
There’s something deeply unsettling about watching a machine accomplish something extraordinary and realizing that the accomplishment itself might be the beginning of a much bigger problem.
OpenAI has been pushing the boundaries of AI-assisted mathematical reasoning, including producing formal proofs for difficult mathematical problems. These developments are impressive, but they’ve also raised uncomfortable questions about the future of mathematics and the people who practice it.
Because beneath all the excitement about AI solving difficult problems, there’s a much bigger question we should be asking:
What happens when AI becomes so good at thinking that humans stop learning how to think for themselves?
I call this the Mathapocalypse.
I’m not suggesting mathematics is about to disappear. Rather, I think what’s happening in mathematics offers us a glimpse of a potentially disturbing future for human intelligence.
Let me explain.
Mathematics Is About More Than Getting the Right Answer
I have a soft spot for mathematics. Back in college, I came pretty close to majoring in it.
To me, math is a language that describes reality. There’s something elegant and beautiful about the simple truths humans have discovered through it.
Mathematics is also a great example of a field where the process of discovery can be just as valuable as the final result.
In many professions, the primary goal is to produce an output. A software engineer writes code. An architect designs a building. An accountant prepares a financial statement. The output is what the customer or employer generally pays for.
If an AI can produce the same result faster, cheaper, and with fewer mistakes, it becomes difficult to justify paying a human to do the same work.
But intellectual pursuits can be different.
When mathematicians work on a difficult problem, they aren’t simply trying to produce a proof. They’re exploring ideas, developing techniques, testing conjectures, and discovering relationships they didn’t previously understand.
Even when a particular approach fails, the effort can produce knowledge that becomes useful somewhere else.
Sometimes, the real value lies not in the destination, but in the journey.
Some of Humanity’s Greatest Discoveries Were Unexpected Side Effects
Think about the history of mathematics and science.
The development of calculus gave humanity powerful new ways to describe motion, change, and physical systems. Those ideas eventually became essential to engineering and physics.
Number theory, once viewed by many as an abstract pursuit with limited practical applications, eventually became fundamental to modern cryptography.
Fourier analysis, developed to study mathematical problems involving heat, became an important tool in signal processing, communications, and image compression.
These developments didn’t happen because someone sat down and said, “Hey, let’s invent the technology that will power smartphones in a couple of centuries.”
They happened because people pursued difficult intellectual problems, sometimes for reasons that seemed entirely disconnected from practical applications.
The journey produced tools that nobody could fully anticipate at the beginning.
Consider the Space Race. The competition to reach space generated advances in rocketry, satellite communications, integrated circuits, and other technologies that eventually found applications far beyond the original mission.
Humanity didn’t just get astronauts into space. It developed capabilities that transformed life back on Earth.
When humans investigate difficult problems, we sometimes discover things far more valuable than the answers we were originally looking for.
Now imagine replacing that process with an AI that simply generates the answer.
Would we still get the same unexpected discoveries?
The answer is obviously NO.
But there’s an important distinction between a machine producing a solution and humans understanding the process that led to it.
And that distinction could become increasingly important as AI capabilities improve.
What Happens When the Answer Becomes More Important Than Understanding?
Imagine an AI solving a mathematical problem that has frustrated researchers for decades.
It produces a proof. Technically, the proof is correct.
But the proof is also enormous, convoluted, and difficult for a human to understand.
Formal mathematical proofs can involve vast amounts of machine-generated code. A formal verification system may be able to check that a proof is valid even when the underlying reasoning is difficult for a human mathematician to follow.
This creates an interesting problem.
We might have a machine that can establish that a mathematical statement follows from a set of assumptions, while humans struggle to understand the result in a way that generates further insights.
Of course, formal verification is a major advantage. A proof checked by a trusted formal system is not merely an AI confidently asserting that it is correct.
But verifying correctness and developing human understanding are not the same thing.
Suppose an AI produces a proof that is technically sound but offers little insight into why the result is true or how its techniques could be applied to other problems.
We get the answer. But do we get the understanding?
If this becomes the normal way mathematics is done, mathematicians could increasingly find themselves reviewing machine-generated proofs, checking their validity, and MAYBE trying to extract useful insights from them.
That work would still be important. Someone needs to verify that these systems are doing what they claim to do.
But it could fundamentally change the nature of the profession. The mathematician might gradually transition from being an explorer of the unknown to being an auditor of machine-generated knowledge.
And that raises an uncomfortable question.
If the most intellectually exciting part of the job is increasingly performed by machines, what incentive will there be for humans to pursue it?
The Next Generation Might Simply Give Up
Put yourself in the shoes of a young person with an exceptional talent for mathematics.
Maybe this kid loves numbers, enjoys solving difficult problems, and dreams of becoming a mathematician.
Then they watch AI systems solve problems that even the world’s best mathematicians struggle with.
They see machines generating proofs, exploring mathematical possibilities, and producing results at a scale no human could reasonably match.
And they start wondering what their future looks like.
By the time this young person completes years of education and reaches the professional level, AI might already be better than them at everything.
So why spend years mastering mathematics?
Why endure the frustration of difficult proofs and the struggle to develop expertise when a machine can potentially do the work faster and better?
Sure, they could use AI as a tool. They might even become more productive than previous generations of mathematicians.
But what if the availability of that tool discourages them from developing deep mathematical intuition in the first place?
Why struggle through a difficult problem when you can ask an AI for the solution?
Why learn to derive a proof when a machine can generate one?
These are not just questions about mathematics. They apply to software engineering, scientific research, design, finance, and practically every profession built around intellectual work.
The question is whether these incentives will eventually change how many people enter these fields and how much expertise they develop.
Because if they do, the consequences could extend far beyond individual careers.
The Most Dangerous Part Might Be Losing the People Who Know When AI Is Wrong
Here’s where my concerns become much more serious.
Mathematics is a relatively small field, and some specialized branches have only a handful of people with deep expertise.
These experts are often among the few people capable of understanding, evaluating, and challenging new results in their particular areas.
Now imagine tha…
Get full access to AsianDadEnergy's Newsletter at asiandadenergy.substack.com/subscribe
Więcej odcinków z kanału "AsianDadEnergy's Podcast"



Nie przegap odcinka z kanału “AsianDadEnergy's Podcast”! Subskrybuj bezpłatnie w aplikacji GetPodcast.








