
The Hidden Cut - Episode 2: Comic Cuts
At 45, I straddle a cultural fault line—old enough to remember when every baby boy was clipped without question, young enough to watch that consensus begin to crack. I grew up in a world where circumcision wasn’t discussed, debated, or doubted. It was just done. Quietly. Universally. Without a second thought.
And when I say I didn’t question it, I mean I didn’t even know there was anything to question. I grew up thinking foreskin was a European myth—like bidets, or bridge trolls.
But the real myth was the silence. The normalization. The way the laugh tracks were doing more than just making us laugh—they were making jokes so we wouldn’t ask any questions.
Click to listen to podcast episode.
When the Laugh Track Targets the Body
It’s hard for most Americans my age or older to pinpoint the first time they heard a circumcision joke. By the time I even understood what they were, it was already an evergreen, ubiquitous subject matter that had crept its way into being an easy target in comedy circles.
However—most of us of a certain age—who were not Jewish, and did not grow up in or around a large Jewish population, remember learning about the religious practice of a bris for the first time in the Seinfeld episode entitled “The Bris,” which aired on October 14, 1993.
And with that, the ice had officially been broken in mainstream media. Circumcision jokes were soon considered fair game in mainstream American entertainment.
“It was like a turtleneck down there!”-Sassy female comedian in the nineties
The Joke We Didn’t Question
It’s difficult to overstate just how influential nineties and early 2000s comedy, film, and TV shaped public disgust toward foreskin, normalizing circumcision through ridicule.
To get a sense of the uniformity of opinion at the time, you have to remember that this was a time when mainstream use of the Internet was in its infancy. YouTube didn’t step onto the scene until 2005. Social media wasn’t even a thought.
Answering machines. Rotary phones. CDs. Faxes.
These are the relics of a time gone by when broadcast television was still basking in the spotlight as the star of mass media. Even cable television—catering to niche audiences and relying on subscription models—couldn’t touch the audience numbers that broadcast regularly enjoyed. TikTok was merely a glimmer in the eye of a wistful programmer who probably hadn’t even been born yet.
Must-See TV, Must-Ignore Truths
Let’s examine how these tentpole comedies influenced American audiences during this era.
Seinfeld (1989–1998)
Arguably one of the most culturally influential sitcoms of all time, Seinfeld starred stand-up comedian Jerry Seinfeld and revolved around the social foibles of four neurotic New Yorkers. It defined the observational humor of the nineties and reshaped what sitcoms could be.
The series ran for nine seasons with a total of 180 episodes—aired on NBC at a time when syndication meant those episodes would rerun endlessly on cable and broadcast networks. Its imprint on American culture wasn’t just deep—it was recursive.
“The Bris” is a top-tier example of how circumcision entered the comedic mainstream. Airing in 1993 as the fifth episode of the show’s fifth season, it lands almost exactly at the midpoint of Seinfeld’s first-run career—right when its influence was peaking.
In the episode, Jerry and Elaine agree to be godparents, which lands them at a newborn’s bris—cue Kramer denouncing circumcision as “mutilation,” and a neurotic, borderline-deranged mohel wielding the scalpel. The baby still gets cut, of course—because tradition must be upheld. Especially when it’s for laughs.
Kramer’s concern is portrayed as hysterical—his use of the word “mutilation” treated as comic exaggeration. But that outburst may have been the first time many viewers ever heard someone question circumcision at all. And just like that, dissent was reduced to a punchline.
For many Americans, this was their first time hearing the word “circumcision” on television—served with jokes, neuroses, and a casual shrug toward bodily autonomy.
Everyone watched Seinfeld. Everyone quoted Seinfeld.
It claimed to be a show about nothing. But was it?
We laughed so hard at the cartoonish depiction of the mohel… we never stopped to ask ourselves: Who was having the last laugh?
Friends (1994–2004)
If Seinfeld built the nineties blueprint for clever detachment, Friends made it cozy, palatable, and aspirational. The definitive sitcom of the era, its characters shaped beauty standards, gender dynamics, and relationship norms.
Anything it joked about became part of pop vernacular—including foreskin.
Set in a rent-controlled New York fantasyland, the show followed six impossibly attractive twenty-somethings as they navigated love, work, and what complicated coffee drink to order at Central Perk.
Over ten seasons and 236 episodes originally aired on NBC, Friends became one of the most-watched sitcoms in American history. It shaped how a generation thought about dating, desirability, gender roles—and yes, even anatomy.
✂️ Quick cut: If you’re enjoying this, become a paid subscriber. These essays take time to research and write—and your support keeps the scissors sharp.
Subscribe to follow the thread—from laugh tracks to foreskins to the emotional fallout we’re only just beginning to name.
In Season 8, Episode 3, “The One Where Rachel Tells Ross,” Phoebe unveils a musical number titled “The Ballad of the Uncircumcised Man.”
It’s played for laughs in a quick joke. Of course it is. Ross reacts with discomfort, and the entire concept is treated as quirky, vaguely European, and faintly embarrassing.
Foreskin is the punchline. Again.
While Friends rarely centered on religion, it quietly normalized a specific kind of Jewish-American identity—secular, upper-middle-class, and woven into the fabric of aspirational New York life.
Ross and Monica Geller weren’t presented as “the Jewish characters.” They simply were—subtly reinforcing Jewishness as part of the default landscape of educated, urban adulthood.
They felt familiar to millions of viewers. Their Jewishness wasn’t othered—it was a personality trait. In doing so, Friends helped quietly reinforce Jewish-American norms as part of the mainstream.
The show didn’t have to preach circumcision. It just had to make the uncircumcised man feel strange enough to laugh at—and present the people laughing as normal.
The result?
Viewers weren’t pushed toward tradition. They were pulled toward it, gently, by six beautiful friends with great hair and a joke for every occasion.
Sex and the City (1998–2004)
If Friends told women how to flirt, Sex and the City taught them how to sex. It set the tone for how sex was discussed on television—especially among women, and especially in cities. The series was bold, stylish, and brash. But it also reinforced plenty of assumptions about male desirability along the way.
In Season 4, Episode 8 (“My Motherboard, My Self”), Charlotte dates an uncircumcised man—and her friends react with a mix of shock, amusement, and performative curiosity. Samantha offers to “train him” sexually, treating the foreskin as an obstacle or at best, a kink to be overcome.
The episode doesn’t just mention foreskin. It exoticizes it. The man is treated like a sexual project, his body a novelty. The underlying message? The uncut penis isn’t normal—it’s something to manage.
In a show that was often hailed during its time as liberating, especially for female sexual autonomy, the foreskin storyline reminds us: liberation had its limits. And one of those limits, apparently, was anatomy that didn’t conform to the new American standard.
Curb Your Enthusiasm (2000–present)
If Seinfeld was neurotic, Curb is neurotic with a lawyer. It follows Larry David—playing a semi-fictionalized version of himself—as he bumbles through daily life, social expectations, and occasional existential meltdowns. It’s Jewish, cynical, self-aware—and sometimes surprisingly sharp.
Circumcision comes up multiple times in the show, usually through awkward conversations or tense interactions with rabbis. At one point, Larry questions whether his own circumcision was even necessary, only to be met with blank stares or aggressive rebuttals.
On the surface, these moments seem to edge toward subversion. But in the end, the question is always absorbed back into the humor. Larry gets shut down, ignored, or distracted. And the episode moves on.
Even in a show that regularly challenges social norms, the circumcision question is treated as just another of Larry’s many inappropriate tangents. Subversive? Maybe. But never enough to demonstrably shift the needle.
Arrested Development (2003–2006, revived later)
If Sex and the City glamorized urban sexuality, and Curb satirized Jewish neuroses, Arrested Development gave us a farcical takedown of privilege, dysfunction, and liberal guilt. It was sharp, chaotic, and way ahead of its time.
In Season 1, Episode 5 (“Charity Drive”), Lindsay Bluth jumps on the bandwagon of various social causes—including, notably, intactivism. She adopts the slogan “Save the Foreskins” as a kind of rich white woman performance piece. Her activism is shallow, performative, and totally mocked.
The effect? Arrested Development undermines the legitimacy of anti-circumcision advocacy by coding it as ridiculous and unserious. If you cared about foreskin, the show seemed to say, you were probably just another privileged narcissist looking for a cause to adopt.
It was satire, yes—but the damage was real. Because even when you mock the liberal elite, you’re still telling the audience that foreskin advocacy is for clowns.
The Laugh Track Is Still Playing
We laughed. We cringed. We shrugged it off.
But maybe we shouldn’t have. Because hidden inside those punchlines was a much sharper cultural message…
This core pantheon of zeitgeist-defining shows shaped humor, relationships, identity, and norms for millions of viewers—especially Gen X and elder Millennials.
The sitcoms may be off the air, but the laugh track is still playing in our heads.
The joke that foreskin is gross... still lives on.
And so does the assumption that cutting is normal.
Maybe it’s time we stop laughing—and start asking who made it a joke in the first place.
In the next episode, we’ll explore how the explosive rise of online pornography cemented the circumcised body as the visual standard—and turned desire into data.
Until then, I’m Lisa. And this… is The Hidden Cut—a series about what’s been removed, revised, and left on history’s cutting room floor.
Further Reading & Receipts
The following sources offer deeper context for the TV episodes, cultural commentary, and historical framing explored in “Late Night Jokes and Lost Skin.” Laughter may soften the blow—but it doesn't always heal the wound. Here’s where the jokes started, and where the silence was hiding.
Sitcoms & Episodes Referenced:
* Seinfeld, Season 5, Episode 5 – “The Bris”Aired October 14, 1993. Features Kramer’s “mutilation” outburst and the infamous mohel.https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0697661/
* Friends, Season 8, Episode 3 – “The One Where Rachel Tells Ross”Aired October 11, 2001. Includes Phoebe’s “Ballad of the Uncircumcised Man.”https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0583476/
* Sex and the City, Season 4, Episode 8 – “My Motherboard, My Self”Aired July 1, 2001. Charlotte dates an uncircumcised man; foreskin becomes a subplot.https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0698650/
* Curb Your Enthusiasm (multiple episodes)Ongoing themes of circumcision, awkwardly woven into Larry David’s identity crises.https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0264235/
* Arrested Development, Season 1, Episode 5 – “Charity Drive”Aired November 16, 2003. Lindsay joins a fictional foreskin activism campaign as satire.https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0515214/
Cultural Commentary & Criticism:
* “Something Ain't Kosher Here: The Rise of the 'Jewish' Sitcom” by Vincent Brook (2003)A deep dive into how Jewish identity shaped American sitcoms, including Seinfeld and Friends.https://www.amazon.com/Something-Aint-Kosher-Here-Jewish/dp/0813532116
* “A Mind of Its Own: A Cultural History of the Penis” by David M. Friedman (2002) While not exclusively about TV, this book offers cultural insight into how foreskin has been viewed across time and media.https://www.amazon.com/Mind-Its-Own-Cultural-History/dp/0684853205
* “Ilana Taught A Lesson On 'Broad City'” – BustleAn article that dissects Ilana’s joke about the Jewish circumcision practice of oral suction by the mohel (metzitzah b'peh), and also references Seinfeld’s “The Bris.”https://www.bustle.com/articles/155753-is-broad-citys-description-of-a-mohel-a-bris-real-ilana-had-a-lot-to
* “Foreskin Phobia: How The Intact Penis Has Been Shamed” – Intact America BlogA media-aware critique of foreskin representation in American pop culture.https://intactamerica.org/foreskin-phobia-intact-penis-shamed/
Observations & Social Impact:
* “It’s an inherent comfort zone’: why the American sitcom has endured” – The Guardian (2021)A review of the CNN docuseries History of the Sitcom.https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2021/jul/08/cnn-history-of-the-sitcom-why-it-endured
Think something got left on the cutting room floor? Add your notes below—we’re still editing in real time.
Get full access to Lisa Writes Now at lisawritesnow.substack.com/subscribe
More episodes from "Yo Soy Belinda: The Belinda The Housekeeper Story"
Don't miss an episode of “Yo Soy Belinda: The Belinda The Housekeeper Story” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.