
This is actually part three going into specifics on the series of "what happens in a crit?": what actually happens in the room. Start with the critics we decided not to invite back. There is the one who belittles — top-down, making a student feel small the moment they try to hold a dialogue, there for an argument rather than to guide. There is the subtler version, perfectly civil, who turns out to have exactly one way of designing and wants to impose it; sometimes with an agenda, because they would like that student working for them later. And there is the critic who stays quiet because others have spoken first — when in my view there is always something left out.
Then the kind worth keeping. A student, not a star student, proposed farms in a primary school so children would learn to care for animals. One critic took that straight to food security and the role of schools as a food supply in Malaysia — opening up what a school even is, and what systems might sit on top of the old ones. That is breadth, and it is the point of a thesis-level crit. I also talk about my own limits: I am the moderator, not the guide, and I do my guiding afterwards, catching students with the keywords from the session. Some students go quiet in a crit and never say why, because they do not feel safe to. Finding out what is actually wrong takes consistency, and time none of us really have.
© 2026 Talk Architecture, Author: Naziaty Mohd Yaacob. Photo by Naziaty Mohd Yaacob on design thesis crit 2018
Do subscribe for premium content and special features which will help to support and sustain Talk Architecture podcast on a more in-depth explanation on design thesis and processes. These special commentaries and ‘how to’ explanations are valuable insights and knowledge not found elsewhere!
D'autres épisodes de "Talk Architecture"



Ne ratez aucun épisode de “Talk Architecture” et abonnez-vous gratuitement à ce podcast dans l'application GetPodcast.








