
The Math Behind America's Data Center Buildout Doesn't Add Up | Susan Luschas
"I didn't realize we were already oversized for what we need. I would love to know what we're building this overcapacity for if it's not for a digital surveillance and control grid."
A White Paper: "Data Centers: What do we need all this data for? A Mathematical Analysis"
Susan Luschas and her husband Manuel Luschas, authors of the white paper "Data Centers: What do we need all this data for? A Mathematical Analysis"1, are both electrical engineers.
Susan has a PhD from MIT in electrical engineering and she worked on some of the first WiFi, Bluetooth and cell phone chips in Silicon Valley. Later, she worked as a professor at Santa Clara University.
Manuel worked for many years on digital highspeed data communication devices for data centers in Silicon Valley.
In 2020, during the height of the Pandemic, they left California and moved to South Dakota so that their daughters could go to school in person and without having to wear facemasks.
Just yesterday, in the midterm elections, Manuel won one of the two South Dakota House District 2 seats.
Why They Wrote the White PaperIn early 2026 Susan Luschas gave a talk to a local group in South Dakota about the importance of cash in preventing the creation of a totalitarian control grid made possible through a large number of hyperscale data centers.
Afterwards, a South Dakotan asked her why she is so sure that data centers are meant for surveillance and control.
She gave him an answer - but she wasn't happy with it:
"I told him: 'Because I worked in Silicon Valley and, between me and my husband, we've helped build these things.'
"And then in hindsight, I realized that's not really a great answer. 'Believe me' is not really a great answer.
"And then I thought, well, I can mathematically prove it to him. And we were in a room with a whiteboard, and I thought, I can mathematically prove this to him. And then I thought, it'd probably take me a bunch of assumptions that may not make sense to him. And it will take maybe an hour or two.
"And then I thought, maybe instead I'll write a white paper and then I'll have it all referenced. He can see exactly where I got my numbers from for my assumptions. He can check my math and he can tell me where the math is wrong.
"I know as a tech person that these numbers don't add up. We don't need this much data center processing power for our everyday."
CHAPTERS
00:05 Why a White Paper Can Prove the Data Center Buildout
01:59 Two Electrical Engineering PhDs Behind the Math
04:38 An Open Invitation to Find a Mistake
06:28 Measuring Everything in Watts
08:20 Table One: Which Digital Activities Count
12:02 Insignificant Data Sources Moved to the Appendix
15:49 Reading the Numbers: Streaming, AI, Self-Driving Cars
19:39 Crypto Mining Outweighs Worst-Case Streaming
22:59 How Much Energy Do AI Tasks Really Use
31:46 Watts Versus Watt-Hours Explained
34:03 Daily AI Use Versus Total Digital Demand
35:48 Why Military Data Stays Off Commercial Data Centers
40:06 Table Two: Existing Capacity Is Triple the Need
44:53 Idle Capacity and the Mousetrap Theory
47:38 South Dakota: 32 Megawatts, Almost All Crypto
52:03 2030 Forecasts: 148 Gigawatts Nationally, 23 Times More in South Dakota
54:55 Table Three: Every Data Center in South Dakota
56:43 Why the Berkeley Lab Forecast Leaves Out Crypto
1:00:53 Local Projects: A 50-Megawatt AI Site and a 500-Megawatt Site Under NDA
1:03:19 Where Will the Electricity Come From
1:05:00 Testing Other Explanations: AI Growth, Biometrics, Tokenization
1:09:35 The Utopia Scenario: A Three-Terawatt Control Grid
1:17:37 Utopia Versus 2030 Capacity
1:20:45 What a Partial Control System Would Require
1:23:07 Data Centers by Country
1:26:36 What China's Social Credit System Actually Is
1:31:29 Does "Keeping Up With China" Hold Up?
1:34:12 Artificial General Intelligence and Edge Computing
1:38:24 Reader Feedback So Far
1:40:19 Taxpayer Funding and Circular Financing
1:43:44 The Next Paper: Why the Financial Numbers Don't Work
1:47:03 What Zoning Boards Can Do
1:49:45 Cities and Counties That Have Banned Data Centers
1:55:20 Building Bans From the Bottom Up
RESOURCES
-
To email Susan with ideas, suggestions and corrections: [email protected]
-
Susan and Manuel Luschas: Data Centers: What do we need all this data for? A Mathematical Analysis
-
Cities, Counties, and States That Banned Data Centers; email Susan at [email protected] if you know of additional bans: https://content.campaignpartner.net/images/149540/County_and_City_Bans_on_Data_Centers_V3.pdf
-
15 minute movie 'Utopia'
More episodes from "Flashlights"



Don't miss an episode of “Flashlights” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








