The Science of Learning podcast

Why Students Learn More When They Fail: Manu Kapur on Productive Failure

0:00
47:37
Spola tillbaka 15 sekunder
Spola framåt 15 sekunder

What if struggling with a problem before you know how to solve it actually helps you learn? My guest is Manu Kapur, the learning scientist who developed the influential concept of productive failure. His research challenges one of our most common assumptions about teaching: that the best way to help students learn something new is to explain it clearly first, and then have them practice it, repeat it, apply it, and give them feedback on whether they do it right or wrong. 

Watch the full video interview on YouTube: https://youtu.be/kvAhZuuxNCg

Kapur's research suggests that, for complex concepts, it can be more effective to reverse that sequence. In his productive failure pedagogical designs, students first explore a carefully designed problem that they don't yet know how to solve. It's a hard problem, and they struggle. They'll often go down an incorrect path or a dead end. The teacher then explains the expert solution and how that is related to their own experiments and struggles. The initial struggle activates students' prior knowledge and prepares them to understand the instruction at a deeper level.

In our conversation, we discuss: 

  • why getting the right answer isn't necessarily the same as understanding;
  • why the timing of instruction matters;
  • and why struggle, mistakes, and even failure can be powerful parts of learning.

Kapur explains what productive failure looks like in an actual classroom, using examples from mathematics including standard deviation, calculus, and linear algebra. He also describes research showing that relatively small changes to instruction can produce substantial improvements in student learning. In one university mathematics course, inserting Productive Failure activities before just ten major concepts increased the passing rate from about 55 percent to 75 percent. We also explore a broader lesson about learning: if something is always easy, you may not be learning very much.

Productive failure doesn't mean simply letting people fail. Kapur emphasizes that these learning experiences must be deliberately designed, psychologically safe, and followed by expert instruction. The goal is to create low-stakes opportunities for productive struggle so that learners develop deeper understanding—and are less likely to fail when the stakes are high. 

We also discuss whether productive failure can work outside mathematics and science, where Kapur originally developed the approach. We talk about how it can be used in workplace learning and apprenticeships, and what athletes, mathematicians, surgeons, and pilots can teach us about learning through struggle. 

The Science of Learning is hosted by learning scientist Keith Sawyer and features conversations with leading researchers about what science tells us about how people learn. 

Subscribe to The Science of Creativity Substack newsletter: https://keithsawyer.substack.com/

Watch the full video interview on YouTube: https://youtu.be/kvAhZuuxNCg 

Music by license from SoundStripe: 

  • "Uptown Lovers Instrumental" by AFTERNOONZ
  • "Miss Missy" by AFTERNOONZ
  • "What's the Big Deal" by Ryan Saranich

Copyright ©️2026 Keith Sawyer

Fler avsnitt från "The Science of Learning"