
The loudest animal on Earth shouts while it hunts. Killer whales that hunt seals stay silent. Why would one hunter shout and another hold its tongue?
It comes down to one fact about sound: a call goes one way to the listener, but its echo has to make the round trip back. So every ping you send to find your prey also tells your prey about you, and how loud you can afford to be depends on who's listening. We start with bats that turned out to be shouting, and a moth that hears a loud bat long before the bat can find it, then see engineers hit the same wall with radar, and German U-boats that switched off their own detectors. We test the rule on a sperm whale whose prey is barely listening, a bat that whispers, killer whales that go silent, submarines that mostly listen, beaked whales that rise without a sound, and Hawaiian crickets that went quiet in about five years once a fly started hunting them by ear. Then the chase: moths that swerve, bats that steer, and a desert tiger moth that jams bat sonar. Moths had ears long before there were bats to hear, and on bat-free islands they kept the ears but lost the flinch. Last, the noise that's ours: traffic, shipping that fills the low range right whales call in, and navy sonar, which sets off the beaked whales' escape plan for killer whales. Noise stops when we stop, and in the Canary Islands, turning it down seems to have worked.
Chapters
00:00 Cold open
01:58 Welcome
02:38 Part one: bats that shout
04:41 Part one: the listener hears first
06:49 Part one: radar and U-boats
09:04 Part two: shout when nobody is listening
12:27 Part two: whisper
14:09 Part two: go silent
17:02 Part two: submarines and quiet radar
18:25 Part two: beaked whales go quiet
19:29 Part two: the cricket that went quiet
22:45 Part three: the chase
25:42 Part three: talking back
27:12 Where the ears came from
28:43 The flinch: take the bats away
29:54 Slow and fast
30:37 Part four: when the noise is ours
34:00 Part four: our ping
37:37 Close
Sounds
- Sperm whale clicks and creak: NOAA (public domain)
- Bat calls and feeding buzz, slowed ten times: "Bat feeding buzz" by Kaldari (CC0)
- Fish-eating killer whales, Glacier Bay, Alaska: National Park Service (public domain)
- Pacific field cricket: Natural History Museum, London, recordist W. J. Reynolds (CC BY 3.0)
- Large ship underwater: NOAA Fisheries (public domain)
- Sonar ping: re-created for this episode
Music
- "Warm Fingers" and "One Little Triumph" (Piano Mover) and "Dibbled" (Thimble Rider) by Blue Dot Sessions (CC BY-NC 4.0), sessions.blue
- Theme: royalty-free intro track
Key sources
Griffin 1944 Science; Goerlitz et al. 2010 Curr Biol; Skolnik 2001; NSA SRH-025; Fais et al. 2016 Sci Rep; Watwood et al. 2006 J Anim Ecol; Mooney et al. 2010 J Exp Biol; Barrett-Lennard et al. 1996 and Deecke et al. 2005 Anim Behav; Deecke et al. 2002 Nature; Aguilar de Soto et al. 2020 Sci Rep; Zuk et al. 2006 Biol Lett; Tinghitella et al. 2018 Am Nat; Hartley 1992 JASA; Ghose et al. 2006 PLoS Biol; Corcoran & Conner 2016 J Exp Biol; Corcoran et al. 2009 Science; Kawahara et al. 2019 PNAS; Fullard et al. 2004 J Evol Biol; Siemers & Schaub 2011 Proc R Soc B; Tennessen et al. 2024 Glob Change Biol; McDonald et al. 2006 JASA; Hatch et al. 2012 Conserv Biol; Rolland et al. 2012 Proc R Soc B; Tyack et al. 2011 PLoS ONE; NOAA/Navy Bahamas report 2001; Bernaldo de Quirós et al. 2019 Proc R Soc B; Fernández et al. 2013 Nature.
More episodes from "Relatively Human: Fundamental Laws of Biology and Physics"



Don't miss an episode of “Relatively Human: Fundamental Laws of Biology and Physics” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








