Leading Quality podcast

Quality Planning: Making Room for What Matters

0:00
54:55
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Why This Episode Matters

Healthcare organizations can run successful improvement projects while leaving the conditions that undermine their results untouched. Executives pursue competing priorities, governance processes underperform, and middle managers receive requests they cannot reconcile. Clinical teams are then expected to deliver improvements that last. Drawing on her work with health systems through IHI, Jennifer Lenoci-Edwards argues that these difficulties require attention to quality planning alongside improvement methodology. Her distinction between strategic, structural, and clinical variation helps explain why an organization can achieve promising project results yet find itself addressing the same problems three years later. The leadership challenge is to negotiate shared priorities, understand what patients and staff need, and arrange the structures and support that make execution possible. It is also to recognize when leaders’ own decisions are contributing to the confusion they want frontline teams to overcome.

Key Ideas Explored

  • Clinical variation is only one part of the improvement problem. Jennifer’s framework also identifies strategic variation—leaders pursuing different agendas—and structural variation, where governance, peer review, root cause analysis, and huddles fail to function effectively. She argues that unresolved problems in these areas weaken the sustainability and spread of clinical gains.
  • Quality planning requires concessions, not just agreement that everything matters. Executives must negotiate what they will prioritize collectively and what they will relinquish. Shared direction does not require every department to contribute equally to every target: a maternity service may have little contribution to an organization’s mortality goal while retaining legitimate improvement priorities of its own.
  • A well-designed process can conceal a critical failure in practice. Jennifer describes an impressive escalating huddle system in which the most serious problems never reached the CEO because staff were nervous about escalating them. The existence of a structure says little about whether it delivers the information leaders most need.
  • Dashboard colors can create consequences without demonstrating change. Jennifer recalls a colleague describing red and green reporting as “pizza party or punch in the nose.” Without examining data over time and distinguishing common from special cause variation, organizations can alternate between celebration and criticism while the underlying process remains unchanged.
  • Knowing the strategy does not guarantee having a role in it. While working in an emergency department, Jennifer recognized a patient’s connection to a population health initiative but had no defined contribution to make. Middle managers and frontline teams need clarity about their role, relevant evidence, and usable improvement tools; additional meetings alone do not provide that connection.

Takeaways for Quality Leaders

  • Before commissioning another project, ask which supporting arrangements need to change: who must work together, what tools are missing, and how successful changes will enter quality control.
  • Prepare for priority-setting with evidence about regulatory requirements, contractual commitments, patient experience, and workforce needs. Which proposed priorities reflect those needs, and which primarily reflect an executive’s interests?
  • Trace a serious concern through your escalation process. Where might it stop, and what response do people anticipate from the next leader?
  • Give middle managers enough improvement knowledge to question requests constructively: does this result suggest special cause variation, and is the requested action likely to produce a meaningful change?

Continue the Conversation

Jennifer Lenoci-Edwards on LinkedIn

Resources & Frameworks Referenced

  • Three types of variation: Strategic, structural, and clinical variation.
  • Whole System Quality: IHI white paper informing the organizational assessment rubric Jennifer describes.
  • Model for Improvement and PDSA: Improvement approaches referenced in the discussion of clinical projects and iterative learning.
  • Quality planning, quality improvement, and quality control: Connecting priority-setting, execution, and sustained performance.

Leading Quality is a podcast for healthcare leaders committed to improving systems, culture, and outcomes.

If you found this episode valuable, follow the show, rate and review the podcast, or share it with a colleague working to improve care.

Connect with Jason Meadows on LinkedIn for more insights on healthcare quality and leadership.

New episodes published every other Thursday at 7AM Eastern Time.

Credits:

Host, Writer, and Executive Producer
Jason Meadows, MD

Produced by
Thrive Healthcare Improvement

Edited by
Milan Milosavljevic

More episodes from "Leading Quality"