Health Coaching and Beyond podcast

Episode 40 - Finding Consistency Without Losing Personalisation

0:00
37:49
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Summary

In this episode, Ollie is joined by Peak Health's Education Director, Dr Caroline Hart, to explore a question facing the growing health coaching profession: how can we establish consistent standards while keeping health coaching truly person-centred?

Their conversation is prompted by a recently published paper from New Zealand, which reviews 76 health coaching studies conducted between 2013 and 2023. The findings highlight considerable variation in how health coaching is delivered, who provides it and what training practitioners receive. Perhaps more importantly, the research reveals how inconsistently these details are reported, making it difficult to compare approaches and understand what really works.

Ollie and Caroline reflect on what this means for the development of health coaching in the UK. They discuss the importance of recognised qualifications, competency frameworks and external quality assurance, while considering the progress already made through NHS England's Health and Wellbeing Coach Workforce Development Framework.

But standardisation brings its own challenges. If health coaching is fundamentally about responding to individual needs, how do we establish shared principles without becoming overly prescriptive? Caroline explores the importance of maintaining individual agency and ensuring that consistency never comes at the expense of flexibility and personalisation.

The conversation also draws on Ollie's recent experience at an Individual Placement and Support conference, where he was struck by the role that fidelity to a clearly defined model has played in improving outcomes for people experiencing serious mental health difficulties. Could health coaching learn something from this more established approach?

Takeaways

  • Health coaching is growing internationally, but approaches to delivery, training and evaluation remain inconsistent.
  • A review of 76 studies highlights significant gaps in how health coaching interventions are described and reported.
  • Without clear information about training, methods and delivery, it becomes difficult to compare research findings and understand outcomes.
  • Consistent standards are important, but health coaching must remain flexible and responsive to individual needs.
  • The NHS Health and Wellbeing Coach Workforce Development Framework provides a foundation for developing and assessing practitioner competencies.
  • Recognised qualifications, external scrutiny and quality assurance can help strengthen confidence in health coaching practice.
  • Person-centred care means protecting individual agency, rather than allowing frameworks to become overly practitioner-led.
  • The success of Individual Placement and Support (IPS) offers valuable lessons about the relationship between fidelity to a model and effective outcomes.
  • Stronger evaluation, research and shared definitions are needed as health coaching continues to develop.
  • International collaboration could help establish common standards while recognising different cultural and healthcare contexts.
  • The challenge for the profession is to identify the core principles of effective health coaching without losing the adaptability that makes it valuable.

Further Reading

The research paper discussed by Ollie and Caroline in this episode, can be found in the Journal of Primary Health Care. Implementing Health Coaching for People With Long-Term Conditions, Caroline Stretton, Antonia Rosedale, Angela C. Davenport, Julie Pryor. https://connectsci.au/hc/article/doi/10.1071/HC26082/278819/Implementing-health-coaching-for-people-with-long

More episodes from "Health Coaching and Beyond"