
Why Does Medicare Pay Different Prices for the Same Procedures? Site Neutral Payments w/Charlie Katebi
“Comprehensive site neutral payment policy is the simple principle that whether the service is being rendered in an independent doctor’s office, or a hospital-owned doctor’s office, or in the outpatient department of a hospital campus, that service should be one price.” —Charlie Katebi
Howdy folks. Charlie Katebi of the America First Policy Institute joins me today to talk about site neutral policy in Medicare.
Medicare builds its hospital outpatient rates from the overhead costs of every hospital system in the country. All of it gets folded into the price of a routine x-ray, including one delivered at a standalone clinic that a hospital happens to own. Depending on the service, payment rates can be 43 to 600 percent more than an independent practice down the road for identical work. That gap is also why hospitals keep buying physician practices. Redesignating an existing office as “hospital-owned” raises prices without any corresponding quality improvement.
Comprehensive site neutral policy would mean one price for a service, whether it is delivered in an independent doctor’s office, a hospital-owned clinic, or a hospital outpatient department.
Site neutral is one of the many issues we discussed at our recent Medicare Budget Options conference at the Hoover Institution. Charlie’s brief is published here, which is well worth checking out.
CBO puts it at $156 billion in federal savings over ten years plus roughly $94 billion for beneficiaries in lower coinsurance and Part B premiums, and it scores versions of the policy in its Options for Reducing the Deficit (https://www.cbo.gov/budget-options) volume.
Getting the full version requires Congress to rewrite the payment statute. HHS has discretionary authority under the Social Security Act to curb unnecessary volume increases, and the Trump administration has used it three times, but administrative solutions only reach a handful of services and the savings are measured in hundreds of millions of dollars instead of hundreds of billions.
In chatting with Charlie, I’m reminded again of how much central planning leads to inefficient behaviors. Determining prices by including all of the overhead costs of providing services sounds good in theory, but a dose of the real world will tell you that prices in competitive markets aren’t dictated by what it costs to offer the service. They’re what sellers can get from willing buyers, and what buyers can get from willing sellers.
What’s in the episode
[1:01] Charlie’s route into health policy, starting at a think tank in Wyoming.
[4:41] The two payment systems leads to bad incentives. Sell your physician practice to a hospital system and the same service pays 43 to 600 percent more.
[7:55] Why seniors feel this directly. Cost sharing of 20 percent means higher prices are also paid by beneficiaries.
[9:30] Every hospital’s overhead in the country gets averaged into what your local hospital-owned clinic charges for an x-ray.
[12:09] What site-neutral payment actually means. Pay for what it costs to deliver the service and stop there.
[13:32] Why we need to cut spending: Two trillion dollar deficits and about half a trillion of Medicare spending comes straight from general revenues.
[16:31] Comprehensive site neutral, the $156 billion CBO score, and the $94 billion of it that goes back to beneficiaries.
[19:30] What HHS can do without Congress. The 2018 clinic visit rule, the 2025 drug administration rule, and this July’s proposed rule on imaging.
[22:06] The three-part test HHS built to survive judicial scrutiny after Loper Bright.
[25:51] Bigger picture concern: All of this still happens inside a centrally planned price system. Charlie agrees and explains why the patient is never the customer.
[30:42] The politics: Employers, insurers and physicians want site neutral. Hospitals do not. But hospitals have a building in every congressional district.
[34:23] Why site neutral is always on the reconciliation pay-for list and never survives to the final bill.
[36:20] The closest it has come since 2015. The House passed a $2 billion version in the Lower Costs, More Transparency Act and the Senate never took it up.
[38:08] The 2033 trust fund date and why Part B and Part D deserve the attention Part A gets.
Thanks for reading and listening Subscribe for free to get every new episode.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit church.substack.com
Więcej odcinków z kanału "584 Vetoes"



Nie przegap odcinka z kanału “584 Vetoes”! Subskrybuj bezpłatnie w aplikacji GetPodcast.








