
Three curses. One classroom. And a Defense Against the Dark Arts lesson that raises a LOT of questions.
This week on Books & Butterbeer, Johnna and Katie dive into Chapter 14 of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, The Unforgivable Curses.
Harry, Ron, and Hermione finally attend their first Defense Against the Dark Arts lesson with Mad-Eye Moody, and it is nothing like they expected. Instead of learning ordinary countercurses, the students witness demonstrations of the three Unforgivable Curses: Imperius, Cruciatus, and Avada Kedavra.
Most of the class thinks Moody is brilliant. But Harry, Hermione, and Neville have very different reactions, and reading this chapter as adults has us questioning just about everything happening in that classroom.
In this episode, we talk about:
If you had to choose between the Imperius Curse and the Cruciatus Curse, which would you rather experience?
Whether demonstrating the Unforgivable Curses to fourteen-year-olds is an appropriate teaching method
The many red flags surrounding Moody's behavior and how differently we interpret them knowing what happens later
Why Neville's reaction to the Cruciatus Curse is so heartbreaking
Hermione being the only student who recognizes that something is seriously wrong
Why Moody's treatment of Neville, including his seemingly thoughtful gift, deserves a much closer look
The surprising number of times Moody actually says "Constant Vigilance!"
Harry and Ron's spectacularly ridiculous Divination homework
Our own experiences with school assignments that got a little out of hand
Fred and George acting suspiciously in the Gryffindor common room
Hermione officially introducing S.P.E.W. and her campaign for house-elf welfare
Sirius deciding to return north after hearing about Harry's scar
And why Harry's frustration with Sirius leads to a very unfair reaction toward poor Hedwig
We also discuss how much more carefully Goblet of Fire needs to be read the second time around. Moments that initially seem like ordinary classroom interactions become something entirely different when you understand the motivations behind them.
And then there is Neville.
What makes this chapter especially difficult to revisit is knowing what Neville has experienced and watching him struggle through a lesson that most of his classmates find entertaining. His reaction, Hermione's concern, and the quiet ending of the chapter remind us that not everyone walks away from the same experience unaffected.
Of course, we still find time to discuss a chameleon princess escaping a tower, an undergraduate paper that somehow included three paragraphs about the Romanovs' dog, and whether Professor Trelawney would notice if Ron predicted that he drowned twice.
Because apparently we cannot get through even the darkest chapters without a few unexpected detours.
Grab your Butterbeer, settle in, and remember:
Constant Vigilance!
We're also making a little change to our reread! Starting next week, we're going to experiment with covering two chapters per episode. We'd love to hear whether you prefer our traditional chapter-by-chapter discussions or enjoy spending a little more time moving through the story together.
Next week: Beauxbatons and Durmstrang AND The Goblet of Fire!
Więcej odcinków z kanału "Books and Butterbeer"



Nie przegap odcinka z kanału “Books and Butterbeer”! Subskrybuj bezpłatnie w aplikacji GetPodcast.








