Hour 3: Giants Expectations Just Exploded!

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): Hoff explains his issues with David Stearns and how he's playing too many games during this off-season. Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram & TikTok To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

With a real head coach now in place, the entire Giants conversation shifts from “hope” to “expectation.” The guys debate what the floor actually is in 2026: simply a winning season, meaningful football in December, or a flat-out playoff mandate. They also dig into the reality of the NFC landscape, the pressure on Joe Schoen now that the “big hire” is done, and why some fans are setting the bar high while others are preaching patience. Plus, callers weigh in on whether this feels like a true turning point, and why Harbaugh should inspire more confidence than past “winning coaches” like Dan Reeves.

It’s a wild day in New York sports. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to the Giants hiring John Harbaugh as their next head coach and break down what it means for Big Blue moving forward. Plus, the guys dive deep into the Kyle Tucker sweepstakes, debating the Mets’ reported short-term mega offer versus Toronto’s long-term deal, whether Tucker is worth $50 million per year, and what decision makes the most sense for both the player and the Mets. Giants history, Mets roster construction, Yankees crossover fallout, and plenty of classic Evan & Tiki banter all in one jam-packed segment on WFAN.

The Mets are reportedly in with a massive short-term offer for Kyle Tucker, while Toronto looms with long-term security and the Dodgers lurk as a wildcard. The guys debate the core question every star free agent faces: take the absurd annual payday and bet on yourself, or lock in a decade of guaranteed money and never look back. They dig into whether Tucker is truly worth Juan Soto-level money, the risks of overpaying on a short deal, and why a ten-year commitment feels dangerous for the Mets. From roster construction to championship ceilings to quality-of-life considerations, this turns into a full breakdown of what Tucker should do, and what the Mets should be willing to live with if they miss out.

Cinco De Luncho takes center stage as Evan, Tiki, and Shaun rank the five greatest games ever played at the old Giants Stadium. From iconic playoff blowouts to unforgettable regular season moments, each list sparks debate, nostalgia, and plenty of arguing over what truly belongs in the top five. The conversation weaves through legendary wins, painful losses that shaped championships, and personal memories from the field and the stands. A full-on Giants history lesson with strong opinions, laughs, and classic sports radio chaos.

John Harbaugh to the Giants feels like the rare “everyone wanted him and you actually got him” moment, and the guys dive into why this hire is different from the team’s recent coaching cycles. They also give Joe Schoen credit for building a roster and drafting Jaxson Dart in a way that made the job appealing enough for Harbaugh to skip other interviews entirely. Plus, the phones light up with fans debating Harbaugh vs. McCarthy, the “can a coach win a Super Bowl with two teams” question, and whether anyone owes an apology to ownership. Then the show pivots to a brutal Knicks loss, a Brunson ankle scare, and why the effort level (especially from KAT) had everyone boiling.

The Giants finally have a real head coach, and everything feels different. Evan, Tiki, and Sean debate how much the John Harbaugh hire should immediately raise expectations in Year 1. Is a winning season the floor, or is it fair to expect playoff contention right away? The guys dive into what this move means for Joe Shane, how tough the NFC really is, why meaningful football in December matters, and whether Giants fans should aim high or stay patient. One thing is clear: the bar has officially been raised in New York with John Harbaugh now leading the franchise.

A passionate debate erupts over tanking, fandom, and what fans are actually supposed to root for in September and October. The guys argue whether it’s ever acceptable to cheer for losses, how draft position really changes franchises, and why fans should never be told to embrace losing. The conversation spills into Giants optimism under John Harbaugh, Jets misery, long term expectations, and whether New York sports fans are finally allowed to believe again or if that’s just asking to get burned.

A full blown Jets meltdown after Dante Moore decides to return to college. The guys debate why Moore staying in school actually hurts the Jets by taking options off the board, killing trade down possibilities, and increasing pressure on the front office to get quarterback right. What starts as a simple prediction check quickly turns into a heated argument about draft philosophy, organizational competence, and whether Jets fans are actually celebrating being saved from themselves.

The guys break down a wild stat that makes the John Harbaugh moment feel even bigger: the Giants almost never bring in a head coach who already has a Super Bowl on his resume, and across New York sports it’s surprisingly rare to land a proven champion and have it translate into titles here. That leads to the Weeb Ewbank deep dive as the lone example of a coach who won elsewhere and then won again with a New York team, plus a rapid fire debate over which sports even “count” in the conversation. Then the callers take over, mixing Harbaugh euphoria with classic New York superstition, including one fan reaching for “Giants were first to do this” trivia and the show pushing back with a simpler point: Harbaugh means consistent competence, yearly playoff contention, and eventually a real shot at a title. The segment also hits on 2026 expectations with Jaxson Dart entering Year 2, and why this feels different than other “can’t miss” New York celebrations like Aaron Rodgers to the Jets or the Nets superteam. The message is basically this: even if it doesn’t immediately end in a parade, Harbaugh can still be the turning point that drags the Giants out of the mud for the long haul.