#12425 Imposter Catholic Churches – Why Aren’t You Catholic? - Joe Heschmeyer

“How do you prove God exists without science?” This episode explores the intersection of faith and reason, addressing questions like how to engage with skeptics who demand scientific proof, the challenges faced by those seeking answers about Catholicism, and the complexities surrounding priest celibacy in the early Church. Tune in for a thoughtful exploration of these important topics. Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com Questions Covered: 13:25 – How do you respond to someone who doesn’t believe in God because you can’t prove it with math or science? 18:12 – I’m not Catholic because I have so many questions and can’t find people to talk to in good faith. 39:24 – I was raised Catholic, but I don’t believe in the real presence. 52:05 – I don’t fully understand priest celibacy since in the early Church they were allowed to marry?

“Can non-Catholics be saved?” This episode explores this critical question while also addressing concerns about pride masses in local parishes, the nature of apostolic churches, and the intercession of saints. Join us as we navigate these important topics and provide clarity on Catholic beliefs and practices. Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com Questions Covered: 06:37 – I just became Catholic and a Catholic church in my community is having a pride mass and festival. I’m very confused. Does our Church allow this? 15:01 – My friend says they are not Catholic because every apostolic Church claims to be the one true Church. How do I respond? 19:13 – I’m Catholic. Rev 20:4-6 Where are the souls that are sleeping? 25:06 – How do I talk to non-Catholics who say they can’t be Catholic because of how they treated natives? 33:32 – I understand the intercession of saints but a lot of the time the actual prayer sounds like it’s directed to them and not just intercession. 47:45 – Catholics are too obsessed with the physical like, scapulars, and medals. Those things are not in the bible and are traditions of men. 52:42 – I’m Lutheran. The issue for me is Sola Scriptura and when the Church contradicts scripture.

“What Similarities Are There Between Catholics and Lutherans?” In this episode, we explore key differences between Catholicism and the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod, discuss ways to encourage others to return to the faith through the Eucharist, and delve into the significance of focus during the Eucharistic liturgy. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics. Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com Questions Covered: 03:45 – I’m Lutheran in OCIA. What would you say are the main highlights between Catholics and Lutheran Church Missouri Synod? 14:14 – How should I help bring people back through the Eucharist? 28:45 – How does transubstantiation happen? 37:40 – During the Eucharistic liturgy where should our attention be, the altar or the tabernacle? 46:19 – I’m having trouble explaining the eucharist and the early church to my Protestant friends. What advice would you give me?

“Do specifics about the Eucharist really matter?” This episode dives into the significance of the Eucharist, exploring questions like why eucharistic miracles occur and the importance of distinguishing between consubstantiation and transubstantiation. Join us as we also discuss the implications of consuming blessed bread from an orthodox church and the historical tradition of the Eucharist in tabernacles. Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com Questions Covered: 01:00 – Why do eucharistic miracles happen? 09:05 – Why does it matter to distinguish between consubstantiation and transubstantiation? 20:25 – Can my kids consume the blessed bread that’s not consecrated at an orthodox church? 29:20 – How do you defend eucharistic miracles? 34:16 – Do we have any writings of when the tradition of holding the eucharist in a tabernacle started? 37:55 – Was Martin Luther’s intent for people to give up the importance of the eucharist? If not, why did they move away from it? 46:00 – What do you recommend I do to prepare to be an extraordinary minister of Holy Communion? 51:32 – Who do many evangelicals deny eucharistic miracles?

“Can God hear our mental prayer?” This episode explores the nuances of prayer and divine communication, alongside intriguing questions about the establishment of early churches by the apostles, the concept of infallibility, and the comparison between the Catholic and Pentecostal churches. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics. Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com Questions Covered: 07:33 – Are we able to trace back what churches the other apostles established? 13:50 – What did you see in the Catholic Church that made you open your eyes to converting? 21:45 – Would it be possible for a year of divine judgment? If yes, then why doesn’t he? 28:55 – Can the pope ever break from the seat of Peter? 36:55 – What Catholic study bible do you recommend? And which translation? 39:43 – How does the Pentecostal church compare to the Catholic Church? 44:04 – Can God hear our mental prayer? Was Jesus a good boy as a kid? 46:43 – How do we reconcile parts of the church that have been corrupt in the medieval ages and the infallibility of the church? 53:00 – What is infallibility

“What is the biblical evidence against the great apostasy?” In this episode, we explore this critical question alongside topics such as the Church’s stance on the death penalty and self-defense, the validity of the Eucharist in other apostolic churches, and the historical development of the papacy. Join us for a thoughtful examination of these important issues. Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com Questions Covered: 02:11 – What is the biblical evidence against the great apostasy? 16:35 – I’m discovering Catholicism. If Catholics believe in the sacredness of all human life, where does the Church stand on the death penalty and self defense? 23:41 – Is it enough for us Catholics to give to the Church and trust that they will give it to the poor? How would you apply to women giving to the poor when there’s safety concerns? 34:35 – What is the validity of the eucharist in other apostolic churches? 40:35 – Was there always a pope, or was there a development of power when Rome fell? 46:25 – Where are the bodies of Jesus and Mary? Where do they physically reside? 48:39 – Our priest read writings of St. Ignatius of Antioch during the homely. St. Ignatius told his readers not to do anything to avoid his martyrdom. Wouldn’t this go against preserving innocent life?

“Can The Brown Scapular Save You from Hell?” In this episode, we explore the significance of the brown scapular and its role in salvation. Additionally, we tackle questions about Galatians 3 and its implications for the chosen people, recommend resources for transitioning from atheism to theism, and discuss St. Ignatius of Antioch’s self-identification in his letters. Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com Questions Covered: 01:08 – Will the brown scapular alone save you from hell? What is the brown scapular, and what does it actually do? 06:48 – Does Galatians 3 mean that we are all the chosen people? 21:14 – What book do you recommend making the jump from atheism to theism? 44:38 – What does St. Ignatius of Antioch mean when he introduces himself as God Inspired in his letters? 48:12 – What’s the Catholic response to people who use the bible to claim the earth is flat?

“Did Vatican II make us too kind to other religions?” This episode explores the implications of Vatican II on interfaith relations, alongside questions about the historical treatment of Catholics by certain Jewish sects, the Vatican’s role during the Holocaust, and how to reconcile Jesus’ claims with the beliefs of Judaism and Islam. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics. Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com Questions Covered: 03:02 – Did Vatican II Make Us Too Kind to Other Religions? 31:29 – If Catholics and Jews are supposed to get along, why are Catholics mistreated by certain sects of Judaism? 35:21 – What was the Vatican’s role during the Holocaust? 43:37 – How can we accept Jesus saying I am the Way Truth and Life and embrace Judaism and Islam knowing they reject Jesus? 46:40 – Does the Incarnation of Jesus resolve the issue of the arbitrariness of the Jewish notion of being the chosen people? 49:31 – How does the Church’s stance today compare its previous stance of super secessionism?

“Responding to Attacks on the Papacy” This episode explores the role of the pope in the Catholic Church, addressing questions like the implications of priest celibacy in light of 1 Timothy 3 and the reasoning behind Timothy’s circumcision by Paul. Additionally, we delve into the Church’s stance on alcohol and its interpretation of love in Romans. Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com Questions Covered: 02:34 – I’m not Catholic because I don’t believe that the pope holds Peter’s office. 21:06 – What are your thoughts on priest celibacy in light of 1 Tim. 3? 30:24 – If Paul was sent to the Gentile, why did he have Timothy circumcised? 33:07 – Why is alcohol permitted in the Catholic Church? 43:55 – How do Catholics understand Paul in Romans saying love is the fulfillment of the law? Is Paul solely referring to Jewish customs?

“How To Respond to ‘Catholics Oppose Science'” This episode tackles the perception that the Catholic Church opposes progress, addressing historical issues like Galileo and monarchies. Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com Questions Covered: 03:59 – What do you say to the person who says they are not Catholic because the Catholic Church has always opposed progress and they give you a smorgasbord of reasons? Galileo, Jews in Ghettos, siding with Kings and Queens in the age of democracy, not letting women be priests, etc… 11:00 – I’m going to a protestant apologetics conference this Friday. What questions should I ask Wes Huff while I’m there? 17:23 – I’m Protestant. If two Catholics fall away from the Church and get married outside the Catholic Church, are they considered fornicators? 41:13 – My husband is a Baptist. Would 2 Peter 2:4 help with helping explain losing one’s salvation? 51:55 – Doesn’t it seem like Protestants almost view baptism like confirmation?