200. The Great Disney Draft

200 episodes in, and J.B. and Eddie are celebrating the only way they know how — by turning Disney fandom into a full-blown fantasy draft. Inspired by their love of sports drafts and the great Disney adults vs. sports fans debate, the guys compete across five categories, pulling from the entire Walt Disney Studios, Disney Animation, and Pixar catalog to build out their ultimate rosters. Who will they choose?

J.B. and Eddie are out of the vault and over the moon for this one. This week the guys review Pixar's Wall-E (2008) — a film that somehow delivers sharp environmental and social commentary, a sweeping romance, and some of the best physical comedy in Pixar history, all with barely any dialogue. Is it the most underrated film in the Pixar canon? The guys make a strong case, and debate where Wall-E ranks among cinema's greatest robots.Then in Disney News: the new class of Disney Legends is announced ahead of D23 — and it's a fascinating mix of animators, voice actors, Imagineers, and a couple of familiar faces with movies coming out this summer. Plus, Avengers: Doomsday continues to raise eyebrows as Imax hands its screens to Dune: Messiah, and Disney's newly relaunched Adventure World at Disneyland Paris is turning heads with some jaw-dropping robotics. The We Call It Imagineering series on Disney+ is required viewing.

For Narnia! For Aslan! J.B. and Eddie return to Narnia this week as they review The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian (2008). How faithful is it to C.S. Lewis's book? Does it earn its Lord of the Rings ambitions? And what does the film get so wrong about the story's true heart? The guys dig into the castle raid, the Lucy and Aslan dream sequence, Susan's reimagined role, and much more.Then in Disney News: new CEO Josh D'Amaro unveils his vision for Disney+ as the "digital centerpiece" of the entire company, OpenAI shuts down Sora taking Disney's $1 billion investment with it, and the guys react to the new Moana live-action trailer.

J.B. and Eddie are back for another adventure—this time diving into National Treasure: Book of Secrets! From Mount Rushmore to the President’s secret book, the guys break down what makes this sequel such a fun (and chaotic) follow-up, where it works, where it goes off the rails, and why Nicolas Cage might be the only person who can make it all work.They talk through the film’s bigger, bolder approach compared to the original, debate whether this is the perfect example of a “more is more” sequel, and revisit the never-ending mystery of Page 47. Plus, they imagine what could have been (and still could be) with a third installment and how this franchise could’ve had a bigger presence in the Disney parks.As always, they wrap things up with some Disney news and the end of the Iger era.

J.B. and Eddie head back to the fairy-tale-meets-New-York musical that helped revive Disney’s live-action magic: Enchanted. From Amy Adams’ pitch-perfect princess performance to the film’s affectionate parody of classic Disney tropes, the guys break down why this movie works so well—and whether it still holds up today. Along the way they talk memorable songs, perfect casting, and why the movie manages to celebrate Disney while also poking fun at it.After the review, they jump into a packed Disney news segment, including reactions to Pixar’s Hoppers, plus several other recent updates from around the Disney universe. As always, the episode wraps with a quick personal story before sending you off with your weekly dose of Disney nostalgia.

We’re breaking down The Game Plan — Disney’s mid-2000s family comedy that asked a very important question: what happens when a superstar quarterback suddenly discovers he’s a dad? From peak Rock-era charisma to Disney Channel–adjacent vibes, we talk about what works, what doesn’t, and where this movie lands in Disney’s long run of live-action family films.We also run through a packed Disney news segment, including Josh Gad popping up in Wonder Man, Marvel staying unusually quiet with no new trailers, thoughts on the current state of The Muppet Show, and our reaction to The Mandalorian & Grogu Super Bowl trailer.

Step into a nostalgic Disney time machine with Honey, We Made a Disney Podcast! Join longtime friends J.B. and Eddie as they hilariously revisit Disney’s cinematic highs and lows—this week diving deep into the 2007 live-action Underdog. From lifeless CGI dog mouths and wasted celebrity cameos to Peter Dinklage’s acrobatic villainy and Patrick Warburton’s platinum-haired henchman, the hosts pull no punches in their most side-splitting takedown yet. Plus, they chat about Disney’s new leadership shake-ups, Zootopia in the parks, and the chaotic adventures of parenting a crib-escaping toddler. If you love Disney nostalgia, movie roasting, and a dash of real-life magic, this podcast episode is your next binge. 

🐀🍝 This week, J.B. and Eddie head to Paris to revisit Pixar’s Ratatouille, a film that quietly became one of the studio’s most beloved classics. They break down why Remy’s story of creativity, discipline, and ambition still resonates, how Brad Bird elevates the animation and storytelling, and why where Ratatouille ultimately ranks among Pixar’s all-time greats.PLUS: Eddie's 20 reasons Sports fans are JUST LIKE Disney Adults.

J.B. and Eddie set sail to the edge of the world with Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End. This week, they tackle the most ambitious entry in the franchise — from the wild mythology and overstuffed plot to Davy Jones, the Pirate Lords, and Jack Sparrow at his most unhinged. The conversation digs into whether this epic conclusion earns its runtime, how it caps off the original trilogy, and why At World’s End feels both massive and messy in equal measure. Along the way, they reflect on Disney’s peak blockbuster era, the highs and lows of the Pirates franchise, and where this film ultimately lands in the series.

Pull up on that yellow strap—it’s time to open the vault! This week, Eddie and J.B. take a trippy trip to the future (and the past) to review Walt Disney Animation’s 2007 feature, Meet the Robinsons. In this episode, the guys break down one of the most chaotic chapters in Disney history, discussing:The Pixar Takeover: How John Lasseter’s arrival in 2006 led to scrapping 60% of this film just a year before its release. Style vs. Substance: A look at the "disjointed" animation style that borrowed from The Incredibles and William Joyce’s original book, A Day with Wilbur Robinson. A "Trippy" Experience: Why the guys felt like something might have been "slipped into their drinks" while watching singing frogs, talking T-Rexes, and a family that defines the word "zany." Villainous Revelations: Their take on Bowler Hat Guy and the "big reveal" that arguably came far too late in the story. The Soundtrack Save: Discussing the massive "needle drops" from artists like Rob Thomas, All-American Rejects, and the Jonas Brothers.Is this Disney's "Black Cauldron moment," or does it stand up better than Chicken Little? Join J.B. and Eddie as they explore the humanity (or lack thereof) in this futuristic "car crash" of a classic. Subscribe to Honey, We Made a Disney Podcast for your weekly dose of Disney nostalgia and a tour through history, one magical film at a time.