
This week, Steve and Christabel tackle (Emily and) Bethany’s BRILLIANT question ‘Why are men?’ To answer, our hosts go back to the basics, beginning with Phillis Trible’s feminist interpretation of the Abrahamic creation story of Adam and (St)Eve. After admiring Adam’s prime rib, we’re transported to ancient Greece, and to the proxy war between Zeus and Prometheus, starring Pandora and her famous jar (NOT box). Steve reminds us that he’s just as good a chaos agent as Eve and Pandora were, as he too cannot resist doing precisely the thing he’s been forbidden to do (and he has the dodgily stitched-up scars to prove it).
We then shift over to Australia to hear the indigenous Kulin Nation’s creation story of Bunjil the wedge-tailed eagle god, his brother, Pallian and his son, Binbeal the rainbow. As with the first two stories, the men are made fist and out of clay, and the women are created after (in this case, as a result of being scooped out of muddy water). This sequential creation of men first, women second is echoed in the Ethiopan creation myth of Wak. Christabel speculates that this stable pattern has helped to reinforce the patriarchal social structures that were described by Simone de Beauvoir. But the social othering of womenkind has a long and rich history that stretches back through and beyond history, and was underwritten by what Anne Sophie Meincke calls Aristotle’s ‘flowerpot’ model of gestation. This early account of pregnancy posits that the purpose of sperm is to create male children (but it can be thwarted if the foetus is exposed to a damp, cold southerly breeze, in which case bad luck: it’s a girl!)
Our duo end on a palate cleanser creation myth, which depicts the simultaneous creation of men and women. This is the story Aristophanes tells during Plato’s Symposium, and it imagines that humans came about as the result of the gods halving four-legged, two-headed monsters. As Christabel explains, romantic love is derived from our innate desire to reunite with the other half from which we were once divinely cleaved. Steve can’t quite tell whether this is quite sweet, or actual body horror, which is the level of confusion (or in the ancient Greek: aporia) that classical philosophy is famous for!
Email us the impossible questions children ask you at [email protected]
Find Steve at https://drstevecross.squarespace.com
Find Christabel at https://christabelcane.com/
Philosophy Playdate theme by Piers Cane
Weitere Episoden von „Philosophy Playdate“



Verpasse keine Episode von “Philosophy Playdate” und abonniere ihn in der kostenlosen GetPodcast App.








