Mind the GAP podkast

Dealing with corrections and retractions: keeping science sound

14.10.2024
0:00
31:13
Do tyłu o 15 sekund
Do przodu o 15 sekund

Science claims to be self-correcting through the system of corrections and retractions in journal publications. But how effective and comprehensive is this self-regulating system? How to deal with potential mistakes? What distinguishes a correction from a retraction? When are they needed and who makes the decision? Where do the responsibilities lie and for whom?

In this episode 3 guests share thoughts on this: Gert Storms, Full Professor at the Faculty of Psychology and Educational Sciences at KU Leuven and chairperson of the Flemish Commission for Research Integrity; Ivan Oransky, co-founder of Retraction Watch, a website reporting on retractions of scientific papers and related topics; Line Edslev Andersen, a philosopher and postdoctoral researcher at the Centre for Logic and Philosophy of Science at Vrije Universiteit Brussel.

In this episode, we cover:

  • The difference between corrections and retractions.
  • The procedure to make these adjustments to the scientific literature.
  • Why it is important to correct and retract literature
  • Why it is important to be transparent about this.
  • What to do when you suspect fraud/mistake in someone else’s paper.
  • The responsibility of all authors of the questioned publication.

----------------------------------------------------------------

This podcast series complements the online training tool 'Mind the GAP, training on Good Academic Practices'. Mind the GAP is an English-language training tool for all researchers and those involved in research, from PhD students to more experienced researchers, to teachers and policy makers.

If you are affiliated with a Flemish university you can find the tool on your institution’s educational platform:

Ghent University: Ufora

KU Leuven: Toledo

University of Antwerp: Blackboard

Hasselt University: Blackboard

Vrije Universiteit Brussels: Canvas

Not part of the above institutions? Go to https://mindthegap.vlir.be/ and follow the international version of the tool (condensed version).  

The Mind the GAP Podcast was jointly developed by VLIR (Flemish Interuniversity Council – Filip Colson) and the five Flemish universities (Ghent University – Stefanie Van der Burght; KU Leuven – Wouter Vandevelde; University of Antwerp – Marianne De Voecht; Hasselt University – Stephanie Ruysschaert;

Więcej odcinków z kanału "Mind the GAP"