Think Differently and Deeply Podcast podcast

"Between Skepticisms: Critical Thinking" featuring Troy Dahlke

0:00
35:45
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

What does it mean to teach students to think critically, and what happens when skepticism itself gets in the way of the pursuit of truth? In this episode of the Think Differently and Deeply podcast, host Glenn Whitman talks with Troy Dahlke, a philosophy and religion teacher at St. Andrew's Episcopal School, about the relationship between skepticism, critical thinking, and the pursuit of truth. A three-time contributor to Think Differently and Deeply, Dahlke shares how his experiences teaching philosophy and religion have shaped his understanding of what it means to help students become thoughtful, discerning learners.

Drawing on his latest article, the conversation explores how skepticism can be both an important component of critical thinking and a potential obstacle when it becomes disconnected from the pursuit of truth. Dahlke challenges educators to consider whether the critical thinking skills they teach are truly helping students make meaningful judgments about what is good and true. He also draws on the work of philosopher Hannah Arendt to explore the dangers of treating truth as subjective and the importance of helping students recognize that some ideas and actions are inherently wrong.

The conversation also examines the role of love, emotion, and intellectual curiosity in teaching and learning. Dahlke reflects on how caring deeply about both the subject matter and the students themselves shapes his approach to teaching, and why engaging students requires more than simply transferring knowledge. He also shares how his teaching has evolved over 20 years, including his decision to cover less content, spend more time with foundational texts, and create opportunities for students to engage more deeply with challenging ideas.

"When we are too skeptical of the truth, our skepticism is wrongly oriented. And therefore, our critical thinking skills are wrongly oriented." — Troy Dahlke.

What You'll Learn:

  • How Troy Dahlke's approach to teaching philosophy and religion has evolved over 20 years
  • Why having faith in the value of what you teach can help students engage with challenging material
  • The relationship between skepticism, critical thinking, and the pursuit of truth
  • Why critical thinking requires students to make judgments about what is good and true
  • How Hannah Arendt's work challenges educators to reconsider assumptions about truth and progress
  • Why teaching critical thinking skills without an orientation toward truth can be problematic
  • The role of love, emotion, and intellectual engagement in meaningful teaching and learning
  • How educators can examine the assumptions and unintended messages embedded in their teaching
  • Why teachers should consider whether the skills they develop could be used in service of harmful ideologies
  • How narrowing the scope of course content can create opportunities for deeper learning

"I think in some way one of the tricks of good learning is getting kids to find something that's valuable and they don't know that it's valuable." — Troy Dahlke.

—

SUBSCRIBE TO THINK DIFFERENTLY & DEEPLY ON iTUNES/APPLE PODCASTS: https://apple.co/3JCpK1u

And to support our work, please leave us a 5-star review with your feedback on iTunes/Apple Podcasts.

LEARN MORE ABOUT THIS EPISODE: https://www.thecttl.org

———————————

CONNECT WITH US!

———————————

FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/CTTLatSAES

LINKEDIN: https://www.linkedin.com/company/the-cttl

TWITTER: https://twitter.com/TheCTTL

INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/thecttl

More episodes from "Think Differently and Deeply Podcast"