The Voice Science Podcast podkast

Words vs. Gestures: Which Do Singers Follow?

0:00
4:56
Do tyłu o 15 sekund
Do przodu o 15 sekund

📘 Teaching Singers to Practice: a guide for voice teachers on helping students practice with purpose between lessons. Get the guide

When a conductor’s gestures say one thing and their words say another, which one do singers follow?

In this episode, we look at a 2025 study by Grady, Manternach, Brunkan, and Nápoles. They recorded 102 collegiate singers in four choirs singing along with a silent video of a conductor. Before each video, spoken and on-screen instructions either matched the conducting gesture or contradicted it.

What they found

  • When words and gestures agreed, the choirs made about 50% more dynamic contrast: roughly 7 decibels, compared with under 5 when the messages conflicted.
  • When the messages conflicted, singers followed the verbal instructions in all but one case.
  • Conducting experience may matter: singers with more conducting experience may have attended more to the gestures.
  • About a quarter of singers’ comments noted that the gestures contradicted the directions.

The authors’ recommendation: rather than “do as I say, not as I do,” aim for “do what I say and I do.” Video-recording your rehearsals and lessons is one way to check that your words and your gestures are giving singers the same instruction.

Chapters

00:00 Turning to the other side of the room
 00:15 The study
 00:28 Three research questions
 00:55 Why mixed messages matter
 01:20 How the study worked
 01:40 Matching and conflicting instructions
 01:58 Agreement made for bigger dynamics
 02:30 The trickiest combination
 02:50 The melody may have played a part
 03:06 Which message did singers follow?
 03:15 Does experience matter?
 04:02 What singers said
 04:13 The authors’ recommendation
 04:40 More from VoSci

Study

Grady, M., Manternach, J., Brunkan, M., & Nápoles, J. (2025). Singers’ Responses to Congruent and Incongruent Verbal and Nonverbal Instructions. International Journal of Research in Choral Singing, 13, 125–137.

More episodes, articles, and the voice science lexicon: voicescience.org

Keep Singing Smart.

Więcej odcinków z kanału "The Voice Science Podcast"