The Catholic Thing podcast

Struggling with the "Noonday Demon"

0:00
6:56
Reculer de 15 secondes
Avancer de 15 secondes
By Zachary Naccash
Among the Seven Deadly Sins, the sin of Sloth, or acedia in the Greek tradition, is frequently mistaken for simple laziness. The image of an indolent teenager comes to mind – not merely someone who resists work, but is also contemptuous of it. But for the ancient and medieval Christian tradition, mere laziness and Sloth are very different.
Thomas Aquinas, following John Damascene, defines Sloth as a kind of "sorrow" for spiritual good, and explicitly distinguishes it from mere laziness. Sloth is a kind of listlessness that man feels when the good he ought to seek, rather than inspiring him to pursue it, causes him to feel more acutely his own weariness at the prospect. Far from being mere unwillingness to work, sloth is a sorrow or weariness in the very face of spiritual good.
We have largely forgotten about sloth in the modern world, which is not only unfortunate but dangerous. Misdiagnosis of any disease leads to ineffective remedies. As Boethius observes, "If you want the physician to be of assistance to you, you must make your disease known to him."
The world of today is chronically online. We have exchanged social life for 'social' media – replacing the spiritual goods of friendship, contemplation, and interiority with flickering images on a screen, which offer the shelter of anonymity, but inflame envy by fixing attention on material things, and spare us the discomfort of being alone with ourselves.
Modern man has built for himself a technological Platonic cave, and our eyes have adjusted to the dark.
While today's world may be especially suited to inducing acedia, this vice is by no means unique to our age. Among the earliest spiritual writers to treat acedia was Evagrius Ponticus, a student of St. Gregory Nazianzen and an influential fourth-century monk.
In his Praktikos, a work composed to aid monks in pursuing a life of holiness, Evagrius offers some advice to the monk struggling with the "noonday demon" (i.e., Sloth), "who is most grievous of all."
In the first place, Evagrius tells us to live as if we're going to die tomorrow, but to treat our bodies as though we're going to live for a long time. Meditating on death is a common theme of Christian spirituality, and care for the body is generally good advice. But both are especially pertinent to overcoming the noonday demon.

On the one hand, meditation on death – and realizing that it could be tomorrow – spurs us to overcome the sorrow of the moment and pursue spiritual goods, rather than shrink from the effort of achieving them.
On the other hand, acedia is a kind of sadness and, so, a passion. Like all passions, it is closely tied to the body. Evagrius' advice to take care of one's body is, therefore, a practical remedy: you need to care for your body because doing so will help keep you in good spirits. Poor diet, lack of sleep, and a lack of physical activity will all contribute to a feeling of listlessness and sadness, without the noonday demon having to lift a finger. Evagrius' advice, then, is to take good care of your body in such a way as to make the demon work hard to tempt you to sadness.
Evagrius' second piece of advice is to remain in place. For the monks that Evagrius was addressing, there was a strong temptation to leave their cells, to wander about looking for another monk who might distract them, and to gaze up at the sun and count how many hours were left in the day.
While we are similarly tempted, today the temptation often manifests itself in constantly pulling out a phone or glancing at a smartwatch: "What time is it and how long have I been working?" "Do I have any notifications?" "Just a couple of reels, and then I will get to work."
The pull of the phone can be intense, distracting not merely from work but even from actual social activities. It is a common sight today to see a group of young people out together, but communally ignoring each other as they stare into their phones. Evagrius' advice here is basically: enduran...

D'autres épisodes de "The Catholic Thing"