhile, techie public intellectuals pivoted to “AI safety” and now promote their podcasts and newsletters on the very platforms they were catastrophizing just a few years earlier. With the emergence of AI, we face an onslaught of new issues (consent, copyright, fictitious content, etc.) without ever adequately rectifying those which came before.

Most dramatic yet least questioned, AirPods and wearables continue to break sales records... Our tech is increasingly on and inside of our bodies. So much for “getting away.”

Via digital trackers, we willingly give away our heartbeat, body temperature, and DNA to companies without an iota of control. And we’re the ones paying them.

Whoops.

We’re heading in the opposite direction we’ve been proposing. We are no more better off since we’ve coined “the tech-lash” a decade ago.

Our interventions have failed.

Or did we even try?

With such a lack of any meaningful progress, perhaps we require a wholly different approach if we’re to experience a healthier, happier and more productive life with our devices, screens and apps.

Perhaps, we must mature our discourse beyond fighting against these issues, to accepting them.

It’s a strange word choice and seemingly antithetical to what we want, but bear with me...

Instead of unplugging, how may we become more mindful in embracing and strengthening our ability to live with these consequences?

Only then can we find better mastery with and over them.

You are not weak.

The Ignorance of Unplugging

In Digital Minimalism, one of the most popular books on developing a better relationship with modern tech, author Cal Newport writes,

“People don’t succumb to screens because they’re lazy, but instead because billions of dollars have been invested to make this outcome inevitable.”

To overcome this malicious investment against us, Cal urges readers to digital detox. Simply spend a month away from your screens to discover new hobbies and take up journaling.

Let me be clear: I could not agree more with this advice. We all need to touch more grass (or mosh), kindle both passions and meaning, establish new rituals, and engage in a habit of reflection. Absolutely. Yes.

But! I for one refuse to accept these (“detoxing”) tactics as comprehensive or sustainable in our current moment and, further, the moments which come next.

Unplugging is a short-term, unsustainable, selfish and frankly, privileged approach to the downsides of our everyday technological struggles.

While billions of “bad” dollars are spent hooking, billions of “good” dollars are spent onboarding more and more and more people around our planet online. Countries, states, townships, schools, hospitals and non-profits are all ensuring that every facet of society is accessible via a smartphone. This includes countries, which have historically been left behind — connection begets prosperity whether we like it or not. As a result, employment, banking, housing, education, dating, healthcare, you name it — the foundations of any functioning society are now only accessible online.

It takes a certain privilege to opt out.

I’m not alone in this controversial perspective.

Author and consultant, Venkat Rao, calls such harsh disconnection, “Waldenponding,”

“I'd like to try living off the grid for a bit in a log cabin, myself, for a summer or something. I'm also on board with trying and adopting experimental rituals like a no-devices sabbath day...

But as an attitudinal foundation for relating to society and technology, Waldenponding is, I am convinced, a terrible philosophy at both a personal and collective level.

It's a world-and-life negation. A kind of selfish free-riding, tragedy of the commons: not learning to handle your share of the increased attention-management load...”

[...]

“The way to manage your attention is not to ‘unplug’ or do some sort of bullshit Classical Liberal virtue signaling crap of ‘I only read Ancient Greek authors’ but to be sensitive to your current mind size and consciously target the zone you want to be in...”

What is it (Exactly) You’re Fighting Against?

New organizations are popping up to fight this “media addiction.” This is the equivalent of picking a fight with air.

I suppose these orgs don’t have an issue with cave paintings, which are just another form of social media. Books? Ok. eBooks? Ok. Book reviews? Ok. A book review on a social platform? Someone’s comment on a book review? A number which represents the number of people who agree with that book review?

Where exactly would you like to draw the line between kosher and caustic?

Concern and attention is a noble effort, but they — and we — require specificity and nuance in such conversations. Otherwise, we get more noise without change. This is where we are now.

What exactly makes cave paintings, art galleries, newspapers or bulletin boards acceptable forms of social media and how do we distinguish good vs. bad, and healthy vs. unhealthy? Is it algorithmic rankings geared toward engagement, no age minimums, endless feeds, abundance of metrics, growth-for-growth-sake business models, or something else? Pick those, not “media.”

We’ve got a lot to improve. But righteously banning, outlawing or withholding social tech and media means stripping away the support for millions dealing with mental health, alcoholism, religion, chronic illness, cancer, divorce, sexuality, or child raising.

This isn’t an all or nothing deal. Unplugging is a false binary.

That’s the computer thinking spreading amongst us like a virus. The very limiting 0’s and 1’s. Black and white. Disconnect and thrive or stay plugged in and rot. Why is it all or nothing? We are not machines — we’re better at thinking than that and than “them.”

Also, not for anything, have you actually tried leaving the house without a phone recently? How is that supposed to make us less anxious?

What’s Left Behind For Others

A frequent proposed resolution to this conundrum is: “Adopt self-restraint and create better habits.” Love it. How may we begin treat the Internet as a tool like a fishing rod? We only fish when we’re “hungry.”

The prickly flaw in this thinking is that unplugging does not reverse any psychological damage already inflicted upon us, nor does it eliminate the opportunities for others to also fall trap when yo…



This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit zine.kleinkleinklein.com/subscribe

Więcej odcinków z kanału "ZINE"