Infinite Threads with Bob Barnett podkast

What Would It Take to Change Your Mind?

0:00
16:12
Do tyłu o 15 sekund
Do przodu o 15 sekund

This is Infinite Threads. I’m Bob Barnett.

There is one question that can tell us a lot about whether we are still thinking critically:

What would it take to change your mind?

Not what would annoy you.

Not what would make you argue harder.

What evidence, honestly, would make you say:

“I was wrong.”

That is a difficult question.

Because once we believe something strongly, we usually do not experience it as a theory anymore.

It starts to feel like part of reality.

Sometimes it even becomes part of who we are.

Our politics.

Our religion.

Our view of history.

Our opinion of another person.

Our understanding of ourselves.

Once a belief gets tied to identity, changing it can feel like losing something much bigger than an argument.

That is where critical thinking gets hard.

Because we like to imagine that we gather evidence, weigh it carefully, and then form a conclusion.

Sometimes we do.

But human beings are also very good at forming the conclusion first and then becoming excellent lawyers for it.

We notice the evidence that helps our case.

We question the evidence that hurts it.

We remember the examples that support us.

And somehow the inconvenient ones never seem quite as memorable.

There is a name for part of this.

Confirmation bias.

It simply means we tend to notice and favor information that confirms what we already believe.

And nobody is immune.

Not conspiracy theorists.

Not skeptics.

Not scientists.

Not me.

Not you.

That matters because sometimes we talk about critical thinking as if it belongs to one particular kind of person.

It does not.

Critical thinking is not something we possess.

It is something we practice.

And practice means we can stop doing it.

Especially when the subject matters to us.

Imagine two people reading the same piece of evidence.

One already believes the claim.

The other does not.

The believer may say:

“See? That proves it.”

The skeptic may say:

“That source is questionable.”

Then another piece of evidence comes along pointing the other direction.

Suddenly the standards switch.

Now the skeptic is impressed.

The believer starts examining every possible flaw.

Both people may sincerely believe they are simply following the evidence.

That is why this is difficult.

Bias does not usually announce itself.

It feels like thinking.

One of the best protections I know is asking ourselves, before the next piece of evidence arrives:

What would change my mind?

Be specific.

If I believe something happened, what evidence would convince me it probably did not?

If I believe somebody is dishonest, what would make me reconsider them?

If I believe an institution is hiding something, what evidence would make me think the ordinary explanation is more likely?

If the answer is...

“Nothing.”

Then we have learned something important.

The belief is no longer waiting for evidence.

It has become protected from evidence.

And once we get there, almost anything can be explained away.

If a prediction comes true, the theory was right.

If it does not, somebody interfered.

If evidence appears, that proves the claim.

If evidence is missing, that proves the cover-up.

If an expert agrees, they are credible.

If an expert disagrees, they are compromised.

Now the belief cannot lose.

And a belief that cannot lose also cannot really be tested.

That is not strength.

It is insulation.

I think we all have beliefs we insulate a little.

Sometimes for emotional reasons.

Admitting we were wrong can be embarrassing.

Especially if we argued about it.

Especially if we posted about it.

Especially if we told everybody else they were fools for not seeing what we saw.

Now changing our mind has a social cost.

We have to face people.

We have to say:

“Remember that thing I was absolutely certain about?”

That can sting.

But I think there is something much more impressive than never being wrong.

Being able to recognize it.

There is real strength in saying:

“I believed that because the evidence looked convincing to me at the time. I have seen better evidence now, and I have changed my mind.”

That should not embarrass us.

That is what thinking is supposed to look like.

If new information can never change our conclusion, then gathering information has become theater.

We already know where we are going.

We are just looking for material to take with us.

And this applies far beyond conspiracy theories.

Think about the stories we tell ourselves about other people.

Someone hurts us once.

We decide they are selfish.

Now every selfish thing they do confirms it.

Every generous thing becomes an exception.

Or maybe we admire somebody.

Then warning signs appear.

We excuse them because they do not fit the person we thought we knew.

The mind likes consistency.

It does not enjoy rebuilding the story.

But sometimes the story needs rebuilding.

That is true of people.

It is true of history.

And it is true of ourselves.

Maybe one of the hardest beliefs to change is the belief we have about who we are.

“I am bad at this.”

“I always mess things up.”

“People like me do not change.”

Those are beliefs too.

And we can protect them against evidence just as fiercely as any conspiracy theory.

Someone praises us.

“They were just being nice.”

We succeed.

“Lucky.”

We improve.

“It will not last.”

Look at what happened there.

We just explained away the evidence.

Human beings are remarkable that way.

We can build a theory around almost anything if we are determined to keep it alive.

So intellectual humility is not just about saying:

“I do not know.”

Although that is a very useful sentence.

It is also about leaving a door unlocked.

A door through which better evidence can enter.

I think skepticism is healthiest when it includes skepticism about ourselves.

Not constant self-doubt.

That is different.

I mean recognizing that our brains are not neutral instruments.

We have histories.

Preferences.

Fears.

Loyalties.

We want some things to be true more than others.

That does not make us foolish.

It makes us human.

But once we know that about ourselves, we can compensate for it.

One way is to ask:

“Am I holding evidence for my side to the same standard as evidence against it?”

That question can be uncomfortable.

Suppose somebody posts a story that confirms everything I already believe politically.

Do I check the source?

Or do I share it because it feels right?

Now suppose the exact same kind of source publishes something I dislike.

Suddenly I become an investigative journalist.

I inspect the date.

The author.

The wording.

The funding.

The punctuation.

Interesting, isn’t it?

Our standards can become remarkably flexible when our identity is involved.

So maybe we need one standard.

Evidence I like does not get a discount.

Evidence I dislike does not get an extra tax.

That is difficult.

But it is fair.

And fairness matters here.

Because our beliefs do not stay inside our heads.

They affect other people.

They shape who we trust.

Who we fear.

Who we vote for.

Who we accuse.

Who we stop speaking to.

A false belief can hurt someone even when the person holding it has good intentions.

That is why this is more than an intellectual exercise.

There are consequences to being certain.

And the stronger our certainty becomes, the more careful we should probably become with what we do because of it.

I think that is especially true when our belief is about another human being.

Before we decide somebody is lying...

Before we decide they are malicious...

Before we decide they are part of some enormous hidden plan...

Maybe we should ask whether the evidence really supports that conclusion.

Because once we stop seeing a person and start seeing only what we believe they represent, something changes in us.

And I want to spend Friday talking about that.

Because after a week about skepticism, conspiracies, evidence, and changing our minds, there is still one part of this we have not talked about very much.

What happens to the people?

How do we disagree without losing each other?

How do we challenge a belief without turning the person who holds it into an enemy?

And what does love have to do with critical thinking?

More than we might think.

But before we get there, I want to leave you with one question.

Pick one belief you feel absolutely certain…



Get full access to Infinite Threads at bobs618464.substack.com/subscribe

Więcej odcinków z kanału "Infinite Threads with Bob Barnett"