Aarva podcast

Crosscut: men finding connection

16/11/2026
0:00
29:01
Reculer de 15 secondes
Avancer de 15 secondes
Psychiatrists are noticing a strange shift: men who refuse to set foot in a therapist's office are pouring their hearts out to AI chatbots. Writing for STAT News last week, Annalisa Merelli asks why a machine suddenly feels like the only safe place for a man to cry. Something interesting emerges when placing that modern isolation next to a Vox article by Miles Bryan, published just days later. Bryan points out that the emotionally stunted male is actually a recent invention, and that intense, non-judgmental support used to be the historical standard for male friendship. Putting them side by side creates a sharp contrast between the artificial connection men rely on today and the real closeness they once had.

Annalisa Merelli leaves you with the image of a grieving man driving down an Italian freeway, crying to a piece of software because a chatbot feels safer than a human. Her reporting suggests men are so starved for non-judgmental spaces that they have to outsource their vulnerability to machines. It looks like a distinctly modern crisis. But Miles Bryan, up next, takes that exact same premise—the isolated modern male—and flips the historical context. What jumps out reading Bryan is the realization that this emotional stunting is a recent invention. He points out that for thousands of years, men were actually considered the experts in forming the most intimate kinds of bonds. Aristotle even defined the perfect friendship as a soulmate connection between two men, while dismissing women's friendships as purely transactional. Read alongside Bryan, the men in Merelli’s piece no longer look like they are trying to learn a new, unnatural skill by talking to artificial intelligence. Instead, they seem to be desperately trying to recreate a historical male bond that modern culture somehow dismantled. The software is just stepping in to fill a very old void.

What lingers is the image of a man typing his secrets into a phone. The need to be heard hasn't disappeared from men over the last century. It just moved from the parlor to the glowing screen. A chatbot offers a space to cry without judgment, replacing the fierce loyalty that used to exist between friends. The instinct for closeness is still there. But as lines of code step in to catch those private tears, a question remains. Can an artificial confidant teach someone how to trust another human being, or does it just become a safer place to hide?

Sources:
STAT News: AI chatbots aren’t therapists. But can they finally get men to open up?
Vox: Men weren’t always “bad at friendship”

For more features and details, visit aarva.app

D'autres épisodes de "Aarva"