
Today, we’re speaking to Dr Vicki Wesh and Dr Claire Burton about the paper they’ve published here in the BJGP alongside co-first authors Alice Faux-Nightingale and Rosie Harrison.
Title of paper: Why Primary Care Clinicians use Advice and Guidance: A qualitative study
Available at: https://doi.org/10.3399/BJGP.2026.0217
Advice and Guidance (A&G), introduced in 2015, enables primary care clinicians to obtain specialist input for patients within elective care pathways without initiating a formal referral; the proposed 2026/27 GP Contract aims to expand or mandate its use in line with the NHS ten-year plan and strategic efforts to move more care from hospitals into the community.
• Our findings suggest clinicians decide to engage with A&G when they can expect timely, high-quality responses that support safe management of sometimes clinically complex patients.
• Primary Care Clinicians are also sensitive to the risks of inappropriate transfer of workload from secondary to primary care, clinical responsibility for conditions traditionally managed in secondary care, and associated costs into primary care, and that these concerns directly influence their willingness to use A&G.
• Ensuring that electronic A&G systems support transparent, two-way communication and maintain visibility for both primary and secondary care teams may therefore improve usability and sustain clinician engagement.
Transcript
This transcript was generated using AI and has not been reviewed for accuracy. Please be aware it may contain errors or omissions.
Speaker A
00:00:01.600 - 00:01:03.060
Hi and welcome to BJGP Interviews.
I'm Nada Khan and I'm the Senior Research editor here at the bjgp.
Thanks for listening to today's podcast.
In today's episode, we're talking to Dr. Vicki Welsh and Dr. Claire Burton about the paper they've published here in the bjgp.
They've published this alongside co first authors Alice Vo Nightingale and Rosie Harrison, and the paper is titled why Primary Care Clinicians Use Advice and A Qualitative Study.
So thanks very much for joining me, both of you, and it's a really interesting paper and it's highly topical, I think, in today's primary care setting.
Just thinking about how we're using advice and guidance and Claire, I wonder if I could just come to you first and I wonder if you could just start by giving us a bit of an overview of what advice and guidance is meant to offer and maybe also just about how you want to explore how primary care clinicians actually use it.
Speaker B
00:01:03.300 - 00:02:03.040
Advice and guidance is essentially a process that allows primary care clinicians, so we use that term inclusively to include GPs, advanced nurse practitioners, physicians, associates and anyone else in the primary care setting who might be using advice and guidance to seek formalised advice from specialists.
So usually consultants in a secondary care setting around the care of their patients.
So it doesn't necessitate a formal or full elective referral, but it goes through usually the electronic referral system, which means that the question that is being asked and the response that is being given is formalised and can be fed back to patients and used in the process of care.
So I suppose, you know, 20 years ago we'd have been picking up the phone or emailing our colleagues, but this has become, since 2015, a more formalised process that can be used as an option when seeking specialist advice.
Speaker A
00:02:03.600 - 00:02:11.200
Yeah.
And Vicky, you were just going to also tell us a little bit about why you wanted to look at how primary care clinicians actually use it in practice.
Speaker C
00:02:11.920 - 00:02:59.720
So, as gps, Clare and I have had mixed experiences in our own practice of using advice and guidance.
Sometimes it can be really helpful, sometimes less so.
And we were aware back in 2022, 23, when we wrote this research project, that advice and guidance was being increasingly used by our specialist colleagues, but there was no real evidence base to support the best use of advice and guidance.
So we designed this badger study, along with our CO applicants, to develop an evidence base, really, to help us, as an NHS system, make best use of this advice and guidance service.
Speaker A
00:03:00.360 - 00:03:33.960
Yeah, fair enough.
So in this project you conducted 20 semi structured interviews with primary care clinicians from 20 practices across the Northwest and West Midlands.
And really, you just explored their experiences of using advice and guidance.
And I think it's really interesting that your findings suggest that clinicians don't use advice and guidance for every patient or in every situation, really.
But I wonder what your thoughts were from the interviews about what people thought made it useful and when a direct referral might be more appropriate.
Speaker B
00:03:34.840 - 00:03:39.000
So, again, I just wonder if it might be best to contextualize these interviews.
Sure,.
Speaker C
00:03:39.160 - 00:03:39.640
Yeah.
Speaker B
00:03:39.720 - 00:05:56.320
This wasn't a standalone study, so this was part of a much wider, as Vicky mentioned, study that we call Badger.
So building an evidence base for the use of advice and guidance across the primary secondary care interface.
So as well as interviewing primary care clinicians, we also interviewed secondary care clinicians and patients and commissioners, which is part of a separate piece of published work, or hopefully published work.
So this paper is very much focusing on understanding the clinical reasoning behind using advice and guidance from the primary care perspective.
And following the analysis of the interviews, we came out with four sort of overarching themes which were around advice and guidance being used, dependent on clinical presentation, so acuity and complexity.
So I think we heard from gps, quite understandably that, you know, if somebody was incredibly unwell and needed acute admission, then that would be done, and if it was a clear need for a referral, then that would be done.
So advice and guidance was being used in these cases where it was felt that a full formalised elective referral wasn't necessary or might not be necessary.
And it was perhaps at the sort of edge of what can be done in primary care or should be done in primary care or within the skillsets of primary care.
But it was also being used to navigate healthcare pathways which are ever changing.
And the other things that were sort of influencing use was previous experience.
So clinicians who had very positive experiences were more likely to use it again.
And that could be kind of specialty specific.
It wasn't just a general rule.
And it was also used in a sort of more nuanced way around validating clinical decision making and to really support patients.
So if patients felt that they needed the input of a specialist and there was any sort of degree of uncertainty, then sometimes it was also used to provide effective reassurance to patients if there was maybe some disagreement or conflicts in the need for that referral.
Speaker A
00:05:56.720 - 00:06:12.480
Yeah, and I wonder if we could just unpick some of those themes a bit further.
So you talked about how clinicians used advice and guidance to navigate complicated healthcare pathways.
And could you give us an idea of how that would work in practice?
So what sort of examples would that suggest?
Speaker B
00:06:13.600 - 00:07:20.720
So, I think when it comes to referral, there are obviously some very sort of objective times when a referral needs to be made.
So if the patient is presenting with symptoms that need to be fast tracked on a T rek cancer pathway, then that's very clear.
And then there are some other diagnoses that we know require specialist input to make.
But sometimes, particularly if the systems around the practice are changing, so, you know, different clinics in different settings being provided by different groups, advice and guidance can just help ensure that a referral that is potentially being made is made to the right place to save time and increase efficiency.
And, yeah, that's really quite supportive of the SPO model, isn't it, that there is a single point of access into the specialist healthcare system.
So we did hear from clinicians that it was being used to navigate this.
I guess the other important thing is to just contextualise the landscape that these interviews were taking place in, because these interviews happened at a bit of a crossover period, before Spiro was a thing.
Speaker A
00:07:21.200 - 00:07:39.920
Yeah.
And I guess that's one thing to mention that advice and guidance is sort of a bigger part of the policy direction for general practice in England and sort of has a more embedded use in the sort of recent GP contract.
So do you have any thoughts about its shift towards wider use, given the work that you've been doing more broadly about advice and guidance?
Speaker...
More episodes from "BJGP Interviews"



Don't miss an episode of “BJGP Interviews” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








