
Three women. Three centuries. Real stories with a feminine twist.
In the final episode of our Halloween Storytelling Trilogy, we head to Corstorphine, Edinburgh, where a sycamore tree once marked the spot where James Forrester was killed. Local legend says a woman dressed in white still haunts the area. In one telling, she's pining for the man she killed. But who decided that was what she was waiting for?
The woman behind the ghost story was Christian Nimmo. In 1679, she was convicted of killing James, the 2nd Lord Forrester, with his own sword. She escaped custody, was recaptured and was executed by the Maiden, Scotland's early beheading machine. One historical account called her a woman of "godless life". That judgement tells us something about the man who wrote it, too.
So what do we know about James? He was older than Christian, her uncle by marriage and the man who succeeded to the Forrester title and estate through arrangements tied to his marriage into the family. He may have known Christian when she was growing up. We don't know when their relationship began or what happened in private, but the age gap, family connection and his position make it worth asking how much freedom she had. Could a story passed down as a lovers' quarrel have involved coercion or grooming? Could Christian have been trying to get away from him?
And there's a detail that changes how you might hear the whole story. According to a surviving account, Christian said James came at her with his sword and that she took it from him to protect herself. Her account was dismissed. Lulu and Mary revisit that moment through a modern feminist lens. What would we need to know to distinguish between murder, manslaughter and self-defence? And how much did what people thought of Christian shape what they were willing to believe?
Five takeaways from this episode
-
The ghost story gives Christian a motive of its own. The idea that she still pines for James tells us how the legend imagines her feelings. We have very little access to what she actually felt.
-
James's position deserves a closer look. His age, title and place in Christian's family raise questions about who had power in the relationship and what choices were open to her.
-
Christian gave an account of self-defence. The surviving record preserves her claim that James came at her with his sword, even as it dismisses it. That gives us another version of the encounter to consider.
-
"Godless" is a judgement about character. How readily do we let a description of a woman's morals shape what we believe about her actions?
-
You can question the ghost and the story attached to her. Why has the image of a woman longing for her lover endured, while her claim that she feared for her safety is so easily forgotten?
Resource mentioned: Kate Foster, The Maiden, a historical novel inspired by Christian Nimmo's case.
Please like and share this episode, and help us bring these women's stories into the conversation.
More episodes from "She Rebel Radio"



Don't miss an episode of “She Rebel Radio” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








