Highlands Current Audio Stories podcast

Saint Basil Files for Bankruptcy

0:00
5:19
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds
Philipstown school seeks shield from abuse cases
Saint Basil Academy in Philipstown filed for bankruptcy on Nov. 13, temporarily halting trials in two of the five lawsuits in which adults allege that they were sexually abused as children by its clergy or staff.
A federal bankruptcy judge on Tuesday (Nov. 17) paused a trial scheduled to start that day in a lawsuit against Saint Basil and the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America by an Illinois man who claims abuse by the Rev. Philip Koutoufas, a former director at the school. Proceedings in that case and a second set for jury selection on Nov. 30 are stopped until at least Dec. 1.
Saint Basil, which operates programs for children, young adults and single mothers with children at its 100-acre campus off Route 9D, is seeking a delay of at least four months in all five cases, saying it faces "an existential threat" because it "lacks the financial capacity to satisfy potential judgments."
After declaring in the bankruptcy filing that both its assets and liabilities range from $1 million to $10 million, the academy said that it failed to reach a settlement with all five plaintiffs during a mediation session on Nov. 4 and that the plaintiffs rejected a settlement proposed on Nov. 12.
Giving Saint Basil more time, according to court documents, will allow it to "avoid depletion of estate assets and to foster an environment in which all parties in interest can engage in meaningful settlement negotiations regarding a consensual resolution" to the lawsuits.

In response to the bankruptcy filing, the New York County judge overseeing the two paused cases and a third one set for jury selection in January initially ordered Tuesday's trial to proceed without Saint Basil. But the school claimed in its bankruptcy filing that even trying the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese alone could result in findings that could be used against it because its executive director, Father Constantine Sitaras, has been subpoenaed to testify.
In extending the delay to the archdiocese, bankruptcy Judge Kyu Paek said, "The balance of hardships tips in the debtor's favor." He added that his temporary order "preserves all claims of all parties and releases no claim against any party."
Those claims, by the woman and four men suing Saint Basil and the archdiocese, date to the 1980s. The Illinois man, who also names the Greek Orthodox Ladies Philoptochos Society as a defendant, alleges that his abuse by Koutoufas began in 1986, when he was 4 and taken in the director's truck off campus at night. Koutoufas parked underneath a nearby bridge and began fondling his genitals and kissing him, said the man. The abuse continued for years, he alleges, with Koutoufas taking him from a dorm two to three times a week.
His trial was to be followed on Nov. 30 by that of a New York woman who says she entered Saint Basil in 1983, when she was 10. While riding with Koutoufas in a truck after class, according to court documents, she asked the priest why he believed in God. He allegedly stopped the truck, took her to the base of a tree and "explained the miraculous nature of the transformation of a tiny seed into a large tree."
When she doubted his explanation, Koutoufas "responded by calling her a nonbeliever with a demon inside of her that needed to be exorcised" and then sexually assaulted her, according to court documents. She said the abuse continued five more times in the woods, as well as in his office.
She said that the school's practice of letting students stay with host families led to further assaults by males on Long Island and in Brooklyn. One male raped her in 1985, when she was 12, she alleges, and two assaulted her when she was 14.
A third trial scheduled to begin in January concerns allegations by Christopher Bowen, a Pennsylvania resident who alleges abuse by a former teacher and dorm supervisor, Finley Everett Eubanks. His abuse, said Bowen, occurred between 1983 and 1986, when he was 12 to 15 years old.

Eubanks, who died i...

More episodes from "Highlands Current Audio Stories"